10/09/2026
Ristorante Bartolotta dal 1993 – Wauwatosa, WI
Overall: A-
Bread - Focaccia and Ciabatta
Zuppa Alla Canavesana - Hearty winter bread soup with beef broth, pancetta, cabbage and parmigiano, baked until bubbly and golden.
Morbidelle Di Caprino Con Polenta Taragna E Fonduta Piemontese - Warm goat cheese with creamy buckwheat polenta and classic Piemontese cheese sauce
Uovo In Ravioli “Maestro Valentino” - Large egg yolk, ricotta, and spinach raviolo with brown butter and Parmigiano
Agnolotti Del Plin Al Sugo D’Arrosto - Piemontese meat-filled pasta with roasted veal jus
Frigate Miata Di Carne - Mixed grill: beef strip loin, pork ribs, lamb chop and Italian sausage, garlic-rosemary roasted potatoes
Coniglio All’Astigiana - Asti-style braised rabbit leg with w**e, fresh herbs and pancetta
Crema di Limone “Costa D’Amalfi” - Chilled lemon custard with toasted meringue
Torta Di Cioccolato Amaro - Flourless chocolate cake with vanilla bean crème anglaise
Filled cookie sandwiches
Overview – Ristorante Bartolotta dal 1993 is an Italian restaurant in Wauwatosa. They offer upscale regional Italian food in a quaint, small-medium space with a small bar. They focus their menu on a particular region of Italy, which they change seasonally. When I visited, I enjoyed their Piemonte menu.
Bread - Rosemary focaccia and ciabatta. Both chewy, properly crispy crust. Served with well-tempered flavorful butter.
Zuppa - Basically French onion soup on steroids. Broth-soaked bread and tender cabbage with a matrix of melty cheese. Rich, comforting, and delightful. Achieved arguably the highest praise I can give which is quickly finding a recipe and making this at home.
Goat Cheese – A mount of warm goat cheese covered in a suuuuper creamy polenta and smothered in cheese sauce. It was crazy to have warm goat cheese be the firmest texture in the dish. Cheese on cheese flavor.
Raviolo – A large raviolo swimming in brown butter, which was all I could taste with the dish. All other flavor nuances were covered up. The raviolo was fine, but the dish was just very out of balance out of balance. Needed some acidity and like 90% less butter.
Agnolotti – Pleasant, delicate. Good pasta, pleasant veal filling, but flavor felt too reserved for me.
Grigante – Really well cooked meat – lamb was particularly sweet, ribs were incredibly flavorful and tender, sausage was nice, beef was good but a little weaker. Potatoes were pleasant, greens (broccolini?) were absolutely incredible.
Rabbit - Good but hoped for more. Meat was tender but not unctuous. Sauce was flavorful with complexity, no noticeably pancetta pop.
Lemon Cream – Super creamy, brightly lemony, nice presentation and meringue texture.
Chocolate Tarte – Great chocolate flavor. Not as creamy as I’d like, slightly more on the pasty side. Nice vanilla bean in crème with dairy richness.
Sandwich Cookies – Nutty flavored cookies were on the crispy/hard side for their thickness. They were sandwiched around thick-set chocolate hazelnut filling.
Summary – Ristorante Bartolotta isn’t blowing up social media but they continue as one of Milwaukee’s stalwart greats.