Cookie Magic

Custom sugar cookies, party decor, and holiday activity kits ✨ Making magic easy for every occasion

Cookie Magic brings a touch of sweetness and creativity to every celebration. Based in Maplewood, NJ, I craft custom sugar cookies that not only look amazing but taste even better. Whether you're planning a wedding, shower, birthday, or need a delightful gift box, I’d love to create something magical just for you. Let's make your next event unforgettable with cookies that are as special as your celebration!

05/30/2026

🎓 Celebrating another local grad with these BU cookies!

05/28/2026

🥍 These cookies were a small way to sweeten a day that was all about honoring my customer's friend, who was a beloved member of their collegiate lacrosse team

05/27/2026

Happy ribbon cutting day to !!

05/23/2026

🍪 What can you expect from my cookie decorating classes?

🏖 A fun night out with friends
🏖 To make your own delicious art
🏖 All the supplies you need-- including pre-baked cookies and prepared icing
🏖 Step-by-step instruction-- no experience necessary!

🌞 Join me at South Orange-Maplewood Adult School on Wednesday, Jun 3 from 7-9pm to make these beachy cookies! I guarantee you'll impress yourself!

🔗 Sign up now (link in bio)

05/19/2026

Stitch-themed birthday party? No problem, I've got it!

05/16/2026

🎓 It's that time of year!

Every year I'm lucky enough to help local families celebrate graduations and bring some sweet school spirit to their event

First up, University of Maryland!

05/14/2026

⚾️🧢 I don't break out the airbrush all that often these days, but it was a necessity to add that little something extra to these vintage baseball themed birthday cookies!

05/10/2026

🌈🦋 This set of first communion cookies is for a girl who loves rainbows!

So I tweaked my original design mockup to add some rainbow touches to these otherwise gold and white cookies. And I have to say I love the end result!

05/09/2026

First Holy Communion celebrations - two ways

I made two different cookie sets for families celebrating this milestone this year... and they're completely different!

Each time I design a cookie set, it's completely customized to the recipient's interests, preferences, and themes.

🌸🍪 This first one is a gorgeous pink floral set, and stay tuned for tomorrow's, with a completely different vibe!

05/08/2026

🗓️ We're fully booked up for May and June is filling up fast!

Reach out now if you're looking for custom cookies for late June and beyond ☀️

Address

Maplewood, NJ
07040

Website

http://www.makemagiceasy.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cookie Magic posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cookie Magic:

Want your business to be the top-listed Food & Beverage Service in Maplewood?