08/30/2026
This is my CopyCat recipe for Creamy Italian, honestly, I think it’s better!
I was really sad when Covid came around and closed down the buffet at Pizza Hut. I have many memories of going there with my family after church on Sunday. I even had my graduation dinner there. Anyways, I want to give credit for parts of this recipe to Todd Wilbur, he is known for writing many Top Secret Recipes. And I have tasted so many that are very close to the real thing. Follow him he has some amazing recipes, and he’s funny too. But, this one, wasn’t there for me, because I didn’t remember it being spicy, and that is what red pepper flakes did to it. Now, playing devil’s advocate here, there may have been different versions of dressing, as I understand that Pizza Hut changed companies a few times, but the one I grew up is closer to this taste. So I decided, I agree with Todd that it is peppers, so I added the smash burger seasoning and it is pretty darn close to what I remember.
1 cup Dukes Mayo
1/4 cup Red W**e Vinegar
1/2 tsp Crazy Salt
1/4 tsp Accent
1 tsp Italian seasoning
1 tsp Smash Burger Seasoning (or something with dried red peppers and other veggies)
1 Tbsp sugar, plus 1 tsp
Mix all ingredients in a bowl and cover. Refrigerate for at least 4 hrs, overnight is best.