09/03/2026
Can you spot the difference between these two homemade English muffins?
The first was split with a fork. The second was sliced with a knife—courtesy of Chris, who unknowingly committed a minor English muffin offense in our kitchen. 😂
Now we have photographic evidence of why the method matters!
Fork-splitting gently pulls apart the inside of the muffin, creating all those wonderful craggy nooks and crannies. When toasted, the raised edges become crisp and golden while the little pockets catch every bit of melted butter, jam, or honey.
A knife cuts straight through those pockets, leaving behind a smoother surface. It will still taste good—but you lose some of the texture that makes an English muffin special.
To fork-split yours, poke the tines all the way around the outside edge, then gently pull the two halves apart. It takes only a few extra seconds, and the photos show exactly why it’s worth it!
From my kitchen to yours — Weekend Baking at the Allan’s.
Now that you’ve seen the evidence, are you Team Fork-Split or Team Knife?