09/13/2026
The Kitchen Disasters section on the blog has been sitting empty for a while, mostly because I’ve been suppressing the evidence. Not anymore.
Back in 2010, I had a carrot cake I trusted (Sharon’s; it has never once failed me). Then I let a baking challenge talk me into a fancier version, and I walked away from the sure thing to chase it. It baked flat and dense and rubbery. And instead of admitting defeat, I frosted it and photographed it like I was interviewing for a job at a food magazine.
The photos look incredible. The cake was a rubber impression of a cake. Here’s the whole story, and the lesson I actually took from it: karacooks.com/carrot-cake-fail
I had a carrot cake that never failed me, then chased a fancier one. It baked flat, dense, and rubbery. I frosted it and shot it like a magazine anyway.