Red Rooster Cookie Jar

Call Directions Website

Red Rooster Cookie Jar From the classroom to the kitchen after 25 years! Traded in lesson plans for recipes.
(3)

Retired middle school Spanish teacher, turned baker, ready for a new adventure! Pursuing a passion, Red Rooster Cookie Jar makes cookies from scratch the old school way, wooden spoon and all...Just like you would make if you had the time!

10/24/2026

🍪❤️ A LITTLE SLICE OF PENNSYLVANIA RIGHT HERE IN FLORIDA!

Yesterday, I took a little ride to Lady Lake to visit the most darling little cookie shop, Red Rooster Cookie Jar! 🐓🍪

Now, anyone who knows me knows that Molasses Cookies are my absolute FAVORITE. They’re not really much of a thing here in Florida, but back home in Pennsylvania, they’re practically a winter staple! 🤤❤️

Well, when I saw that she was advertising Molasses Cookies, I couldn’t help myself! I messaged her, asked her to save me a couple dozen (don’t judge me 🤣), and made sure they could go straight into my freezer. She assured me they freeze and thaw beautifully, and that was all the convincing I needed!

Y’all, what an absolutely adorable little shop!! So welcoming, with SO many delicious varieties of cookies to choose from!

It’s located right off 441 in Lady Lake, making it super easy to get in and out of, too!

If you’re ever in the area, do yourself a favor and stop in to say hello! Supporting another small business while satisfying my Pennsylvania cookie cravings? That’s a win-win in my book! 🙌🏼❤️

Trust me, you AND your belly will not be disappointed! 🍪🤭

🐔🚨FLOCK YEAH! IT'S CINNAMON ROLL SATURDAY! 🚨🐔SOUND THE ROOSTER ALARM! 📣Wake up, Lady Lake! The cinnamon rolls are HERE, ...
10/24/2026

🐔🚨FLOCK YEAH! IT'S CINNAMON ROLL SATURDAY! 🚨🐔

SOUND THE ROOSTER ALARM! 📣

Wake up, Lady Lake! The cinnamon rolls are HERE, and your breakfast plans just got a whole lot more interesting. 🤤💗

We have two reasons to abandon whatever sensible breakfast you were considering:

CINNAMON ROLL WITH YUM CRUMBS - for those who believe that if a little yum is good, MORE YUM IS BETTER.

CARAMEL PECAN CINNAMON ROLL - gooey, nutty, caramelly deliciousness that should probably come with its own fan club.

They are edible hugs.
They are weekend happiness.
They are the reason your stretchy pants have a dedicated hook by the door. 🤣

⚠️IMPORTANT CINNAMON ROLL SAFETY NOTICE:

Do not make eye contact with someone holding the last roll unless you are prepared to defend your position.

Do not say, "I'll just have a bite unless you are comfortable with being called a liar.

And NEVER assume there will be some left when you get here! 😂

COME EARLY. COME HUNGRY. COME THIRSTY FOR COFFEE. COME READY TO ENJOY EATING ON THE PORCH UNDER THE OAK TREES. LEAVE WITH A SWIRL IN YOUR HEART AND ICING ON YOUR FACE. 💗🐔

107 EAST LADY LAKE BLVD.
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com

Update: we also have whole pies in the case today! Key Lime, Cannoli, and My Nana’s Italian Almond Ricotta Cake!🚨🐔 ATTEN...
10/23/2026

Update: we also have whole pies in the case today! Key Lime, Cannoli, and My Nana’s Italian Almond Ricotta Cake!

🚨🐔 ATTENTION, CINNAMON ROLL ENTHUSIASTS! THIS IS YOUR OFFICIAL WARNING! 🐔🚨

Saturday is coming. And you know what that means...

CINNAMON. ROLL. SATURDAY. 🤤💗

Our bakers are preparing the swirly, gooey, icing-covered happiness that has people setting alarms, making plans, and possibly negotiating custody arrangements over the last roll. 😂

Classic Cinnamon Roll with Cinnamon Roll Yum Crumbs - because apparently, we looked at a cinnamon roll and thought, "You know what this needs? MORE YUM."

