https://www.facebook.com/685982907930203/

Buttersweet Bakery LLC

Home
United States
Batesville, IN
Buttersweet Bakery LLC

Directions

Oatmeal cream pies, cookies, cupcakes, cakes, muffins, and more!
(1)

10/18/2026

🌸 Baptism Sheet Cake 🌸 Vanilla half sheet cake (12x18 inches) with two layers of cake and buttercream in between. As always, everything is 100% homemade.

Sheet cakes are a labor of love - 3x vanilla cake recipe and 6x buttercream recipe. That's a lot of butter! 🧈 It's sooo good though! It's worth it ☺️

xoxo 🧈

10/17/2026

🥕 Chatty Cathy 🥕 This 6" Chatty Cathy Carrot Cake is my all-time favorite cake! I'm so happy that I've received my first customer order for it!!

This cake gets its name from my childhood best friend's family. Her grandpa would call me Chatty Cathy because I have always been a talker lol. They made this delicious carrot cake for gatherings and would always save a slice for me. It was even the cake I requested for my high school graduation party! 🩵🥕

xoxo 🧈

10/15/2026

✨ Pumpkin Oatmeal Cream Pies ✨ These are SO tasty and so soft! These are currently my favorite treat that I make. Also, I have exciting news!! I'm going to have a pop-up on Saturday, Oct 24th from 10 am - 3 pm. Should these be on the menu?? What treats would you like to see at the pop-up?

Let me know! I'm so excited. The pop-up will be at The Old Schubox in Batesville! 🎊☺️

10/11/2026

🪻 Wildflower Birthday Cake 🪻 8" Red Velvet cake with homemade vanilla buttercream. Such a pretty cake!

I mixed nearly 10 colors to create the details! I used AmeriColor and Colour Mill 🎂 food coloring. I needed so much red food coloring for the red velvet cake that I bought a big bottle this time!

If you aren't a fan of food dyes, I can always make a cake for you with dye free food coloring! Just ask! 🐝🐞

xoxo 🧈

10/07/2026

🍏 Apple Fritter Bread 🍏 I made more mini loaves of apple fritter bread this weekend for the family campout! I wanted everyone to try the Applefest menu ☺️ I think they were a hit! The apple fritter bread was definitely my favorite from the Applefest. What was your favorite??

If you didn't get a chance to come to Applefest, you can always order a dozen buckeyes, apple oatmeal cream pies, or apple fritter breads by sending me a message/email!

I was recently gifted the Pampered Chef long loaf pans, so maybe I need to make XL loaves of apple fritter bread next! 🤪

xoxo 🧈

10/05/2026

🎂 Birthday Cake 🎂 8" yellow cake with vanilla buttercream. I made this cake for my family campout over the weekend! There are so many family members and birthdays to celebrate, so my aunt requested this cake to cover September, October, and November birthdays lol.

I love piping vanilla buttercream (without food coloring)! It's so crisp! This cake also allowed me to practice writing with icing. It is not one of my strengths, but I'm continuing to work on it!

xoxo 🧈

10/04/2026

🐞 1st Birthday Sheet Cake 🐞 I made this vanilla sheet cake for a 1st birthday party! This was my fourth sheet cake that I've ever made.

I used the invitation as inspiration; it had strawberries, flowers, and lady bugs! 🍓🐞🍰

Super cute! I also made a couple dozen mini oatmeal cream pies.

xoxo 🧈

Address

Batesville
Batesville, IN

Website

facebook.com

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Buttersweet Bakery LLC posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Want your business to be the top-listed food & beverage service in Batesville?