My Sugar Pie

My Sugar Pie The ‘My Sugar Pie’ pie list includes more than 50 different pies--all handmade, with a light, crispy pastry crust Accepting pie orders - NOW OPEN
(232)

Pumpkin Season is starting at My Sugar Pie! Come in to try a slice or whole pie of Pumpkin, Pumpkin Praline, or Chippy P...
27/08/2026

Pumpkin Season is starting at My Sugar Pie! Come in to try a slice or whole pie of Pumpkin, Pumpkin Praline, or Chippy Pumpkin!

Fresh Peach Pies being baked today!
25/08/2026

Fresh Peach Pies being baked today!

Great day for My Sugar Pie at the Carmel Farmers Market! Thanks to the fabulous volunteers who make it so special every ...
22/08/2026

Great day for My Sugar Pie at the Carmel Farmers Market! Thanks to the fabulous volunteers who make it so special every Saturday morning!

Eighteen years of pie baking and counting! Thanks Main Street Zionsville!
21/08/2026

Eighteen years of pie baking and counting! Thanks Main Street Zionsville!

CHARMING ON PURPOSE
There’s just something about a homemade pie.
At My Sugar Pie , old-fashioned recipes, handmade goodness and a whole lot of love come together in a charming little cottage on Main Street Zionsville.

From Hoosier Sugar Cream to classic favorites, Kelly has a pie for just about every sweet tooth.

Now we want to know: What’s YOUR favorite kind of pie?

"Mom' Original" Dutch Apple? Sugar Cream "Hoosier Sugar Pie"? S'more Pie?

Tell us in the comments! And go get yourself a slice!

My Sugar Pie
https://www.mysugarpie.com
📍40 E Pine St.

My Sugar Pie is HIRING! Bakers, Assistant Bakers, & Bakery Prep Associates/Cashiers. Part time, full time, internships a...
20/08/2026

My Sugar Pie is HIRING! Bakers, Assistant Bakers, & Bakery Prep Associates/Cashiers. Part time, full time, internships and seasonal help all welcome! Send your Resume to [email protected]!

Fresh Peach Dumplings available now at My Sugar Pie and the Carmel Farmers Market!
14/08/2026

Fresh Peach Dumplings available now at My Sugar Pie and the Carmel Farmers Market!

Thank you Main Street Zionsville for providing promotional help and shining a light on our little local business! ...
13/08/2026

Thank you Main Street Zionsville for providing promotional help and shining a light on our little local business!

CHARMING ON PURPOSE
The best memories often come with a little something sweet.
A birthday celebration. A family dinner. A thoughtful gift. Or simply a stop on Main Street Zionsville for a slice because today feels like a pie kind of day.
At My Sugar Pie, handmade pies are baked from scratch bringing sweetness to both special occasions and everyday moments.

🥧 My Sugar Pie
📍40 East Pine Street, Zionsivlle

13/08/2026

Fresh Peach Dumplings hot out of the ovens right now!

Need Fresh Produce, Meats, and My Sugar Pie!?! Market Wagon is the way to get delivery of locally grown foods to your do...
07/08/2026

Need Fresh Produce, Meats, and My Sugar Pie!?! Market Wagon is the way to get delivery of locally grown foods to your door! It’s an online farmers market delivering every Thursday! www.marketwagon.com

Buy One Slice, Get One Free! Back to School Slice Special!
05/08/2026

Buy One Slice, Get One Free! Back to School Slice Special!

Address

40 East Pine Street
IN

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10:00 - 16:00
Wednesday 10:00 - 16:00
Thursday 10:00 - 16:00
Friday 10:00 - 16:00
Saturday 08:00 - 16:00

Telephone

+13177338717

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when My Sugar Pie posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to My Sugar Pie:

Shortcuts

  • Want your business to be the top-listed Food & Beverage Service?

Share