09/21/2026
In 1984, the State of Idaho sent armed deputies to take children from their homes and threw their parents in jail.
The charge? Educating their own children at home.
Three brothers and their wives in New Plymouth, sixteen children between them, chose to teach their kids themselves. At the time, Idaho law said a child had to be "comparably instructed, as may be determined by the trustees of the school district." That one vague phrase let local officials decide whether your teaching measured up, and if they didn't like the answer, they could bury you in it. These parents were convicted, put on probation, and when they wouldn't hand their children over to the district's terms, the judge sentenced all six of them to six months in the Payette County jail. And the state went after the children, too. In January 1985, armed sheriff's deputies arrived at the family's home and took the children away into foster care, while their parents stood by, helpless to stop it.
Their answer was simple: "They're my children. There's no doubt God gave them to us."
Idaho became one of the freest states in the country to homeschool only because that injustice sparked a movement that spent years fixing the law so it could never happen again. A descendant of that very family, Brandon Shippy, serves in the Idaho Senate today.
But here's what every Idaho family should understand: that freedom lives in statute. What one legislature grants, another can take back. Scroll the comments on my post from last night and you'll find Idahoans, right now, demanding the state regulate homeschoolers, set standards, decide which parents are fit. The impulse that jailed those parents never went away.
That's why I'm proposing one line for Idaho's Bill of Rights: "The right of the people to educate their children outside of the public schools of the state shall not be infringed."
Not a program. Not a dollar. A promise, placed where no future legislature can quietly erase it, that Idaho will never again jail a parent or seize a child over how that child is taught.
"Freedom is a fragile thing," Reagan said. "It is never more than one generation away from extinction."
Let's put this one beyond their reach.
Had you heard of the Shippy story? Tell me in the comments.
And if it's new to you, share it. This is our history, and it's exactly why this freedom belongs in the constitution.