The Better Butter Cookie Company

The Better Butter Cookie Company Our mission is simple: to elevate the joy of everyday moments with pure butter cookies. Greetings! That's why I'm deeply committed to making a difference.
(3)

Visit my hotplate storefront https://www.hotplate.com/betterbuttercookiecompany I take immense pride in my roots as a native of Detroit, Michigan, where I was nurtured by the warmth of a family-run restaurant, renowned for my mother's delectable cookies. From an early age, I, along with my brother and childhood friends, ventured into the world of entrepreneurial spirit by selling cookies door-to-d

oor, instilling in me a strong work ethic. My lifelong journey with a passion for baking ignited when I received a cookbook and an easy-bake oven as a memorable Christmas gift. These experiences nurtured my love for crafting sweet delights. Today, I've evolved into an Autoimmune Health Coach, specializing in the Autoimmune Protocol—an advanced elimination diet. My role involves empowering clients to create their own sweet treats while ensuring complete transparency about their ingredients. Being a person with an autoimmune disease myself, I understand firsthand how challenging it can be to go to places and find no gluten-free or vegan options. At the Better Butter Cookie Company, I offer not only our classic pure butter cookies but also gluten-free and vegan options, ensuring that everyone can savor the magic of our treats. We also provide diabetic-friendly cookie choices for those who need them. One pivotal moment that changed my life was when my neighbors invited me to showcase my mom's old-fashioned, homemade, pure butter cookies at a local fair. To my astonishment, they became an instant sensation, marking the inception of the Better Butter Cookie Company. Our brand is a delightful tribute to the 1950s, reminiscent of beloved TV shows like "I Love Lucy," "Andy Griffith," and "Dick Van Dyke." My fascination with the fashion and nostalgia of simpler times is deeply ingrained in our brand's ethos. As they say, life is sweeter with cookies, and everything is better with butter! I invite you to indulge in the timeless joy of Better Butter Cookies. Place your order today, and I eagerly anticipate sharing the magic of these classic treats with you!

09/05/2026

I really thought I was about to RUN OUT of cookies today. 😂

I brought about 100 cookies to Broadway Boutique thinking, “If I sell all these, that would be a GREAT day.”

By 2 PM, I was down to around 40.

By the time I packed up?

About 10 left. 😳

What got me most was seeing so many of my regulars come find me at a brand-new location. Y’all did not have to do that, and I appreciate it more than you know.

I also got to meet Jana B Sparkles and Catherine from Longhorn Coffee Trailer—two really fun highlights from an already great day.

Thank you to Carissa Ann, the Broadway Boutique team, everybody who shared the posts, and every single person who stopped by, grabbed cookies, and supported Better Butter Cookie Company.

Y’all showed OUT today. 🍪

Have a safe and happy Labor Day weekend!

09/04/2026

Here till sellout.

NEW this weekend — and she’s bringing grandma’s kitchen with her. 🍍🥥Meet the Hummingbird Cake Cookie — a soft, old-fashi...
09/04/2026

NEW this weekend — and she’s bringing grandma’s kitchen with her. 🍍🥥

Meet the Hummingbird Cake Cookie — a soft, old-fashioned cookie inspired by the Southern classic, finished with pineapple, coconut, toasted walnuts, and that sweet hummingbird-cake goodness.

I’m bringing a limited batch, so once they’re gone, they’re gone.

Find Better Butter Cookie Company this weekend at:

Friday | Broadway Boutique | 11 AM–5 PM
Sunday | Bryan Symphony Orchestra at Dogwood Park | 5–9 PM

And yes… the full cookie lineup is coming with me, including Classic Chocolate Chip, Cookies & Cream, Peanut Butter Bliss, Nutella Bliss, Snickerdoodle, and Grandma’s Campfire Dream.

Come grab a Hummingbird before I decide this one belongs permanently on the menu. 😂

Which cookie are you coming for?

09/03/2026
09/03/2026

The new Hummingbird Cake Cookie is coming out in a limited batch this weekend.

