Proper Pastry

Proper Pastry Best little pastry shop and dessert catering company

Sourdough bagel production will be on Friday and Saturday only. We are no longer supplying Penny Drip. We will start c...
06/15/2026

Sourdough bagel production will be on Friday and Saturday only. We are no longer supplying Penny Drip. We will start carrying flavors as well as the sourdough. If you would like to order more than a dozen please contact Proper Pastry online or 260-413-5203.

We were out of power for 16 hours so I will not be opening today. Next week should be normal hours!
06/13/2026

We were out of power for 16 hours so I will not be opening today. Next week should be normal hours!

does 3 tier cakes for all occasions!
06/01/2026

does 3 tier cakes for all occasions!

Just a heads up...the bakery will be closed an hour early tomorrow for a cake delivery; so come early to get these rhub...
05/30/2026

Just a heads up...the bakery will be closed an hour early tomorrow for a cake delivery; so come early to get these rhubarb lemon curd bars!

Yes...I will make you a giant devils food cake!
05/24/2026

Yes...I will make you a giant devils food cake!

Stop by this week for the best macarons in town!!
05/18/2026

Stop by this week for the best macarons in town!!

Custom orders available !
04/28/2026

Custom orders available !

Customize your next order!
04/12/2026

Customize your next order!

Creme brulee made with Country Garden egg yolks and Kuehnertdairyfarm cream. Come sample in Proper Pastry cream puffs, ...
04/08/2026

Creme brulee made with Country Garden egg yolks and Kuehnertdairyfarm cream. Come sample in Proper Pastry cream puffs, eclairs, and bear claws!

Try Italian buttercream for your next cake! So light and delicious 🎂
04/06/2026

Try Italian buttercream for your next cake! So light and delicious 🎂

Address

139 N. Main Street
Main Street, IN
46783

Opening Hours

Wednesday 8am - 4pm
Thursday 8am - 4pm
Friday 8am - 4pm
Saturday 8am - 3pm

Telephone

+1 260-413-5203

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Proper Pastry posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category