Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe

Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe We’re a full-service butcher and deli serving quality meats, prepared sides, and more with fair prices and friendly customer service. At Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe, we believe you should always trust that the food you put on the table was cut and prepared with care.
(333)

Family owned and operated since 1982, we offer the same quality meats and products that we use in our own kitchens. We love heading to work every day, and our team is always happy to answer any question you may have. We make the whole shopping experience something to look forward to, from the warm atmosphere to price tags that’ll make you smile.

Operating as usual

07/27/2021

Steak sale while supplies last
Tuesday - Friday 9-5
Saturday 8-3
Closed Sunday/Monday

T Bone Steak $12.99 per pound

Strip Loin Steak $12.99 per pound

Bone In RibEye $13.99 per pound

Rib Eye Steak $13.99 per pound

Were busy getting ready for the weekendFresh through Saturday we’re offering lots of fresh options
07/01/2021

Were busy getting ready for the weekend
Fresh through Saturday we’re offering lots of fresh options

We’ve got the SteakFeaturing Copper Creek Prime and upper 2/3 choiceCome visit us at Evansville or Newburgh we’re open u...
06/26/2021

We’ve got the Steak
Featuring Copper Creek Prime and upper 2/3 choice
Come visit us at Evansville or Newburgh we’re open until 3 o’clock

Father’s Day Destination Stop for the weekendFeaturing Copper Creek Prime & Choice Steaks Plain or Cajun Bratwurst $4.99...
06/17/2021

Father’s Day Destination Stop for the weekend
Featuring Copper Creek Prime & Choice Steaks

Plain or Cajun Bratwurst $4.99 per pound
Ground Beef Patties $4.99 per pound

Open till 3 todayCan’t wait to see what everyone is cooking this weekend. Here are a few yummy options. Now offering PRI...
06/12/2021

Open till 3 today
Can’t wait to see what everyone is cooking this weekend. Here are a few yummy options.
Now offering PRIME COPPER CREEK line of steaks.
Come in and see us before 3 today

Check out the selection of premium “Prime”Grade steaks from Copper Creek
05/20/2021

Check out the selection of premium “Prime”
Grade steaks from Copper Creek

Check out the selection of premium “Prime”
Grade steaks from Copper Creek

Great looking Bone In Rib-Eye going in the counter. These will be running $14.99 per pound while supplies last. Regular ...
05/20/2021

Great looking Bone In Rib-Eye going in the counter. These will be running $14.99 per pound while supplies last.
Regular price was $17.99 per pound.
Short sale while supplies last. Place your order today for the weekend.
1 to 1 1/2 pound per steak.

Great looking Bone In Rib-Eye going in the counter. These will be running $14.99 per pound while supplies last.
Regular price was $17.99 per pound.
Short sale while supplies last. Place your order today for the weekend.
1 to 1 1/2 pound per steak.

Your favorite food is even better with your friends!
05/11/2021

Your favorite food is even better with your friends!

Your favorite food is even better with your friends!

05/10/2021

NOW HIRING FULL AND PART-TIME EMPLOYEES AT OUR NEWBURGH LOCATION!!! PLEASE APPLY IN STORE AT
7766 FRUITWOOD LANE, NEWBURGH, IN

Help us celebrate #MothersDay by sharing the best advice your mama ever gave you! #MamaKnowsBest 💓
05/09/2021

Help us celebrate #MothersDay by sharing the best advice your mama ever gave you! #MamaKnowsBest 💓

Help us celebrate #MothersDay by sharing the best advice your mama ever gave you! #MamaKnowsBest 💓

Who has time for diets anyway?!
05/06/2021

Who has time for diets anyway?!

Who has time for diets anyway?!

Just a simple thank you for always supporting us. We have the best customers!
05/04/2021

Just a simple thank you for always supporting us. We have the best customers!

Just a simple thank you for always supporting us. We have the best customers!

We’re open till 3:00 and ready to serve up some good eats for the weekend. Come in to let us feel your grills
05/01/2021

We’re open till 3:00 and ready to serve up some good eats for the weekend.
Come in to let us feel your grills

Check your watch... it's time to eat!
04/29/2021

Check your watch... it's time to eat!

Check your watch... it's time to eat!

Which are you more likely to order? We prefer... BOTH!
04/27/2021

Which are you more likely to order? We prefer... BOTH!

Which are you more likely to order? We prefer... BOTH!

