The Cheese Shop

Call Directions Website Contact the business

The Cheese Shop The Cape May creamery! Specialty cheeses, charcuterie boards, sandwiches, gourmet food products, & more in America's original seaside resort. 🧀🇺🇸

Fall flavors, spooky cheeses, and all the seasonal goodness! 🍂🎃👻The Cheese Shop is stocked with festive finds perfect fo...
10/12/2026

Fall flavors, spooky cheeses, and all the seasonal goodness! 🍂🎃👻

The Cheese Shop is stocked with festive finds perfect for Halloween gatherings, fall entertaining, or just treating yourself to a little taste of the season. Stop by and check out all the fall and Halloween goodies before they disappear!

Highlights include:

🔸 Petite Boo Cheese from Marin French Cheese Company: adorned with a striking orange paste and a layer of black, all encased in a soft, bloomy white rind, it's not just a cheese; it captures the spirit of Halloween.

🔸 Moses Reaper from Jasper Hill Farm: button mushroom, fresh milk, and a slight eggy funk with annatto added, turning it a festive shade of orange, with a gray-tinged rind thanks to vegetable ash.

🔸 Pumpkin Spice from Beemster: an irresistible blend of pumpkin spices, including cinnamon, nutmeg, cardamom, and ginger, blended right into a mild, young Gouda to infuse it with aromatic, fragrant fall flavor.

October is National Dessert Month! Our bakery case has a great variety of unique dessert items to satisfy your sweet too...
10/05/2026

October is National Dessert Month! Our bakery case has a great variety of unique dessert items to satisfy your sweet tooth! 😋

October is National Pasta Month! 🍝Our Cape May Gourmet pastas are crafted with premium, responsibly sourced semolina flo...
10/02/2026

October is National Pasta Month! 🍝

Our Cape May Gourmet pastas are crafted with premium, responsibly sourced semolina flour and bronze-cut molds that give each piece of pasta that perfect, sauce-grabbing texture.
🔸 Radiatori
🔸 Tomato Basil Radiatori
🔸 Spinach Gemelli
🔸 Orecchiette
🔸 Spicy Garlic Fusilli
🔸 Mezzi Rigatoni

We’re keeping it simple: just honest ingredients, traditional methods, and a whole lot of love (and a little fun, too). ❤️

Abbondanza,
~ The Spatocco’s

🧀 Deer Creek Cheeses are BACK! 🧀Deer Creek favorites are back in stock—bold, flavorful, and seriously hard to resist.
09/30/2026

🧀 Deer Creek Cheeses are BACK! 🧀

Deer Creek favorites are back in stock—bold, flavorful, and seriously hard to resist.

September 29th is National Biscotti Day! We carry a wide variety of house-made biscotti from our sister shop, Cape May O...
09/29/2026

September 29th is National Biscotti Day! We carry a wide variety of house-made biscotti from our sister shop, Cape May Olive Oil Co.!

Varieties include Cherry & Almond, Chocolate Walnut, Cranberry & Pecan, and Lemon & Coconut. 🍒🍫🍋🥥 They are all perfect with coffee, fine teas, Vin Santo, red wines, or as a late night treat.

Shop in-store or online at capeislandfoods.com/shop/biscotti-crostini/5MXEFK3BS2E5MSGIIOYPIPV6.

One of Cape May’s most popular fall events, Oktoberfest, takes place right behind our shop and on surrounding streets th...
09/24/2026

One of Cape May’s most popular fall events, Oktoberfest, takes place right behind our shop and on surrounding streets this Saturday. While you’re enjoying the festivities, we also invite you to visit us here at The Cheese Shop! You’ll love our specialty cheeses, cured meats, spreads, charcuterie boards, sandwiches, & more. 🧀🍻

We are honored to have been named as the Best Gourmet & Specialty Food in Cape May in this year's Best of Cape May award...
09/21/2026

We are honored to have been named as the Best Gourmet & Specialty Food in Cape May in this year's Best of Cape May awards, as voted on by the readers of Cape May.com! Thank you to all who voted for us! If you haven't yet discovered us, check us out for specialty cheeses, cured meats, spreads, charcuterie boards, sandwiches, & more! 🧀

September 20th is National String Cheese Day! A great quick snack option in the shop is a Beecher’s Homemade Cheese Flag...
09/18/2026

September 20th is National String Cheese Day! A great quick snack option in the shop is a Beecher’s Homemade Cheese Flagship Cheese Stick! This semi-hard cow’s milk string cheese is versatile, robust, and nutty.

The Washington Street Mall’s Fall Sidewalk Sales are taking place this Thursday through Sunday, and while you’re shoppin...
09/14/2026

The Washington Street Mall’s Fall Sidewalk Sales are taking place this Thursday through Sunday, and while you’re shopping the great deals here on the Mall, we invite you to visit us here at The Cheese Shop. You’ll love our specialty cheeses, cured meats, spreads, charcuterie boards, sandwiches, & more! 🧀🛍️

Address

304 Washington Street
Cape May, NJ
NJ

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 6pm
Tuesday 10am - 6pm
Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 7pm
Saturday 10am - 7pm
Sunday 10am - 6pm

Telephone

+16093054080

Website

,

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cheese Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Cheese Shop:

Shortcuts

Share