Not Just a Cookie

Not Just a Cookie Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Not Just a Cookie, Liverpool, NY.

Had so much fun bringing these Yoshi cookies to life 💚🍪I love how bright and clean these turned out — definitely one of ...
05/31/2026

Had so much fun bringing these Yoshi cookies to life 💚🍪

I love how bright and clean these turned out — definitely one of those sets that’s hard to box up because you just want to keep staring at them 😍

Perfect for any Mario-themed party or gamer celebration 🎮✨

If you’re thinking about custom cookies for your next event, feel free to message me! limited availability 💌

Had so much fun creating this Minecraft-themed birthday set for Liam! 🎮💚From Creepers to TNT to the sweetest little Ende...
05/23/2026

Had so much fun creating this Minecraft-themed birthday set for Liam! 🎮💚

From Creepers to TNT to the sweetest little Enderman holding a cake 🎂—every cookie is hand-decorated with royal icing and lots of love.

Custom sets are always one of my favorites to bring to life! If you have a party theme in mind, I’d love to create something special for you too ✨

Simple, elegant, and full of meaning ✨These First Communion cookies feature classic white crosses with delicate gold det...
05/04/2026

Simple, elegant, and full of meaning ✨

These First Communion cookies feature classic white crosses with delicate gold detailing—perfect for celebrating such a special and sacred day. 🤍

Limited availability for upcoming dates—message me to reserve your set.

Not Just a Cookie

Oh boy 💙This sweet baby shower set was all about soft textures, cozy details, and the dreamiest shades of blue. From the...
04/28/2026

Oh boy 💙

This sweet baby shower set was all about soft textures, cozy details, and the dreamiest shades of blue. From the knit-style onesies to the classic “oh boy” cookies, every piece was made to celebrate a very special little one on the way ✨

Custom cookie sets are available for baby showers, birthdays, and special events—designed to match your theme perfectly.

✨ Limited availability for upcoming dates
Message me to reserve your spot 💌

Jungle baby shower cookies for Baby O’Connor 🌿Soft sage greens, warm neutrals, and the cutest little safari friends.Whic...
03/16/2026

Jungle baby shower cookies for Baby O’Connor 🌿
Soft sage greens, warm neutrals, and the cutest little safari friends.

Which one is your favorite? The monkey, lion, elephant, or giraffe? 🥹


Wait until you see the gold details on this bridal shower cookie set ✨💍Blush, gold, and a little bridal magic for Kelsey...
03/06/2026

Wait until you see the gold details on this bridal shower cookie set ✨💍

Blush, gold, and a little bridal magic for Kelsey before she becomes Mrs. 🤍

Which cookie is your favorite? 💗



(sorry for all the pics I couldn’t decide which to use) 😊

Just a cute little winter set ❄️🤍💙🥶
02/19/2026

Just a cute little winter set ❄️🤍💙🥶

7th birthday set for a sweet girl with her favorite things done in her favorite colors . 🩷🤍
02/16/2026

7th birthday set for a sweet girl with her favorite things done in her favorite colors . 🩷🤍

A sweet hedgehog for a special little boys 6th Birthday! 🦔🤎❤️
02/14/2026

A sweet hedgehog for a special little boys 6th Birthday! 🦔🤎❤️

Sweet little spa day for a 7th birthday 💖🧖‍♀️Pink, turquoise, and lots of birthday fun!
02/06/2026

Sweet little spa day for a 7th birthday 💖🧖‍♀️
Pink, turquoise, and lots of birthday fun!

Address

Liverpool, NY
13090

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Not Just a Cookie posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Not Just a Cookie:

Shortcuts

Share