Cookie Magic

Cookie Magic Custom sugar cookies, party decor, and holiday activity kits ✨ Making magic easy for every occasion

Cookie Magic brings a touch of sweetness and creativity to every celebration. Based in Maplewood, NJ, I craft custom sugar cookies that not only look amazing but taste even better. Whether you're planning a wedding, shower, birthday, or need a delightful gift box, I’d love to create something magical just for you. Let's make your next event unforgettable with cookies that are as special as your celebration!

⚾ Celebrating the end of a baseball season with these custom cookies designed to look just like the team's jerseys... cu...
08/29/2026

⚾ Celebrating the end of a baseball season with these custom cookies designed to look just like the team's jerseys... customized with the players' names and numbers of course!

🐶🐾 Happy National Dog DayRemembering this custom set designed to look just like my clients' two dogs so they could be a ...
08/26/2026

🐶🐾 Happy National Dog Day

Remembering this custom set designed to look just like my clients' two dogs so they could be a part of their wedding too!

🐢🍕Cowabunga! I recently made this custom TMNT set for a special 6th birthday right here in the SOMA.Are you celebrating ...
08/25/2026

🐢🍕Cowabunga! I recently made this custom TMNT set for a special 6th birthday right here in the SOMA.

Are you celebrating something special this Fall? Bring your party theme to life with custom sugar cookies— submit your order request now!

Marking 90 years with beautiful blue hydrangeas!
08/20/2026

Marking 90 years with beautiful blue hydrangeas!

💍These cookies are extra special because they were made to celebrate the wedding of one of my oldest friend’s son!Wishin...
08/17/2026

💍These cookies are extra special because they were made to celebrate the wedding of one of my oldest friend’s son!

Wishing the couple a lifetime of happiness (and cookies)!!

🍎📝 It's the time you've been waiting for (and I know that because of just how many messages I've received asking about B...
08/15/2026

🍎📝 It's the time you've been waiting for (and I know that because of just how many messages I've received asking about Back to School cookies)!!

Orders are open from now through Sunday, August 22.

Free SOMA delivery on Monday, August 31, or you can pickup at my Maplewood location between 3-9pm on August 31.

⏰Limited quantities available. Don't miss out on my most highly anticipated sale of the year!

🍌This 10-year old and her friends are obsessed with squishies and NeeDohs...so we turned some of her favorites into cook...
08/10/2026

🍌This 10-year old and her friends are obsessed with squishies and NeeDohs...

so we turned some of her favorites into cookies for her party!

😀🌸 It's a smiley face/flower power theme for this 6-year-old's birthday party!We even tied in the bubble-themed venue wi...
08/08/2026

😀🌸 It's a smiley face/flower power theme for this 6-year-old's birthday party!

We even tied in the bubble-themed venue with the background print on the peace sign... I love adding in little details like these 🫧

🍼🐉 How cute is this baby dragon baby shower theme?Hatching soon!!
08/06/2026

🍼🐉 How cute is this baby dragon baby shower theme?

Hatching soon!!

I spoke too soon!🎓 *now* I'm finished with grad cookies for the yearCongrats to all the 2026 grads!
08/03/2026

I spoke too soon!

🎓 *now* I'm finished with grad cookies for the year

Congrats to all the 2026 grads!

Address

Maplewood, NJ
07040

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cookie Magic posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cookie Magic:

Shortcuts

Share

Category