Betty Kaye Bakery

Directions Website Contact the business

Betty Kaye Bakery We offer a variety of items ranging from homemade breads, cookies, cupcakes, and our famous brownies. We are Carroll County's oldest and finest bakery.

We, like so many other small businesses, are having a hard time finding skilled help. Because of this, we are changing t...
10/12/2026

We, like so many other small businesses, are having a hard time finding skilled help. Because of this, we are changing the days we are going to open. Our new days and hours of operation are- OPEN Thursdays and Fridays from 7:30-5, and Saturdays from 7:30-3. We will now be CLOSED on Sundays, Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays. We will extend our days of operation closer to the holiday season. We are also discontinuing some of our items, but by ordering you can be sure to help us decide what we continue to make. Please place orders online (through Facebook messenger) or by calling the store at 330-627-2665. We look forward to your continued patronage and THANK YOU for all of your cooperation

Mill weekends features- pumpkin pie, assorted Halloween cutouts, small and large croissants, old fashioned maple nut or ...
10/09/2026

Mill weekends features- pumpkin pie, assorted Halloween cutouts, small and large croissants, old fashioned maple nut or cinnamon, giant cinnamon rolls, pb filled cream sticks, pb and jelly, raspberry filled, apple, and pumpkin donuts, red velvet cupcakes, nut, multigrain, and sourdough breads, sub buns and sliders

Weekends features- red velvet, salted caramel, caramel apple, and pumpkin bars, assorted character cutouts, old fashione...
10/02/2026

Weekends features- red velvet, salted caramel, caramel apple, and pumpkin bars, assorted character cutouts, old fashioned maple, maple nut, or cinnamon, giant cinnamon rolls, pumpkin, apple, and raspberry filled glazed donuts, sour dough and multigrain breads, and garlic knots

They’re back…. Pumpkin and apple donuts! We also have Cookie Monster, Oscar the Grouch, sunflower, and mummy cutouts ...
09/30/2026

They’re back…. Pumpkin and apple donuts! We also have Cookie Monster, Oscar the Grouch, sunflower, and mummy cutouts

Weekends features- Spider-Man, unicorn, minion, sloth, football, and pumpkin cutouts, assorted fall brownies, red velvet...
09/25/2026

Weekends features- Spider-Man, unicorn, minion, sloth, football, and pumpkin cutouts, assorted fall brownies, red velvet cupcakes with cream cheese icing, raspberry filled glazed donuts, white cake with strawberry filling and mock cream icing, old fashioned maple or cinnamon rolls, sour dough bread and wheat cloverleaf rolls

Weekends features- sloth, unicorn, football and pumpkin cutouts, pumpkin, caramel apple, tollhouse, and blondie brownies...
09/18/2026

Weekends features- sloth, unicorn, football and pumpkin cutouts, pumpkin, caramel apple, tollhouse, and blondie brownies, chocolate pb iced cupcakes, raisin, sourdough, pumpernickel, and garlic and everything twist breads, sliders and garlic knots, and raspberry filled glazed donuts, old fashioned maple or cinnamon rolls and giant cinnamon rolls

Weekend features- red velvet, pumpkin, caramel apple, and tollhouse brownies, old fashioned cinnamon or maple rolls, gia...
09/11/2026

Weekend features- red velvet, pumpkin, caramel apple, and tollhouse brownies, old fashioned cinnamon or maple rolls, giant cinnamon rolls, cupcake and sunflower cutouts, apple fritters, glazed, and raspberry filled glazed donuts, cobblestone and sourdough breads

You have waited patiently and they are finally back- Caramel apple bars and pumpkin bars! Stop in and be one of the firs...
09/10/2026

You have waited patiently and they are finally back- Caramel apple bars and pumpkin bars! Stop in and be one of the first to enjoy these amazing treats

Labor Day Weekend Features- cookies n cream, lemon, red velvet, and tollhouse brownies, sandwich, hotdog, Bbq, and party...
09/04/2026

Labor Day Weekend Features- cookies n cream, lemon, red velvet, and tollhouse brownies, sandwich, hotdog, Bbq, and party buns, garlic knots, assorted fruit pies, sour dough bread, raspberry filled glazed donuts, old fashioned cinnamon, maple or maple nut, giant cinnamon rolls, and turtle or blueberry cheesecakes

Weekends features- peach bars, lemon bars, lemon and raspberry bars, and salted caramel brownies, old fashioned maple, m...
08/28/2026

Weekends features- peach bars, lemon bars, lemon and raspberry bars, and salted caramel brownies, old fashioned maple, maple nut or cinnamon rolls, giant cinnamon rolls, lemon cream pies, chocolate raspberry , red velvet, and maple cupcakes, burnt almond tortes, and assorted twist breads

Address

72 West Main Street
Carrollton, OH
44615

Opening Hours

Thursday 7:30am - 5pm
Friday 7:30am - 5pm
Saturday 7:30am - 3pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Betty Kaye Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Betty Kaye Bakery:

Shortcuts

Share

Category