Caramel Pecan Cinnamon Rolls- gooey caramel, crunchy pecans, and absolutely no interest in behaving themselves.

This is not the weekend to say, "I'll just see what's left."

That sentence has broken hearts, disappointed taste buds, and left grown adults staring sadly at the empty counter. 😭🤣

Set your alarms. Make your plans. Locate your stretchy pants.
SATURDAY IS COMING, AND THE ROLLS ARE CALLING!

107 EAST LADY LAKE BLVD.
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com

🚨🍪COOP SCOOP! THIS WEEK'S COOKIE OF THE WEEK IS BRINGING BACK YOUR GRANDMA'S KITCHEN... AND POSSIBLY YOUR CHILDHOOD! 🍪🚨...
10/22/2026

🚨🍪COOP SCOOP! THIS WEEK'S COOKIE OF THE WEEK IS BRINGING BACK YOUR GRANDMA'S KITCHEN... AND POSSIBLY YOUR CHILDHOOD! 🍪🚨

Remember when Grandma baked molasses cookies? The house smelled like cinnamon, ginger, and pure happiness. The cookies were soft, chewy, perfectly spiced, and somehow Grandma always knew when you were sneaking a second one.

Well, butter our biscuits and call us nostalgic! 🐓💞
These beauties bring that old-fashioned, warm-spice goodness that makes you want to curl up with a cup of coffee and reminisce about the good ol' days.

You know, back when your knees worked, your back didn't make sound effects, and the only thing keeping you awake at night was wondering if you'd left a cookie in the kitchen. 🤣

One bite and you'll be transported straight to Grandma's kitchen.
Side effects may include:
🍪 Sudden childhood flashbacks.
💞 Uncontrollable smiling.
☕ An urgent need for coffee.
🐓 The phrase "I should've bought more." Remember once they're gone, that's it 'til next year!

107 EAST LADY LAKE BLVD.
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com

🚨🐓 IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT FROM THE STRETCHY PANTS DEPARTMENT! 🐓🚨We interrupt your regularly scheduled scrolling to bring...
10/21/2026

🚨🐓 IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT FROM THE STRETCHY PANTS DEPARTMENT! 🐓🚨

We interrupt your regularly scheduled scrolling to bring you a message of extreme importance.

There is a dangerous misconception circulating in our community that you must WAIT until the holidays to eat holiday worthy desserts.

WHO STARTED THIS NONSENSE?! 😱🤣

At Red Rooster Cookie Jar Bakery, we believe in being prepared.

Prepared for unexpected company.
Prepared for a bad day.
Prepared for a good day.
Prepared for that moment when you open the refrigerator at 8:47pm and suddenly remember there's a cheesecake.

THAT is what we call responsible adulting. 🤣

Our bakers are busy making the good stuff, our coffee is ready to help you face your responsibilities, and our stretchy pants are standing by for whatever happens next.

And if you're already planning your Thanksgiving and Christmas desserts, our holiday preorder menus are LIVE!

Come see us at 107 EAST LADY LAKE BLVD. I
Where calories are just tiny circles of happiness... and stretchy pants are a perfectly reasonable business expense. 🤣💞

M-F: 9-4
SAT. 10-5
352-204-0201

🚨🍗🎄HOLIDAY PREORDERS ARE LIVE, PEOPLE! THIS IS NOT A DRILL! 🎄🍗🚨Thanksgiving and Christmas are coming faster than Aunt Ca...
10/20/2026

🚨🍗🎄HOLIDAY PREORDERS ARE LIVE, PEOPLE! THIS IS NOT A DRILL! 🎄🍗🚨

Thanksgiving and Christmas are coming faster than Aunt Carol when somebody says, "Who wants the last piece of pie?" 😂

And Red Rooster Cookie Jar bakery is here to save your holiday dessert table, your sanity, AND your family's reputation.

