The Salem Pie Company

11/19/2025

Don’t forget to place that pie order in by Sunday!! Today’s pie spotlight is sweet cherry pie!This filling is sweet and tart and just perfect with ice cream, order yours for Thanksgiving!!

11/16/2025

Pecan pie is our spotlight pie this Sunday!! This pie is a perfectly set up gooey middle with a crunchy pecan top! I love it warmed up or cold!! Order yours today for the big turkey day next week!!!

11/11/2025

For our pie spotlight today I want to talk about our Salted Carmel Apple Pie! This pie is an absolute delight, it is sweet and salty, just the perfect combo to add with a big scoop of vanilla ice cream! This is a huge seller for us on Thanksgiving because it just screams fall!! Order yours today for this Thanksgiving!!!

11/10/2025

For our pie spotlight I want to talk about our sugar cream pie! If you are a Hoosier, you know we are serious about our sugar cream pie! Here at Salem Pie we take that to heart and believe we have the BEST sugar cream this side of the Mississippi!!! Order yours for your Thanksgiving feast!! And as always thank you for letting us serve you this holiday!!!

11/09/2025

We have our menu active for Thanksgiving! If you would like to place an order for pick up, please send us a message and we would love to serve you this holiday season!

10/26/2025

Salem Pie Co is defrosting!!
Look out for our Thanksgiving menu soon!!

11/28/2024

Thank you all for your support this year for Thanksgiving! We had our best year yet!!! We hope you enjoy time with friends and family and of course enjoy PIE!!!!!

11/12/2024

If you know anyone who needs some joy this Thanksgiving, an awesome customer decided they wanted to buy 24 pies for us to give away to local people for the holiday! Message us at The Willow Creek Collective with a name, address and time of the people you would like us to bring a pie to!

We're down only two pies, with 22 to go! We know there are people out there who could use an extra bit of joy. All we need is a name, address, and preferred delivery time on the Wednesday before Thanksgiving, dropped into our inbox! Pies that are available for this giveaway are pumpkin, cherry, sugar cream and pecan! Don’t delay…reach out to us soon!

11/01/2024

It is that time again! We will be baking and selling pies for Thanksgiving 2024!

We are going a little different direction by asking you to email your order to [email protected].

You also have a opportunity to order at The Willow Creek Collective Farm Stand here in Daleville!

We love serving you all for the holiday season and look forward to hearing from you!! Happy holidays!

Please refer to the flyer for menu, pricing, and directions. If you have any questions don’t hesitate to ask!

10/21/2024

The Salem Pie Company is defrosting…Thanksgiving Menu coming SOON

07/15/2024

I am sending off our homemade “confetti” cake today for an awesome lady’s birthday! If you need a custom treat don’t forget to send us a DM!! ❤️

04/26/2024

Hello Pie People!!!
We are going to make pies for Mother’s Day!
What pies would you like to see on our menu?!