02/04/2026
MISLEADING MARKETING ON PACKAGED MANURES AND COMPOSTS IN HARDWARE STORES
I have always recommended natural, aged manures to improve your vegetable garden soil and I highly recommend sheep manure for Winter crops because it has a better balance of NPK and gentler nitrogen release.
Importantly, I recommend natural sheep manure collected from under shearing sheds and not commercially composted (see photo below).
I do not recommend the plastic-wrapped products from hardware stores because they are often anaerobic or so mineral-imbalanced that they harm your soils and plants. They are also ethically compromised and highly misleading with their product claims.
Here's why, and I'm using a product a customer spoke to me about yesterday to illustrate this - called Fine Farms Premium Sheep Manure.
Take a look at the product photograph below and then compare the truth:
1. The bag shows a sheep on pasture grass, suggesting natural grass based manures. But this company doesn't own farms or sheep; it collects the manure from sheep feedlots (stated on their website), where intensively farmed animals are kept in enclosed spaces and fed grains, minerals, and medicinal additives, which is not a natural diet.
So the manure is not made from natural pasture grass; it is partially digested grain products. The sheep are not ethically raised in pastures at stocking rates that allow a stress-free life and social engagements - they are raised in intensive livestock pens, and their manure is scraped up into piles beside rotting corpses.
2. The bag claims "Premium" sheep manure. Is there anyone who thinks that manure from grain-fed sheep held in feedlots is "premium"?
3. The bag claims "Natural and Organic" which is misleading. All manures are "natural", and a product only has to be carbon-based to claim it is "organic". It does not mean it is chemical-free, as "certified organic" products are. And intensive feedlots and grain-fed diets are not "natural".
What you might not know is that transitioning a lamb or sheep from pasture to feedlots and grain diets is emotionally stressful and hard on their digestion. Whilst mineral and medicinal supplements are supplied, there are still many deaths. Ethical organisations concerned with intensive livestock management have captured photographs of piles of dead sheep next to manure piles in feedlots.
How would the quality of this feedlot, grain-fed sheep manure possibly compare to the natural sheep manures collected from shearing sheds where sheep were born and raised on pastured lands and live in social group structures?
The last concern is that these companies, like Fine Farms compost the sheep manure, and whilst they say "no additives" and "no green waste" on the packaging, they are not compliant with the composting standards, and they have obviously added wood material products that can be seen in the photograph provided by my customer I spoke to.
If you really want a high-quality, natural sheep manure collected from shearing sheds, keep asking your local nurseries for it. With enough demand, they will source it, and your soils and plants will thank you.
And please look further than the pretty pictures and claims these companies make on these products. They are simply waste recyclers and their packaging claims are misleading.