30/09/2026
Front-loading, part seven: and onto weaning
My aim is to take away the last milk without a growth check and with as little stress as possible. By weaning, I mean coming off milk. The meal stays.
In my current system, I expect most calves to be ready somewhere between eight and nine weeks. That’s earlier than I often weaned in my previous, more restricted system. Back then I fed twice a day, then once a day, and could still be trundling milk out at weeks 10, 11 or 12, sometimes even 13 or 14. Finishing earlier saves a lot of work, but I won’t take milk away just to meet an age target.
I’ve deliberately fed plenty of milk in the first four weeks. That has supported strong early growth, but it can also mean the calves eat less meal at first. I’ve prioritised growth early, knowing their meal intake and digestive development then need time to catch up before milk disappears.
That’s why I can’t make the weaning decision from just one number.
Age helps me plan, but two calves of the same age can have eaten very different amounts of meal. Weight shows me what growth they’ve achieved, but not what will support them next.
The widely used benchmark of doubling birth weight by around eight weeks is a good example. For a 40 kg calf, that means reaching 80 kg, or gaining about 0.7 kg a day. It tells me she has grown well. But a little Jersey born at 20 kg has doubled at only 40 kg; some of ours are now over 60 kg, having tripled their birth weight. Doubling birth weight doesn’t tell me that the rumen can take over.
A fixed weaning weight can be just as misleading. Hugh (full name Hugh Jars, if you say it quickly) was born at 52 kg and weighs 93 kg at five weeks. If I used 90 kg as my rule, you could call him at weaning weight. He plainly isn’t. His weight only makes sense alongside his birth weight, age, milk intake, feeding regime, growth trajectory and how much solid feed he has eaten.
My veal calves take that example further. They cruise past 100 kg, then through 130, 140 or 150 kg, with their growth still supported mainly by milk. That’s exactly what I’m aiming for with their diet. Their milk steps down at the very end. Their weight tells me how well that programme is growing them; it doesn’t tell me they’re ready to live without milk which, being veal, they don’t get weaned.
Meal intake gets me closer to the answer, because eating solid feed helps develop the rumen. But even 2 kg eaten today is only a snapshot. What has the calf eaten over the weeks leading up to today?
That’s where cumulative NFC gives me another way to look. NFC includes the starches, sugars and other non-fibre carbohydrates in starter. Research has used around 15 kg consumed over time as an indicator that a calf can extract the expected energy from starter.
I think of the calculation a little like using a Brix meter for colostrum. Brix doesn’t let me see the antibodies themselves; it gives me a useful estimate of colostrum quality. Cumulative NFC doesn’t let me look inside a calf’s rumen either. But by estimating how much of those carbohydrates she has eaten across her life, I get a better idea of how far her ability to use solid feed may have developed. It’s a window into the process, not a direct test or a guaranteed pass mark.
Our oldest mob is now being offered the equivalent of 375 g of milk powder per calf per day, and the mob’s meal intake is moving past 2 kg per calf per day. Eight of the 48 have stopped drinking milk of their own accord. They still visit the feeder to be social, then head off to eat meal.
That meal figure is an average, though. With Jerseys, Friesian crosses, dairy heifers and beef calves all in the mob, I need to watch who is actually eating and competing at the trough. The same goes for milk at a shared feeder, some will drink more than others. So I have to be very aware to not rely to heavily on the average.
I’ll weigh them tomorrow before deciding when to finish their milk. They’ve been meeting my growth targets through the step-down, and I want to see that continuing now that milk is this low. This mob will be closer to nine weeks than eight because of various timing factors this year. That’s fine. Readiness matters more than the date.
If their intake and individual weights support it, I’ll ease away the last milk over the week. The meal and clean water stay available, and I won’t make another big feed or paddock change at the same time. I’ll weigh them again about 10 days after milk finishes to check whether each calf is still gaining. That follow-up matters it tells me whether all the signs I used to make the decision added up to a calf who could actually keep growing.
Saving weeks of milk feeding is a welcome benefit of front-loading when the transition works well. Readiness is the decision; continued growth after the last drink is how I check it.
Picture of Hugh (at the back) at 93kgs and 5weeks old with his 70kg friend. Hugh is by the Black Simmental bull Bounty Hunter (I love these calves) and 702 in front is by the Belgium Blue bull Glencardoch Marvel who is also a favourite.
When you standardise for % of birthweight growth, 702 has actually grown better. 36.5 kgs to 70kgs vs 52kgs to 93kgs. (The geek in me likes the numbers side of things)