09/27/2026
Making yogurt is so easy! I started doing it years ago because I was tired of "extras" in the ingredients as well as a recycling β»οΈ bin full of little tubs I doubted were really being recycled. In a perfect world, I'd have my own cow π or goat π , but I'm OK with not doing it all. I just buy regular old organic whole milk and a box of these starter culture packets.
1. Heat 1 qt milk to 185Β° or so. I've found it's not an exact science. You just don't want to boil or burn the milk, so I do it slow and low, stirring often.
2. Let the milk cool to about 110Β°, then add the culture and stir.
3. Pour into jars. These jars came with my yogurt maker. You can use any size Mason jar too.
4. Place jars into the yogurt maker. They aren't too expensive and are basically fancy shaped heating pads. You can also use a heating pad for plants, placed in a cooler. Some dehydrators and air fryers, or other specialty appliances have a setting for yogurt or dough proofing (I think that's what it's called, my bread making skills are sub-par). You just want it to maintain a temperature around 105Β° for at least 8 hours. I often have it sit 12 because it finished while I'm asleep. You can go even longer if you want. Some people do 24 hours. The longer, the more bacteria, less lactose and tangy-er flavor.
5. Cover and refrigerate. It'll last about a week before it gets moldy on top.
6. You can save some of this batch to use as a starter for the next batch, but I've found it doesn't come out as smooth and sometimes fails all together. My third round never came out well. I just use a new packet of dry starter.
Cows milk works best. I've had some success with goats milk. I think a different culture might work better. For me, cows milk is just more readily accessible.