11/06/2025
Not Playing the Game
We at Bolze Ranch Angus have been asked many times why we do not submit weights to the American Angus Association and why we do not print EPDs in our bull sale catalog. Here is a short, though not all inclusive list.
1) The beef cattle seedstock industry has historically been driven by extremes. Examples include the 1) short squatty, compressed, slow growing, predisposed to fatness cattle of the 1950-1960s and 2) "jolly green giant", extreme frame score, late maturing, high maintenance, difficult to finish, lower fertility cattle of the mid 1970s to early 1990s. In hindsight, neither was a very good fit for the commercial industry and only the most astute commercial producers did not "jump on the bandwagon". Thankfully, common sense prevailed within a few independently minded breeders. We believe that the current extreme is "maximum EPD trait selection." History has revealed that if the seedstock industry is "given a number" (frame score, cannon bone length, weaning weight, ADG, ultrasound %IMF, EPD, etc.), in the name of "genetic Improvement" , the industry will select for maximums....because maximums sell. This really represents a "no brainer" business model for the seedstock industry because this is what the commercial industry has wanted to or been convinced to buy. In my mind, it begs the question, "Why would the commercial industry want to or feel the need to buy it?"
2). EPDs tend to discount older genetics. Let's use growth for example. Numerous examples exist wherein seedstock breeders have used older genetics with more moderate growth EPDs in "side by side" comparisons to calves sired by the most current, mainstream maximum growth EPD sires.... resulting in calves with very similar performance.
3) Some seedstock producers question the validity of EPDs. EPDs work, especially if high accuracy sires are used. However, in my opinion, EPDs have been used as a "marketing tool" more so than a genetic selection tool. Many traits within beef cattle (especially within the breeds that were originally viewed as the maternal breeds) have long since blown past the "optimum middle" representing the lower input match to their resource environment.
Let's move beyond the "noise" and shift our focus to "environmental sort" wherein the environment tells us which individuals have earned the right to be parents of the next generation.