Casey’s Cookies

Contact the business

Casey’s Cookies Hi! I am Casey, I specialize in making custom-decorated sugar cookies under the Ohio cottage baker law. Send me a message!

Each order is thoughtfully designed and freshly made from my home kitchen to add a sweet, personal touch to your celebrations.

Packed the swimsuits… and the icing bags 😂🐺🍪 I’ll always follow through on your orders, and I love making time for fun w...
10/08/2026

Packed the swimsuits… and the icing bags 😂🐺🍪 I’ll always follow through on your orders, and I love making time for fun with my family, too! A little cookie decorating during our downtime at Great Wolf Lodge means I get to do both 🤍

A baby is brewing ☕️🤎🎀The tiny coffee beans, textured teddy bears, and iced coffees… I had so much fun with this baby sh...
10/02/2026

A baby is brewing ☕️🤎🎀

The tiny coffee beans, textured teddy bears, and iced coffees… I had so much fun with this baby shower set!

10/02/2026

Some behind the scenes, how I make my black icing! 🖤

A little something for my brownie lovers 🤤 Each 2-pack includes one classic fudge brownie and one salted caramel brownie...
10/01/2026

A little something for my brownie lovers 🤤 Each 2-pack includes one classic fudge brownie and one salted caramel brownie made with homemade caramel!

If you love rich, fudgy, chocolatey brownies, these are for you 🍫 $10 per 2 pack, limited availability .

***one 2-pack left

Because these sold out so fast I may make more! Message me if you’re interested, pick up would be Saturday.

Hint to my next order ☕️ 🤎 Look for the reveal of the final set this weekend!And the winner for the half dozen mug hugge...
09/30/2026

Hint to my next order ☕️ 🤎 Look for the reveal of the final set this weekend!

And the winner for the half dozen mug huggers for a correct guess is Angie! Congratulations!

It was fun last time, so let’s do this again! Can you guess what this order is? 👀Hint: it’s not a character theme! Guess...
09/26/2026

It was fun last time, so let’s do this again! Can you guess what this order is? 👀

Hint: it’s not a character theme! Guess both the event and the theme in the comments. I’ll pick a winner from the correct guesses to get a dozen mug hugger cookies! 🍪

* one guess per person !

The finished vintage Winnie the Pooh baby shower set 🍯💛
09/22/2026

The finished vintage Winnie the Pooh baby shower set 🍯💛

09/22/2026

Bringing back one of my favorite cookies from last Halloween 🏚️🎃

The tiny windows, stonework, and Halloween lights took some time, but watching this haunted house come together is still so satisfying! 🕸️

Last 3 boxes available! 🍁☕️I have just 3 boxes of maple leaf mug huggers left — and I’m adding an extra cookie to each b...
09/18/2026

Last 3 boxes available! 🍁☕️
I have just 3 boxes of maple leaf mug huggers left — and I’m adding an extra cookie to each box, so you’ll get 7 cookies for $24!

Vanilla sugar cookies with vanilla royal icing, made to sit perfectly on the side of your coffee or tea mug. Such a cute little fall treat or gift 🤎

Message me to claim a box!

09/18/2026

🎉 The winner of a half dozen mug hugger cookies is Jessica Lyn Ziemba! Congratulations! 🤍

And yes — so many of you guessed it! The order I’m working on is a vintage Winnie the Pooh baby shower set 🍯💛 I can’t wait to share the finished cookies!

Also, I have 3 more half-dozen boxes of maple leaf mug huggers available! 🍁 ** and I’m throwing in one extra cookie for each of these 3 boxes!

They’re vanilla sugar cookies with vanilla royal icing and are made to rest perfectly on the side of your mug — perfect to enjoy with coffee or tea. ☕️ They’d make such a cute little gift… or a treat for yourself!

$24 per box / 7 cookies
🤎To order: https://www.mycustombakes.com/caseyscookies/products/view/Fall%20Mug%20Huggers

***Photo of mug hugger cookies in comments***

Address

Mentor, OH

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Casey’s Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Casey’s Cookies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category