Ahlemeyer Bakery

Call Directions

Ahlemeyer Bakery We are a small family bakery that has been in Columbus over 35 years! Ahlemeyer Bakery is a family owned and operated bakery in Columbus, Indiana.
(1)

We sell a variety of pies, cookies, brownies, sweet rolls, breads and other baked goods. We even carry the Indiana state pie- Sugar Cream! Our goal is quality, baking fresh products every day. Because of this we can run out quickly, so please feel free to call and place an order if there is something specific you are looking for. Our number is 812-372-7437. Great for holidays, birthdays, special gatherings, or for no occasion at all!

New Flavor Alert!!Come by the Bakery and try our new Dark Chocolate Cherry BrowniesOur fudge brownies with dark chocolat...
10/16/2026

New Flavor Alert!!

Come by the Bakery and try our new Dark Chocolate Cherry Brownies

Our fudge brownies with dark chocolate chips and dehydrated tart cherries baked in, topped with chocolate frosting & tart cherry syrup!!

Happy Saturday, y'all! Today's special is Cobbler!The Bakery's Big Batch Mixer needs a little repair before we dive into...
10/10/2026

Happy Saturday, y'all!
Today's special is Cobbler!
The Bakery's Big Batch Mixer needs a little repair before we dive into Thanksgiving season, so while I wait for the new gaskets to come in, we will be featuring our fruit cobblers!
I have cherry, peach, & blackberry and 1 apple pie & 1 pumpkin pie!

09/29/2026

The Bakery will be *CLOSED* Sept 29th, Tuesday & Sept 30th, Wednesday, due to illness.

Story time: A customer messaged me over the weekend about making a special dessert for his 1 year anniversary. (So far, ...
09/23/2026

Story time:
A customer messaged me over the weekend about making a special dessert for his 1 year anniversary. (So far, so good! We love a thoughtful husband)
Have we ever made a *chocolate* tres leches? (No... But you bet I'm gonna try! Why have I never thought about that before?!)
And you better believe I made 2 ❤️

🎺 Today's Special! 🎺
Chocolate Tres Leches! 6$ each

09/08/2026

The Bakery is *CLOSED* today!

Open tomorrow, Wednesday, at noon!!

All the good smells are coming from outside today!❤️
09/05/2026

All the good smells are coming from outside today!❤️

Whats on the menu:

We will be out at Ye Olde Fish House from 830-1130

(( 2024 17th St, Columbus, IN 47201))

[[ On the very off chance you dont know where that is! Also, we need to talk if you havent eaten here yet!

Bring some extra dollars after 10 for some treats at Ahlemeyer Bakery!!]]

We are rockin' this morning! I have Lemon Bars, Berry Cobbler, & Key Lime today 🤓
09/05/2026

We are rockin' this morning! I have Lemon Bars, Berry Cobbler, & Key Lime today 🤓

As well as being the start of Labor Day Weekend, it's also *National Eat An Extra Dessert Day*!Come in for our Labor Day...
09/04/2026

As well as being the start of Labor Day Weekend, it's also *National Eat An Extra Dessert Day*!
Come in for our Labor Day Red, White, & Blue Sugar Cream!

Today has been Gluten-Free Day at the Bakery!Gluten-Free BrowniesGluten-Free Banana BreadGluten-Free SnickerdoodlesGlute...
09/03/2026

Today has been Gluten-Free Day at the Bakery!
Gluten-Free Brownies
Gluten-Free Banana Bread
Gluten-Free Snickerdoodles
Gluten-Free Vanilla Cupcakes (for tomorrow)

Give me 24-hours notice and almost anything in the bakery can be Gluten-Free!

Slices this week are PAYDAY & STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE!!
08/26/2026

Slices this week are PAYDAY & STRAWBERRY CHEESECAKE!!

Address

2034 17th Street
Columbus, IN
47201

Opening Hours

Tuesday 2pm - 6pm
Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 6pm
Saturday 10am - 2pm

Telephone

+18123727437

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Ahlemeyer Bakery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category