10/14/2026
We’ve eaten at a lot of Amish buffets in Indiana. We finally have an opinion on which one is better.
Das Dutchman Essenhaus in Middlebury and Blue Gate Restaurant in Shipshewana are both all-you-can-eat Amish buffets - fried chicken, egg noodles, mashed potatoes, homemade pie. They’re 13 minutes apart. And they’re not the same.
Essenhaus wins on food. The fried chicken is less greasy, better texture, better crust. Blue Gate adds a 1,700-seat performing arts theater and a 7,000-square-foot craft barn next door - it’s a full half-day destination.
A few things to know before you go: both are closed Sundays. Pie is included in the Blue Gate buffet. At Essenhaus, it’s $3.99 a slice upcharge - order it anyway.
Full breakdown: muchtobedone.com/das-dutchman-essenhaus-vs-blue-gate
Essenhaus Blue Gate Restaurant & Theatre