Nana's Cookie Jar

04/02/2026

Dana Rankin your eggs are ready for pick up today by 5. Didn’t know if you remembered. Thank you!

04/01/2026

Just reminding those of you who ordered peanut butter, coconut, or buttercream eggs to pick them up Thursday between 10 and 4 PM! Thank you!🥚🍫✝️

03/26/2026

Ready for pick up!

03/16/2026

Husband needs “St Patrick’s Day” peanut butter eggs for tomorrow!

03/11/2026

Don’t forget! Place orders now for your peanut butter, coconut or buttercream eggs dipped in milk or dark chocolate, $20 per dozen. Pick up Thursday, March 26 or Thursday, April 2. Christy Rabold DonmoyerJodi KreiserBrittany LisaJodi D. Ryman Fells

03/01/2026

Place orders now for your peanut butter, coconut or buttercream eggs dipped in milk or dark chocolate, $20 per dozen. Pick up Thursday, March 26 or Thursday, April 2.

02/12/2026

Peanut butter egg orders will be coming in a couple of weeks!

01/28/2026

FOR VALENTINE’s DAY
PICK UP Friday, February 13

Peanut butter pie $20 (9”)
Chocolate Whoopie pies with vanilla cream or peanut butter filling $25/ doz
Red velvet cheesecake brownies $20/pan (12x8”)

12/15/2025

December 16 is the last day to order Christmas cookies, peanut butter balls, or anything else for Christmas pick up on December 23.

12/09/2025

12/06/2025