Carla's Cookie Box

Directions Website

Carla's Cookie Box It's Not Just a Butter Tart; it's An Experience. Ontario-Made + Locally Sourced Ingredients We are an online bakery shop. We ship Canada 🇨🇦 & USA-wide.

❤️It’s Not Just a Butter Tart; It’s an Experience ❤️

Welcome to Carla’s Cookie Box. We are a Woman Run / Family Run Baking Caterer specializing in Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts, Smash Cakes, and Artisanal Gourmet Baked Goods.

10/19/2026

You can literally SEE the moment the butter tart hits. 😂

That pause.
That look.
That immediate second bite.

We could write a whole paragraph telling you how good they are… but this reaction does a much better job. 😏

🍁 Award-winning Canadian butter tarts
📦 Shipping across Canada
👉 carlacookiebox.com



https://carlacookiebox.com

10/18/2026

We can say “gooey” all day.

But pulling one apart tells the story a whole lot better. 🤤

THAT centre is exactly what we want you to find inside every box.

🍁 Award-winning Canadian butter tarts
📦 Shipping across Canada
👉 carlacookiebox.com



https://carlacookiebox.com

10/17/2026

Traditional butter tarts walked so these flavours could RUN. 🏃‍♀️😂

We love the classic — but we also love asking:

“What else can we turn into a butter tart?”

And that question has gotten us into some delicious trouble. 😏

See the current flavours 👉 carlacookiebox.com



https://carlacookiebox.com

10/16/2026

Tell us you LOVE it without telling us you love it. 😂

We’ll go first: 👆 THAT FACE.

This is exactly why first-bite videos never get old around here.

Want to conduct your own very important butter tart research? 🧐

🍁 carlacookiebox.com



https://carlacookiebox.com

10/15/2026

The filling pull deserves its own moment. 🤤

That rich, gooey centre tucked inside buttery pastry is exactly what a butter tart should be.

No sad little dry tarts over here. 😂

🍁 Taste the difference:
carlacookiebox.com

📦 Shipping across Canada



https://carlacookiebox.com

10/13/2026

Flaky on the outside. Gooey where it counts. 🤤

This is your reminder that a great butter tart should NOT be dry, boring or forgettable.

It should make you immediately reach for another one.

We said what we said. 😂

🍁 Award-winning Canadian butter tarts
👉 carlacookiebox.com



https://carlacookiebox.com

10/12/2026

You know a dessert is good when sharing suddenly feels like a terrible idea. 😂

“Want a bite?”

…actually, never mind.

Order enough so everyone gets their own. Trust us. 😏

🍁 carlacookiebox.com
📦 Canada + USA shipping



https://carlacookiebox.com

10/11/2026

Canada really looked at butter, sugar and pastry and said, “Yep. That’ll do.” 🇨🇦😂

And somehow created one of the greatest desserts of all time.

We just decided to take it a little further. 😉

Award-winning butter tarts, handcrafted in Canada and available in flavours worth getting excited about.

📦 Canada + USA
🛍️ carlacookiebox.com



https://carlacookiebox.com

10/10/2026

Some people politely taste-test.

Some people take one bite and their entire face gives away the review. 😂❤️

We prefer the second kind.

Real people. Real reactions. REALLY good butter tarts.

📦 Canada + USA shipping
🍁 carlacookiebox.com



https://carlacookiebox.com

10/09/2026

WARNING: choosing just one flavour may be harder than expected. 😏

Traditional? Pecan? Something completely over-the-top?

That’s the fun of Carla’s Cookie Box — we don’t believe butter tarts should be boring.

Tell us: are you a CLASSIC or ADVENTUROUS butter tart person? 👇

🍁 carlacookiebox.com



https://carlacookiebox.com

10/08/2026

That little pause after the first bite… 😂

You know the one.

The “wait… why is this SO good?” pause.

Our favourite kind of review requires absolutely no words. 😍

🇨🇦 Handcrafted Canadian butter tarts
📦 Canada shipping
👉 carlacookiebox.com



https://carlacookiebox.com

10/07/2026

I will never not miss you. We needed more of these moments with you. Happy birthday, Paul!

10/07/2026

POV: you thought all butter tarts were basically the same. 👀

Then THIS happens.

We took one of Canada’s most iconic desserts and gave it a whole lot more personality. Classic favourites, wild flavour combinations and that gooey centre we refuse to compromise on. 🤤

🍁 Discover the butter tart box everyone keeps talking about:
carlacookiebox.com



https://carlacookiebox.com

Warm, soft-baked cookies with a chewy centre and a lightly crispy edge — perfect with coffee or tucked into a lunchbox 🍪...
10/05/2026

Warm, soft-baked cookies with a chewy centre and a lightly crispy edge — perfect with coffee or tucked into a lunchbox 🍪. Handmade in Toronto in small batches with locally sourced ingredients and zero preservatives, they feel like a little homemade pause. You can order online at CarlaCookieBox.com.

https://carlacookiebox.com/products/cookies-quick-pick-box

New on the blog: Custom Cookies for Weddings and Special Events — tips from Carla M. on designing memorable, handcrafted...
10/05/2026

New on the blog: Custom Cookies for Weddings and Special Events — tips from Carla M. on designing memorable, handcrafted cookies that match your day. Read about sizing, presentation, and how we bring your logo or theme to life with small-batch care. Link in bio to the full post.

https://carlacookiebox.com/blogs/news/custom-cookies-weddings-events

10/04/2026

A little monthly surprise that feels like a hug in pastry form. Every month you’ll receive six handcrafted butter tarts or gourmet cookies made in Ontario with locally sourced Canadian ingredients; butter tart centres are gooey with no corn syrup, and you choose two flavours each delivery. Explore the flavours and subscribe at CarlaCookieBox.com.

https://carlacookiebox.com/products/subscription-butter-tarts

Surprise someone with fresh cookies every month—no fuss, just thoughtful treats. Each delivery ships 6, 12 or 24 handcra...
10/04/2026

Surprise someone with fresh cookies every month—no fuss, just thoughtful treats. Each delivery ships 6, 12 or 24 handcrafted gourmet cookies made in small batches in Ontario with locally sourced Canadian ingredients, and you choose three flavours to keep things interesting. Ready to gift a little joy? Order online at CarlaCookieBox.com 🍪

https://carlacookiebox.com/products/subscription-cookies

Address

Vaughan, ON
L4L5J9

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Carla's Cookie Box posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category