Banana, pineapple, toasted coconut, walnuts, warm spice, and a light glaze — basically a Southern hummingbird cake turned into one big grandma-style cookie.

You can catch Better Butter Cookie Company at:

Friday — Broadway Boutique Mall, 11–5
Sunday — Bryan Symphony Orchestra at Dogwood Park, 5–9

Limited batch means limited batch. Once they’re gone, they’re gone.

09/03/2026

Oreo has been getting credit for somebody else’s idea for over 100 years. 👀

The chocolate sandwich cookie that came first? Hydrox—in 1908. Oreo didn’t show up until 1912.

And somehow, Oreo became the name everybody remembers.

Meanwhile, Auntie Tee is over here making the chocolate wafers from scratch for Better Butter’s Cookies & Cream. Because if I can make it myself, you already know I probably will. 😂

🍪 Get yours this weekend:

Friday, Sept. 4 | 11 AM–5 PM
Broadway Boutique

Sunday, Sept. 6 | 5–9 PM
Bryan Symphony Orchestra at Dogwood Park

Come get your Cookies & Cream before they’re gone.

Now you know what Auntie Tee knows.

One thing I’m learning about building a small business is that you really don’t build it by yourself.This week feels lik...
09/02/2026

One thing I’m learning about building a small business is that you really don’t build it by yourself.

This week feels like a pretty good example of that.

Friday, Better Butter Cookie Company will be popping up at Broadway Boutique Mall from 11–5 in downtown Cookeville. Broadway is home to products from local vendors and makers, and I’ll be setting up there as the featured popup for the day.

Then Sunday, the Cookie Camper will be at Dogwood Park for the Bryan Symphony Orchestra, an organization that has been bringing live music to this area for decades and helping introduce local children to the arts through its education programs.

And that first photo? That was taken by Heather Good Photography.

If you own a business and you’re trying to build an actual brand—not just post random pictures of what you sell—good brand photography makes a difference. Heather helps businesses create professional photos and visual content that actually tell the story behind what they do.

That’s really what this weekend reminds me of.

A photographer helping businesses tell their story.

A downtown boutique making space for local makers.

A nonprofit bringing music and culture into the community.

And me, somewhere in the middle of it all, still showing up with butter cookies.

That’s what local business looks like to me.

Supporting each other.
Showing up.
Making something worth coming back for.

Friday — Broadway Boutique Mall, 11–5
Sunday — Bryan Symphony Orchestra at Dogwood Park

09/01/2026

Some businesses start with a business plan.

Mine started with butter cookies.

With memories of my mama selling them door-to-door. With old-fashioned recipes. And with the belief that maybe there was still room in this world for cookies that tasted like somebody’s grandma had made them.

I didn’t know exactly what Better Butter Cookie Company would become.

I just kept baking.

One batch became another.
One customer told another.
One pop-up led to the next.

And somewhere along the way, those little butter cookies became a business that keeps stretching me, surprising me, and growing right along with me.

It hasn’t been overnight. And it sure hasn’t been perfect.

But one cookie at a time, we’re getting there.

What’s something you started small that became more than you ever expected?

Cookie cravings? We’ve got you. 🍪✨Better Butter Cookie Company is popping up at Broadway Boutique Mall this Friday, Sept...
08/31/2026

Cookie cravings? We’ve got you. 🍪✨

Better Butter Cookie Company is popping up at Broadway Boutique Mall this Friday, September 4, from 11 AM–5 PM!

📍 107 W. Broad Street, Cookeville

Come grab your grandma-style cookie fix, say hey to Auntie Tee, and stock up before they’re gone. Because sometimes “just one more cookie” is exactly the right answer. 😏🍪

Friday, September 4 | 11–5
Broadway Boutique Mall

Tag your cookie person and tell them where y’all are going Friday. 💕

Address

17 W. Spring Street
Cookeville, TN
38501

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 5pm
Wednesday 11am - 5pm
Thursday 11am - 5pm
Friday 11am - 5pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Better Butter Cookie Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Better Butter Cookie Company:

Share

Category