We've got holiday goodies that will make your guests think you've been secretly attending pastry school. 🤣

🍪 Oatmeal Cream Pies
🥧 Cannoli Pie
🎃 Pumpkin Rolls
🍰 SPECIAL holiday cheesecake flavors
❤️ And plenty more deliciousness to make your stretchy pants nervous!

Let's be honest. Every family has:
🐓 The relative who volunteers YOU to bring dessert.
🥧 Uncle Bob, who says he's "just having a sliver" and returns with a slice the size of a dinner plate.
🍪 The cookie thief who claims they "only took one" while standing over an empty platter.
👀 And that ONE person who eats nothing but the bright red and green M&Ms because apparently, they're on a very strict holiday diet. 🤦‍♀️🤣

DON'T LET YOUR HOLIDAY DESSERT TABLE BECOME A CRIME SCENE.

Place your holiday preorder with us and let RED ROOSTER handle the sweet stuff!

🎄Our holiday menus are LIVE NOW! Head to rrcookiejar.com to get your holiday goodies ordered. Be sure to click on either THANKSGIVING or CHRISTMAS.

Because nothing says "I love you" quite like showing up with dessert that makes people forget what they were arguing about 5 minutes ago.

107 EAST LADY LAKE BLVD.
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201

🐓🍪COOP SCOOP! THIS WEEK'S COOKIE OF THE WEEK IS MOLASSES! 🍪🐓🚨BREAKING NEWS FROM THE COOKIE JAR: GRANDMA'S CALLING... SHE...
10/19/2026

🐓🍪COOP SCOOP! THIS WEEK'S COOKIE OF THE WEEK IS MOLASSES! 🍪🐓

🚨BREAKING NEWS FROM THE COOKIE JAR: GRANDMA'S CALLING... SHE WANTS HER COOKIE RECIPE BACK! 🚨

Well, Grandma can come on down to Red Rooster Cookie Jar because we're bringing BACK THAT OLD-FASHIONED, MOLASSES COOKIE MAGIC! ❤️🍪

Remember when Grandma's kitchen smelled like warm spices, fresh-baked cookies, and a little bit of childhood happiness? When the cookie jar was ALWAYS full... unless Grandpa had been "checking the inventory" again? 🤣

When a cookie was a cookie, a glass of milk was practically mandatory, and getting caught sneaking one before dinner earned you THE LOOK?

👀You know the look. The one that could stop a freight train, silence three children, and make Grandpa suddenly remember he had somewhere else to be.

One bite and you'll be 8 years old again, standing on tiptoes trying to reach the cookie jar. One more bite and you'll be explaining to your family that you're not eating cookies before dinner... You're PRESERVING FAMILY HISTORY. 🤣🤣🤣

⚠️A WORD OF CAUTION FROM THE HEN HOUSE:

🐓 May cause uncontrollable flashbacks to Grandma's kitchen.
🍪 May trigger the phrase, "I'll just have ONE."
🤔 May result in wondering why you ever wasted calories on cookies that weren't THIS good.
👖 May require the immediate deployment of your official bakery uniform: STRETCHY PANTS.
❤️ May cause you to call your mother and ask if she still has Grandma's recipe.

107 EAST LADY LAKE BLVD.
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com

🐓😂 ATTENTION, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN: THE ROOST HAS ISSUED AN OFFICIAL PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT!Having one of those day...
10/18/2026

🐓😂 ATTENTION, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN: THE ROOST HAS ISSUED AN OFFICIAL PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT!

Having one of those days?

Burned the toast?
Lost your keys?
Your family driving you absolutely BANANAS? 🍌
Looked at your bank account and briefly considered moving into a tent?

WE HAVE A SOLUTION!
It's called BAKERY THERAPY. ❤️🍪

Side effects may include:

🍪 Smiling uncontrollable at cookies
🍰 Suddenly believing everything is going to be okay
🥐 Making questionable decisions in the pastry department
☕ Remembering that coffee and a sweet treat can turn a day around
🐓 Accidentally becoming a regular because, well... YOU LIVE HERE NOW!