04/27/2021

Specials through May 1st

Bone in Pork chops $3.99 per pound

Extra Lean Ground Beef $3.99 per pound

Boneless Smoked Pork Chops $5.99 per pound

Leftovers are serious business.
04/20/2021

Leftovers are serious business.

Leftovers are serious business.

Prime Beef TenderloinOnly -$19.99- per poundPlace your call ahead order for this weekend while supplies last 812-423-246...
04/16/2021

Prime Beef Tenderloin
Only -$19.99- per pound
Place your call ahead order for this weekend while supplies last 812-423-2465
Whole untrimmed but will trim and cut steaks, even grind the trimmings for to make some burgers for later all for $19.99 per pound

Prime Beef TenderloinOnly -$19.99- per poundPlace your call ahead order for this weekend while supplies last 812-423-246...
04/16/2021

Prime Beef Tenderloin
Only -$19.99- per pound
Place your call ahead order for this weekend while supplies last 812-423-2465
Whole untrimmed but will trim and cut steaks, even grind the trimmings for to make some burgers for later all for $19.99 per pound

Like if food is basically all you think about... 😂🍴
04/15/2021

Like if food is basically all you think about... 😂🍴

Like if food is basically all you think about... 😂🍴

We make the meals, you make the memories!
04/13/2021

We make the meals, you make the memories!

We make the meals, you make the memories!

04/13/2021

Freezer Package Special
15 pound package with add on options
5 pounds of each
- Pork Chops
- Beef Stew Meat or Cubed Steaks
- Pork Sausage
---$55.00----
Add ons
5 Pound Each
Bratwurst ---------$18.00
Pork Cutlets ------$13.00
Beef Chuck Roast $25.00

If we can all agree on one thing, it's that food will always bring us together.
04/08/2021

If we can all agree on one thing, it's that food will always bring us together.

If we can all agree on one thing, it's that food will always bring us together.

We can't thank you enough for your support - Let's all continue to support Evansville local businesses this year! #EatLo...
04/06/2021

We can't thank you enough for your support - Let's all continue to support Evansville local businesses this year! #EatLocal

We can't thank you enough for your support - Let's all continue to support Evansville local businesses this year! #EatLocal

Hopping you have the happiest Easter! #Easter2021
04/04/2021

Hopping you have the happiest Easter! #Easter2021

Hopping you have the happiest Easter! #Easter2021

Change your lunch plans and come visit us at the old fashion butcher shop and get ready for the weekend we’re offering F...
03/19/2021

Change your lunch plans and come visit us at the old fashion butcher shop and get ready for the weekend we’re offering FREH PRIME CUTS
20 days aged come get your today

Address

2130 Stringtown Rd
Evansville, IN
47711

Opening Hours

Tuesday 9am - 5pm
Wednesday 9am - 5pm
Thursday 9am - 6pm
Friday 9am - 5pm
Saturday 8am - 5pm

Telephone

(812) 423-2465

Products

Full Service Butcher Shoppe & Deli

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe:

Videos

Category

Our Meat is a Cut Above the Rest

Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe isn't your average meat market in Evansville, IN. We offer walk-in and bulk order services. Our wholesale meat suppliers provide prime cuts of meat to stores and restaurants throughout the area.

Many of the top retailers choose us for:


  • Beef steaks, roasts, grinds and burgers

  • Pork loins, breasts, chops and sausages
  • Nearby food & beverage services


    Other Butchers in Evansville

    Show All

    Comments

    When will the Newburgh location open???
    When is your store in Newburgh going to open???
    https://youtu.be/vqd41X4hf3E Our New Ad! Made by our junior butcher, Landon Baehl.
    I figured out what I was going to do for dinner. Thanks for the help. It worked.
    I have heard you all might come to Newburgh. I hope that is true
    What are this weeks specials?
    Are you open till 5p or 4
    I just want to tell y’all how much we have enjoyed your wonderful meats and poultry. We have been customers since moving to the north side of Evv. However. I was there today to get my meats and chicken and none of your staff is masked. Our family has health concerns and cannot take any chances so it will be the last time we are there to purchase your wonderful items. I’m sad about this. I hope you and your staff will reconsider and mask up. It’s not for you it’s for us... your customers. Think about it. We would love to come back but until everyone is masked and protected we just can take the chance. Blessings. 😘
    I hope it's ok to post a picture of my butt on this page. I love that I never have to look for the perfect cut at Old Fashioned, I can just grab the first piece I come to and know it's good.
    what is the price of regular ground beef?
    Are u taking any special orders right now?
    Do you have whole brisket?