02/23/2025
Our own journey has also gone into and then beyond Natural Horsemanship. When you know better, do better. There is SO MUCH to learn.
What happened to Natural Horsemanship?
Well, it is still around. That thing is still thinging. There are folks working with it that do good work for good people, all around the globe. But for some of us, it was not enough.
For some of us, we found Natural Horsemanship at a time when it appeared to be a valid alternative. The alternative to just, getting on and riding, the alternative to methods that ignored the way horses thought. Ten, fifteen even twenty years ago, to utter the words "Natural Horsemanship" in some equestrian environments was enough to make your heart beat with fear. Fear of being seen as a weirdo, of social exclusion, of being dismissed by people who thought it was rubbish, felt it challenged their business or world view, or thought it undermined traditional training.
Somewhere between then and now, at least in the eyes of the people I know, Natural Horsemanship has found its way into the category of "traditional practices".
It is the big pink elephant in the room. Name any celebrity horse trainer today, and you can point to a part of their history where Natural Horsemanship influenced them. Some are talking about it. Some are pretending that never happened.
Blackballing the mentors and ideas of your past does not make them go away.
If we, as innovative horse people today, are walking, it is because Natural Horsemanship crawled. They pioneered a way forwards that alternative practices could not only be "effective" but also be a successful business model too.
So, where is Natural Horsemanship today? This page is called Emotional Horsemanship. And to many, that lumps me in the Natural Horsemanship category. I remember declining a clinic invitation because they asked for a Natural Horsemanship clinic. Still, as recent as my last clinic tour, and as recent as the very last lesson I taught (25 minutes ago), I am approached by people who remark with surprise that what we are teaching with Emotional Horsemanship is really NOT natural horsemanship, according to how we imagine it.
"It really is something different!" Someone said at a clinic. I giggled, because I am been trying to tell you all. But sometimes you just gotta see it for yourself.
I am very grateful for the Natural Horsemanship pioneers. I won't list them by name. But I am grateful for the doors they opened. I am also grateful for the ways that their monopoly of the industry has divided up into tens of thousands of smaller businesses, rather than 1-2 huge conglomerates. It was the democratic evolution of their innovation... that it eventually was de-centred away from powerful men, and into the hands of smaller communities.
But just like you, there came a moment when I was practicing, teaching and training with Natural Horsemanship techniques and principles, that I stopped myself. I started to think beyond what I was doing.
I changed my standards for what constituted a good training.
I was taught that a good training was the EFFECTIVE training that got the result as quickly and tactfully as possible.
In practice, I saw that the NHMS techniques were indeed by design, functioning in a manner to create RESPONSE in the horse, sooner rather than later.
I also watched as the same rope swing that released the horses stuck body and emotional inertia, saddled them with emotional baggage. I stuck around those horses long enough, asked those same horses enough questions in enough environments, that I discovered what that baggage often was.
And the baggage these horses had, had nothing to do with the INTENTIONS natural horsemanship espoused.
The intention was to replicate natural horse behaviour, and create a bond with a horse that replaced force and pain, enabling horsemanship to continue in a safe and kind manner to the horse.
I found out, that in many cases (but not all) that bond was forged in fear. Fear of varying degrees of severity, a spectrum of fear. Sometimes it was the horses realisation that their human was mostly harmless, but not entirely, enough to put them mildly on edge around people. On edge enough to never have steady feet or a long thought. Steady feet and long thoughts often are confused as lack of response or respect. They are not. And often the horses just outright feared what comes next if they do not respond- now.
Not all fear is fear for your life. You can fear for the loss of a varying number of things. Loss of your comfort, your knowledge, your place in the world, your social connections. Loss of your physical safety, loss of your autonomy. All these things can be feared.
To anyone reading who is already annoyed with me for talking about it, I want you to know, I am definitely not talking about you. I am talking about what I used to do. And if this shoe doesn't fit you, don't wear it.
So, for the above reason, and many other reasons I won't get into now, I began to question if Natural Horsemanship was the revolution I wanted to form my entire personality around. I discovered it was not, for me. And certainly not the the horses I was meeting.
So I took what I could, salvaged what I could, and moved into a lifeboat.
In that lifeboat, I floated here and there. I spent some times at varying islands, different methods, eventually those islands and their natives gave me reason to get back in the boat and move on. Why was there so much hostility... everywhere? A strange abundance of hostility and an odd lack of critical thinking?
I kept paddling.
On the way though, I met some lovely folks who jumped in my lifeboat with me. They put their shoulders to the oar. They brought their tools. We collected what we needed to have a sound ship.
Eventually, when I came to create my first online course, I realised that this ship could sail on its own.
I realised I no longer needed natural horsemanship. I took many of those techniques, and edited them. Edited out any aspect that could create fear, small or large, and chose a different foundation.
The foundation is that of care. And not a trite, fluffy, no-substance type of care. And not just horse keeping- though quality horse keeping is the foundation of all quality training.
Care informed by deep scientific work, robust trial and error with thousands of horses, and the authentic connection between what we say, and what we do.
Because I will no longer stand in a room that tells great stories about the horsemanship, but when we actually look at how those words translate into action...
I recorded a podcast on this subject with fellow oarsman Michelle Knapp. She too was deep into the NHMS world, and she too, found her way out to something else.
I want to thank the people who have already listened, and wrote me to let us know how helpful it was for them to hear this subject spoken about plainly. We are here for you.