06/07/2026
Did anyone get a chance to stop by the bake stand yesterday and try this week’s Mystery Flavor Cookie? 🍌🍪
If not, you missed out on Nana’s Banana Puddin’ Cookie — a soft, banana-packed cookie inspired by the classic dessert we all know and love! 💛
Don’t worry if you missed it… the porch pop-up will be back on Saturday, June 20th, from 9 AM–3 PM, with another brand-new Mystery Flavor Cookie making its debut! 🎉
Now I’m curious… what do YOU think the next mystery flavor should be? 🤔
And if you’ve got any wild, crazy, over-the-top cookie flavor combinations bouncing around in your head, drop them in the comments! ⬇️ You never know — your idea might just become the next tasty treat at Sugar on the Shelf! 🍪✨
Let’s hear those flavor ideas!