04/01/2026
SOS Please help an oyster nerd out!
Last week, I sat down to taste two new oysters from Pamlico Bay, NC, grown on Hatteras Island. Both were well shucked and tasted great! Nothing out of the ordinary in terms of salinity, minerality, aroma.
Then I took a sip of tap water.
Immediate hit of intense bitterness. It felt like I had chewed up an aspirin!
It was so, so, so incredibly bitter that I thought there was something wrong with the water. I had not eaten anything else beforehand. But I had drunk tap water at a local restaurant the eve before, and it tasted fine. I asked a couple of the staff members near me to taste the water, and they didn't notice anything unusual about it.
Later that evening, a friend/colleague reported experiencing the same phenomenon after having one of the NC oysters. It only reacted this way with tap water. It felt very validating/reassuring to know that it wasn't just in my mind, but now I'm wondering what exactly happened there??
Has this happened to you?
Please tag or share with a food/flavor scientist that might know what's going on!