10/15/2026
Understanding disbudding before deciding on the method
There are disbudding issues that every owner should consider. We do not have as much trepidation on even the subject of neutering as with disbudding. To leave those horns to grow or to destroy them before they are a peril for man and beast. Let’s weigh the disbudding issues good and bad.
Pros for Horns:
Horns are a natural way that the creator gave the animal for protection. Their horns are the means of settling arguments between the members of the herds’ hierarchy. Kids often test their mettle by jousting with other youngsters. Even does related or not recognize their need to do this and will gently train them to use their horns. Watch your doe, when a baby buck challenges her she puts her head down and gently allows him to win or lose the battle he picks with his horns. Only the herd-queen will not let an unrelated youngster win!
If a challenger arises from the ranks to take on the herd-queen or top sire, they do it with their horns. I’ve witnessed two does go at it for days; before one actually won and became the new herd-queen. Yes I said days! The senior sire discipline younger bucks with his horns, and should the youth actually decide he has a chance of winning the distinction of the new sire; they will fight until one is defeated. This many times ends with one of the bucks being severely injured! Sometimes broken legs, dislocated limbs, or just battered they will limp away, I’ve had one sire disable and kill the younger buck. Another broke his juvenile son's back, and the junior buck had to be dispatched.
Those horns can be very beautiful. There are few things that make your sires as majestic as their lovely horns. My senior breeding buck has magnificent horns of about 27” that match his 270-pound frame awesomely. I’m very fortunate to have a DOCILE buck, because with his size comes grave danger. The herd uses their horns to scratch their backs and sides. Hey, who doesn’t enjoy a good back scratch? They use horns to help drag brush down for eating. And horns in an arid area are a real plus, because they help the goats to cool off and regulate their body temperature.
Now the Cons of horns:
They are a danger to humans and other livestock. The goat's horns can withstand tremendous force. That’s why people have found that hitting a goat that is ramming on the horns, even at the base of them, does no good! It signals to the goat that you want to challenge him and fight. Even a 150 lb lightweight buck can ram a perceived threat at 800 pounds of force per square inch!!! Now add his body weight to that. That would mean my 270 pound buck would hit with a collective body force of over 1000 lbs being hurled at the threat. Of course, the opponent usually has his own force, and each of them has four strong legs that act like a stalwart frame. Your animal buddy does not see things like you his owner does. To one of my bucks, my leading his doe away from him was considered a threat, thus he came from 50 feet behind and rammed me. My son carted me out of the enclosure. Let's look at the instant that that force is directed at you or the dog, a real danger! Now I would have been hit from behind with the same situation, but without the horns it would not have done as much damage. Those hard impenetrable horns of 10-20 lbs each can do damage.
Injury to other livestock or to your furry LDG or another dog. I have a 5-yr old LDG. She was raised with the herd and has seen at lease 5- sire bucks, she is no longer with the goats. One of my bucks took a dislike to the fact that she looked as big as his largest doe and could be a competitor for mates. He rammed her and knocked her a good 7-feet away, twice. Both of her back legs were severely damaged. She is no longer with the flock. If a buck can knock a four legged 165 lb dog that far what could he do with a human with two legs, our center of gravity is not a match for him?
Property damage is a real consideration. Even a small goat will warp and damage fencing and gates (I've gone through at least 6-gates that were totally destroyed. Damage doesn't matter how, by thrusting with horns or rubbing down it to relieve them of shedding hair. The only fence safe from most goats no matter the size is an electric fence, and even it can be damaged if the charge stops for whatever reason. My goats chewed it when the power went out.
Tangling in wire and dangers to the goat are real. The NAHMS lists “goat horn entanglement” is a separate category for goat mortality. In their 2009 report 119,000 goat and kids deaths out of 554,000 was reported for the 1 year period. This report is broken down by category. Since we are talking about horns I won’t get into predators, disease etc. But, in the “other category” is ”entanglements” showing it to be a real threat. I can’t even put a number on the amount of time I have spent removing a goat’s head from “cattle panel wires”. They push their heads through to get at a bunch of leaves, a patch of grass or tasty weeds. However the goats do not know that their horns are narrow at the base and widen out at the tips. Caught, stuck and unable to free themselves. They need a pair of hands and sometimes wire cutters to free them.
Small injuries; Black eyes and twisted or broken glasses are a real thing. Even when dealing with horned does. You will bend down to retrieve something and she dips her head to see what you are doing, bang you collide with those horns. “A younger me” wasn't faced with as many small injuries as my older self. What do I mean by that? When I simply catch a doe they often toss their heads or turn the horns sideways which catch my arms, hips and legs. For a young person that will result in bruises but for elderly or those whose skin is thinning this results in bigger bruises and rips, big gouges in their skin on their arms and sometimes severe bleeding. I wear large bruises and gouges like battle scars all year.
A best practice when you get a male goat kid is to start his training early, like three weeks old. If your little buckling challenges you it is a danger later on when he is grown. Use methods to correct it at the baby stage and not when he is too big to handle. Using a sq**rt bottle or hose will work for a little while but they get used to it and then will ignore it. One of the methods is the “flipping correction”, it represents a more reliable method in the long run. When he is a baby he will restrain better, be careful not to hurt him with unnecessary force. As the little beggar reaches two or three months old be sure to do it EVERY time he butts you or challenges you. At that age he will butt your legs especially from behind. Our aim is not to hurt him, just to correct him and show him you are the head of the herd. This will save a great deal of problems and correction needs when he is too big for you to flip him. If you want more information on this method of correction, see my Nov 26, 2005 post on "That nasty..."
I hope I have helped you with your decisions, “horns or no horns”.
My next article will cover your options of disbudding if you decide that horns are not for you and your family. 🐐