Butter Leaf Custom Catering

Butter Leaf Custom Catering Let's chat about your next custom event!

We are a small female-owned catering business offering custom dinner parties, catered events and personal chef services with focus on local & seasonal ingredients, creative flavors and impeccable presentation.

I had the privilege of cooking for the Edible Columbus’ summer dinner at Jorgensen Farms last year, and to say it was in...
06/12/2026

I had the privilege of cooking for the Edible Columbus’ summer dinner at Jorgensen Farms last year, and to say it was incredible would be an understatement.

The menu was inspired by summer in Italy - where dining al fresco is sacred, and peak-season produce speaks for itself.

Everything was served family-style, so the meal became about much more than just eating. It became about connection, conversation, and the timeless pleasure of dining together.

Thank you to for trusting me, and to Lily Glass for these stunning photos!

When life gets busy, having nourishing, thoughtfully prepared meals waiting for you at home can completely change your w...
06/09/2026

When life gets busy, having nourishing, thoughtfully prepared meals waiting for you at home can completely change your week.

My personal chef service is designed to take the planning, shopping, cooking, and mental load off your plate, while still giving you meals that feel personal, seasonal, and genuinely enjoyable to eat.

Here’s how it works:
▪️ We talk through your preferences, goals, schedule, and dietary needs
▪️ We create tailored weekly menus
▪️ Your meals are delivered ready to heat and enjoy throughout the week

It’s less about “meal prep” and more about creating ease, consistency, and a better daily rhythm.

One client described it better than I ever could 👇

“I knew investing in a personal chef would deliver variety, nutrition and exceptional flavor - but the true ROI was the gift of time and easing the mental load. Each meal is better than the one before! How is it possible? Carrie is such a talented chef and has helped to curate amazing meals week after week. It’s the best investment I have ever made... My life got an upgrade the moment I hired Chef Carrie.” - Regan

If having one less thing to think about sounds really good right now, let’s talk 💚

DM me to learn more.

There’s something about summer gatherings that just feels a little more relaxed ☀️People lingering around the table long...
06/05/2026

There’s something about summer gatherings that just feels a little more relaxed ☀️

People lingering around the table longer.
A drink in hand.
Music playing somewhere in the background.
Everyone slowly migrating toward the food.

Graduation parties, backyard dinners, family celebrations, team gatherings… this is one of my favorite seasons to cook for.

The goal is always the same: beautiful food that makes hosting feel easier and brings people together.

If you’re planning a summer gathering, I’d love to help make it special 🌿

06/02/2026

May was everything it needed to be 🫶

I catered graduation parties and watched families beam with pride.

I cooked private dinners for clients celebrating some pretty big life moments!

I nourished personal chef clients who trusted me with their weekly meals.

I had the honor of being a part of a retirement party.

Even with all of those incredible moments I got to be a part of, I was still able to build something completely new with in-flight catering services.

This month reminded me that I’m building something real. Something that matters. Something I’m proud of.

Thank you to everyone who made this month special. I’m feeling so grateful, and already thinking about what’s next!

Feast on this! In case you didn’t get a good look at last week’s catered light bites… My calendar fills up quickly, so p...
05/29/2026

Feast on this! In case you didn’t get a good look at last week’s catered light bites… 

My calendar fills up quickly, so please DM me about your summer and fall parties, special dinners, and corporate events now. 

What started as a joke on a wedding registry somehow turned into a full dinner party theme 😂🧀Ally added a giant parmesan...
05/26/2026

What started as a joke on a wedding registry somehow turned into a full dinner party theme 😂🧀

Ally added a giant parmesan wheel to her registry as a joke… and one of the parents actually bought it. Naturally, she decided the only reasonable next step was to throw a parmesan-themed birthday dinner party.

So we ran with it.

Swipe to see how I created a 5-course dinner with parmesan cheese in every single course! Yep, even dessert 😉 At least half of her Parmesan cheese wheel has now been used!

Moral of the story: Never joke about cheese. And if you do, call me! 😂

05/24/2026

I was so happy to sponsor the Ohio Regional Business Aviation Association event this week with a spread of light bites at the lovely, historic in downtown Columbus ✈️

As I launch Butter Leaf’s luxury in-flight dining services, I’m incredibly grateful for opportunities like this to share my creativity and connect with the aviation community. And I am so thankful for partners like Lauren for supporting, collaborating and helping spread the word about what I offer.

Things can only go up from here… literally ✨

Mother’s Day Brunch at Clō Wine Gallery & Lounge was a dream!Cooking with seasonal items is one of my favorite things to...
05/19/2026

Mother’s Day Brunch at Clō Wine Gallery & Lounge was a dream!

Cooking with seasonal items is one of my favorite things to do. Guests enjoyed a fresh spring menu featuring produce from and - because local ingredients make all the difference.

The Florentine Pie was hands down one of the best things I’ve ever made!!

Huge shoutout to Darcie (showing off her plating skills 🤩) for the extra hands and amazing energy. I couldn’t have done this without you!

Thank you Clō Wine Gallery & Lounge for inviting me. Don’t forget to keep an eye out for future events! You might see me in the near future 👀

I cook for moments you’ll remember for the rest of your life.Birthdays. Engagement. Promotions. Holiday gatherings. New ...
05/16/2026

I cook for moments you’ll remember for the rest of your life.

Birthdays. Engagement. Promotions. Holiday gatherings. New babies. Team celebrations.

One of my favorite parts of catering and hosting dinner parties is getting a front-row seat to some of the best moments in people’s lives. And I get to help bring everyone together through food.

You let me into the moments that matter most! There’s no better job in the world 🫶

Planning something special? Let’s make it delicious and special.

DM me and let’s talk menus!

Address

4661 Indianola Ave
Columbus, OH
43214

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Butter Leaf Custom Catering posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Butter Leaf Custom Catering:

Shortcuts

Share

Category