Casey’s Cookies

Casey’s Cookies Hi! I am Casey, I specialize in making custom-decorated sugar cookies under the Ohio cottage baker law. Send me a message!
(4)

Each order is thoughtfully designed and freshly made from my home kitchen to add a sweet, personal touch to your celebrations.

Arcade Pac-Man 10th birthday cookies for Zach and Wes! 🎮
06/07/2026

Arcade Pac-Man 10th birthday cookies for Zach and Wes! 🎮

A few orange cookie boxes are still available! 🍊Each box includes 3 hand-decorated orange vanilla cookies, individually ...
06/02/2026

A few orange cookie boxes are still available! 🍊

Each box includes 3 hand-decorated orange vanilla cookies, individually wrapped and packaged up ready for gifting (or keeping for yourself 😉).

Not ready to gift them yet? No problem! These cookies freeze beautifully, so you can tuck them away for a future thank-you gift, hostess gift, birthday surprise, or just a little treat for later.

$20 per box
Message me to claim one before they’re gone!

🍊 FLASH SALE 🍊Freshly picked… from my cookie cutter collection. 😉These orange vanilla sugar cookies are available for a ...
06/01/2026

🍊 FLASH SALE 🍊

Freshly picked… from my cookie cutter collection. 😉

These orange vanilla sugar cookies are available for a limited flash sale!

Each gift box includes:
🍊 1 orange branch cookie
🍊 1 orange slice cookie
🍊 1 orange wedge cookie

Packaged in a gift box with crinkle paper and ready for gifting (or keeping for yourself!). Stays perfectly fresh in freezer to save for a future event!

💲20 per box
📍Mentor, Ohio pickup
📩 Comment SOLD or send me a message to claim yours!

9 boxes available.

**** UPDATE: 5 boxes left

Disappointing to see a customer cancel due to changing her mind after getting a picture of the final product, after the ...
05/30/2026

Disappointing to see a customer cancel due to changing her mind after getting a picture of the final product, after the cookie artist spent hours and hours of her time making these special for her 😔

**this is my mom’s cookie and cake business in Michigan

Another graduation set! I was nervous about making these feel feminine while still sticking to the school colors, but I’...
05/29/2026

Another graduation set! I was nervous about making these feel feminine while still sticking to the school colors, but I’m really happy with how they turned out! And I’m definitely getting my money’s worth out of these graduation cutters 😂

A little booking update 🤍I’m currently booked through the middle of August, and dates for the rest of the year are alrea...
05/29/2026

A little booking update 🤍

I’m currently booked through the middle of August, and dates for the rest of the year are already starting to fill in as well! I’ve also been receiving a lot of last-minute inquiries lately, so I wanted to gently remind everyone that the earlier you reach out, the better, especially because I hate saying no!!

If you know you’ll need cookies for birthdays, baby showers, weddings, holidays, school events, etc., I highly recommend booking more than a month in advance whenever possible to make sure I can fit you into my schedule! It’s never too early to let me know!

I’m so thankful for all of the support and excited for all the fun themes coming up this year 🫶

A girly graduation set🎓 Loving these bright colors 🩷
05/28/2026

A girly graduation set🎓

Loving these bright colors 🩷

05/26/2026

Watch me decorate a floral graduation cap 🩷 a sneak peek to my next graduation set for later this month 🎓

I love the bright, girly color scheme for this set! I can’t wait to see this set come together 😍

Another grad set done 🎓 Crankin’ these orders out before baby gets here!! 😮‍💨 I do love the cleanness and simplicity of ...
05/23/2026

Another grad set done 🎓

Crankin’ these orders out before baby gets here!! 😮‍💨

I do love the cleanness and simplicity of this set. It really worked out that the high school colors and Ohio University colors were basically the same, so no contrasting school colors! 🎉

05/23/2026

⚓️Decorating the sailboat cookie from the New England set, this one was harder than the sweater for me believe it or not, just less tedious.

Simple, clean designs are hard because mistakes become more visible!

Address

Mentor, OH

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Casey’s Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Casey’s Cookies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category