05/26/2026
Thick Boyz Only. When it comes to steaks, that’s the mantra. Here’s how to take an entire strip loin and cut your own New York Strip Steaks at home.
You can find these at your local wholesale store, Costco, etc. Heck, your local butcher or grocery store can probably swing a whole roast your way if you can’t find it readily available.
Method: it’s right there in the opener. I wanted to cut these steaks thick, 1.5 inches to be precise. Why? They were cooked via the reverse sear method in an oven and on the smoker. The thicker the steak, the more evenly it cooks during this method. When searing, a thick steak can adequately take enough heat to achieve a sear without overcooking internally. Plus, if I’m gonna do all this work & eat a steak..like, I want a dang big boy steak.
Trim off any undesirable bits that might be hanging off or silverskin that you probably don’t want to bite into during your steak dinner. I also faced the end of the roast before cutting the steaks (not necessary, but makes it look nicer if you care). All this trim was saved and is going into the next ground beef situation.
A few tricks: mark the desired thickness with a piece of tape. It takes the guesswork out of it until you’re comfortable eyeballing it. Use the back of a knife to basically make a cut line that is in line with the measurement. It’s easy to follow before the cutting starts.
Storage: Vac seal these for long term freezing. Or, whenever your vac sealer craps out because of course it will, toss em in tried & true freezer ziplocks and call it good.
The Numbers:
Starting Weight: 15.88LB
Cost: $161.82
Trim: 2.45lb
Trim Cost: $24.97
Final Trimmed Strip Loin: 13.43
Yield: 9 Steaks @ 1.5 in. Thick
Average Steak Weight: 1.5lbs
Average steak cost: $15.29 per steak
Steaks this size are easily enough for a two person steak dinner (I mean yeah one hungry human too for sure). Whether you hammer it down solo or it’s shared, the cost per steak is still pretty dang good compared to a night out on the town for a steak dinner. Plus, now you know you can have a bulk batch of these made up, frozen & ready at a moments notice!