At Red Rooster Cookie Jar Bakery, we're serving up more than cookies, cakes, cinnamon rolls, and other dangerously delicious goodies.

We're serving up little moments of happiness, one sweet bite at a time. ❤️😁

And unlike your last online shopping spree, YOU CAN EAT THE EVIDENCE. 🤣🤣🤣
So swing by, say hello, grab yourself something delicious, and let us put a little sweetness back into your day!
RED ROOSTER COOKIE JAR bakery where your sweet tooth is family, your stretchy pants are always welcome, and we offer napkins for car snacks because we are a no judgement zone!

107 EAST LADY LAKE BLVD.
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com

🐓🚨FLOCK YEAH! IT'S CINNAMON ROLL SATURDAY!!! 🚨🐓Everybody ROLL OUT OF BED! The cinnamon rolls are READY, and your Saturd...
10/17/2026

🐓🚨FLOCK YEAH! IT'S CINNAMON ROLL SATURDAY!!! 🚨🐓

Everybody ROLL OUT OF BED! The cinnamon rolls are READY, and your Saturday just got a whole lot SWEETER! 🍥🤤

Our jumbo cinnamon rolls are soft, gooey, cinnamon-loaded bundles of happiness, topped with frosting that'll make you forget every bad decision you've ever made.

Well... except the decision to eat just ONE.

Because let's be honest. That's an ambitious goal. 🤣🤣🤣

⚠️WARNING: SIDE EFFECTS MAY INCLUDE:
🤤 Excessive drooling
😍 Uncontrollable happy dancing
👖 Sudden appreciation for stretchy pants
🙋‍♀️ Saying "I'll just have half" and immediately regretting the lie

And remember, our cinnamon rolls have been known to disappear faster than free samples at Costco!

🐓PREORDERS ARE YOUR FRIENDS, PEOPLE! If you haven't reserved yours, come early while supplies last!

Where calories are just tiny circles of happiness... and Saturdays were made for rolling with the dough! 😂❤️

107 EAST LADY LAKE BLVD.
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com

🚨🐔BREAKING NEWS: THE ROLLS ARE MOBILIZING!!! 🐔🚨Attention, flock! Put down whatever you're doing and listen carefully. TH...
10/16/2026

🚨🐔BREAKING NEWS: THE ROLLS ARE MOBILIZING!!! 🐔🚨

Attention, flock! Put down whatever you're doing and listen carefully.

THIS SATURDAY, THE CINNAMON ROLL PERFECT PAIR RETURNS! 🤯🤣

PLAIN WITH CINNAMON ROLL YUM CRUMBS: Because apparently a regular cinnamon roll wasn't enough. We had to put a party on top of a party!

CARAMEL PECAN: Gooey caramel. Crunchy pecans. Cinnamon roll goodness. Basically, a dessert wearing a fancy evening gown.

TWO FLAVORS. ONE BAKERY. ABSOLUTELY NO GUARANTEE YOUR STRETCHY PANTS WILL SURVIVE. 👖💥

Last time, those caramel pecan beauties sold out in 20 minutes!

TWENTY. MINUTES.

That's barely enough time to say, "I'll just have one."

Spoiler alert: NOBODY EVER JUST HAS ONE. 😂

🐓 SATURDAY IS COMING. THE ROLLS ARE RISING. YOUR WAISTBAND IS NERVOUS. Stay tuned for the big roll call!
FLOCK YEAH! LET'S GET READY TO RUUUUUMBLE... I mean, ROLL! 🤣❤️

107 EAST LADY LAKE BLVD.
M-F: 9-4
SAT: 10-5
352-204-0201
rrcookiejar.com

Address

107 E. Lady Lake Boulevard
Lady Lake, FL
32159

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 4pm
Tuesday 9am - 4pm
Wednesday 9am - 4pm
Thursday 9am - 4pm
Friday 9am - 4pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm

Telephone

+13522040201

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Red Rooster Cookie Jar posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category