Allfather's Candy Co.

Allfather's Candy Co. "All Mothers Recommend Allfather's"

It is believed that Allfather's Candy Company dates back to the1880's. Warren Street, Trenton, NJ. Mr.

The candy company was founded by William Allfather and was located at 335 N. During Allfather's early years, Trenton was a manufacturing powerhouse making every conceivable product from the heavy steel cables supporting the Brooklyn Bridge to the finest porcelain dinnerware for the White House. It has been written that 100,000 cheese steaks were prepared and sold every day to the factory workers a

t lunchtime. Eugene Allfather, Jr., son of founder William Allfather, continued to operate the business until 1958. At the age of 72, he sold the candy concern to John Milutus who operated Allfather's for the next 32 years. Milutus then sold Allfather's to Jim Bartolomei, Virgil Brillantini and Ed DiNatale in 1990. For many years to follow, Mr. Milutus sold Allfather' eggs in his “Honey of a Nut” store at the Trenton Farmer's Market. In 2021, the company was taken over Ed’s daughter, Larissa and her fiancé, Andrew Cooney

Craving Allfather's? Stop by Foley's Family Market in Hamilton, where you can still find a great selection of our favori...
05/11/2026

Craving Allfather's? Stop by Foley's Family Market in Hamilton, where you can still find a great selection of our favorites!

Communion season is here—celebrate the occasion with this beautifully crafted white chocolate cross. Message us for more...
05/04/2026

Communion season is here—celebrate the occasion with this beautifully crafted white chocolate cross. Message us for more details!

End of Season Sale!!!! Everything is marked down 50 - 70% off!!!! While supplies last!! Sale ends April 23!
04/09/2026

End of Season Sale!!!! Everything is marked down 50 - 70% off!!!! While supplies last!! Sale ends April 23!

🌷🐰 Happy Easter from Allfather's Candy Company! 🐣🍫From our family to yours, we hope your day is filled with joy, traditi...
04/05/2026

🌷🐰 Happy Easter from Allfather's Candy Company! 🐣🍫

From our family to yours, we hope your day is filled with joy, tradition, and plenty of sweet treats. Thank you for making Allfather's part of your Easter celebrations—we’re honored to be on your table year after year.

Wishing you a beautiful and delicious Easter! 💛

There’s still time to place your order with Allfathers and make this Easter extra special! Don’t miss out on the chance ...
03/30/2026

There’s still time to place your order with Allfathers and make this Easter extra special! Don’t miss out on the chance to share our premium, handcrafted chocolates with family and friends. From classic favorites to unique seasonal treats, we have something for everyone—but time is running out. Order now to ensure your Easter baskets are filled with the rich, delicious tradition that Allfathers is known for. Visit allfatherscandy.com or one of our great retailers.

Celebrate the true meaning of Easter with a sweet tradition that’s as beautiful as it is delicious. Our milk and white c...
03/27/2026

Celebrate the true meaning of Easter with a sweet tradition that’s as beautiful as it is delicious. Our milk and white chocolate crosses are carefully crafted with rich, creamy chocolate that melts perfectly with every bite, offering a moment of indulgence and reflection. The smooth sweetness of premium milk chocolate pairs beautifully with the delicate, velvety taste of white chocolate, creating a timeless treat that’s perfect for gifting, sharing, or adding to your Easter basket. Whether you’re honoring the season or simply treating loved ones, these elegant chocolate crosses make Easter more meaningful—and undeniably more delicious.

03/26/2026
We’re excited to welcome Giant Supermarkets to the Allfathers family! 🎉Now you can find some of your favorite Allfathers...
03/24/2026

We’re excited to welcome Giant Supermarkets to the Allfathers family! 🎉

Now you can find some of your favorite Allfathers chocolates at select Giant locations. Stop by and pick up the sweet treats you love, or visit our website to see which stores near you carry Allfathers.

Thank you for supporting a tradition that’s been bringing families together for generations. 🍫

Only 13 days until Easter!!! Leap into Easter sweetness with our delightful milk chocolate peanut butter frog! 🐸🍫 This c...
03/23/2026

Only 13 days until Easter!!! Leap into Easter sweetness with our delightful milk chocolate peanut butter frog! 🐸🍫 This charming frog is crafted from smooth, creamy milk chocolate and filled with a rich, velvety peanut butter center that melts perfectly with every bite. The playful frog shape adds a fun springtime touch, making it a unique addition to any Easter basket or holiday treat table. Crack through the luscious chocolate shell to discover the irresistible peanut butter filling inside—creating the perfect balance of chocolatey sweetness and nutty goodness. It’s a fun, delicious treat that’s sure to make any Easter celebration a little sweeter! 🌷🥜🍬

Address

Trenton, NJ

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Allfather's Candy Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Allfather's Candy Co.:

Shortcuts

Share