10/07/2026
FISH TALES DINNER SPECIALS & OKTOBERFEST SPECIALS:
2026 GERMAN OKTOBERFEST MUG
$24.95 with $2.95 Refills ALL of October
2026 GERMAN OKTOBERFEST W**E GLASS
$19.95 with $2.95 Refills ALL of October
FRESH-MADE TO ORDER: Regular/Decaf Coffee & Espresso
FRESH SQUEEZED LIME-ADE
1/2 # STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $13.95 OR
WHOLE POUND STEAMED PEELED SHRIMP $25.95
FRIED ALLIGATOR APPETIZER $14.95
MUSHROOM POTSTICKERS W/ SIDE SESAME SOY $9.95
FRESH FRIED GREEN TOMOATOES W/ SIDE JOHNNY DRESSING $12.95
FRIED WISCONSIN CHEESECURDS W/ SIRRACHA MAYO $12.95
NEW: SURFSIDE VODKA ICED TEA- ISLAMORADA CITRUS ALE – TORPEDO IPA -COCONUT KEY LIME ALE -IPA VOODOO RANGER JUICY HAZE - SWEET WATER HAZY IPA NUTRL VODKA SELTZER WATERMELON- NUTRL VODKA SELTZER PINEAPPLE
FAMOSA B**R FROM GUATEMALA
HOMEMADE SOUP & CHOWDERS:
RED CONCH CHOWDER N.E. CLAM CHOWDER CRAWDAD CHOWDER
SIDE CHOICES:
COLESLAW FRENCH FRIES NEW POTATOES POTATO SALAD
GREEN BEANS APPLE SAUCE
DINNER SPECIALS
HOMEMADE SCALLOPED POTATOES & HAM W/ SIDE OF OUR GARLIC BREAD $16.95
FRIED YELLOWTAIL FISH SANDWICH & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER & SIDE $24.95
FRIED ROYAL RED SHRIMP PLATTER & SIDE… $19.95
FRIED OYSTER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95
HOMEMADE SHRIMP BURGER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE… $19.95
GROUPER SANDWICH Grilled OR Blackened & SIDE… $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95
COBIA FISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95
SWORDFISH SANDWICH Fried, Grilled or Blackened W/BLUE CHEESE SAUCE & SIDE $21.95 PLATTER $24.95
GRILLED SALMON PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95
FRIED GROUPER FINGER PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95
OUR SMOKED PORK CHOP W/ MASHED POTATOES/GRAVY & GREEN BEANS… $21.95
FRIED ALLIGATOR PLATTER WITH CHOICE OF SIDE $23.95
JOHNNY SALAD TOPPED w/ OUR PRIME FILET MIGNON TIPS… $23.95
HOGFISH SANDWICH Grilled, Blackened OR Fried & SIDE $21.95 OR PLATTER & SIDE $24.95
HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE HALF POUND PRIME BURGER W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Half Pound Burger Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese
WAGYU BURGER Topped W/ Maple Bacon Jam & Blue Cheese Sauce & SIDE… $18.95
HONEY PEPPER PIMENTO CHEESE CHICKEN SANDWICH W/ CHOICE OF SIDE… $18.95
Fried Chicken Topped With Our Honey Pepper Pimento Cheese
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE OR SAMOA COOKIE
CHOCOLATE CHIP FUDGE BROWNIE
GERMAN BLACK FOREST BROWNIE
TRADITIONAL CINNAMON BUN
STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE A’LA MODE
GERMAN CHOCOLATE CAKE
CARROT CAKE
COLOSSAL CHEESECAKE – Plain, Blueberry or Cherry Topping
BANANA COOKIE BUTTER CHEESECAKE
APPLE DUMPLING A’LA MODE
JOHNNY’S KEY LIME PIE
HOMEMADE PEANUT BUTTER PIE
ICE CREAM MUD PIE ON AN OREO CRUST – CHOCOLATE CHIP
GERMAN B**RS ON TAP
Paulaner Hefeweizen Erdinger Dunkel Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest
B**RS ON TAP
Coors Light Draft Iguana Bait Yuengling
PINOT GRIGIO WHITE ZINFINDEL CHARDONNAY
MOSCATO CABERNET RIESLING
FISH TALES CATOBERFEST
*GERMAN ENTREES COME WITH SAUERKRAUT AND A CHOICE OF POTATO PANCAKE,
NEW POTATOES, RED CABBAGE OR POTATO SALAD
SPECIAL MENU BENEFITING FORGOTTEN FELINES OF THE FLORIDA KEYS
RED ITEMS = $1 DONATED TO FORGOTTEN FELINES WITH EVERY PLATE ORDERED
Appetizer
“TYTY’S” PRETZEL • $12.95
Giant German Pretzel with B**r Cheese
Entrees
*“MEDICAL PLAZA CATS’” SAUSAGE SAMPLER & SIDE • $22.95
With Bratwurst, Kielbasa & Knackwurst, Kraut & Side
*“BIG POPPA’S” HAMBURGER • $17.95
*“RAMBO’S” DOUBLE HAMBURGER • $19.95
Char-Grilled Cheeseburger topped with B**r Cheese,
Sautéed Onion & Bacon on a Pretzel Bun
*ROAST PORK & KRAUT & SIDE • $18.95
*“SISSY 2’S” PORK OR CHICKEN SCHNITZEL & SIDE • $19.95
Lightly Breaded & Fried, topped with Sautéed Onion & Gravy
*PORK REUBEN & SIDE • $18.95
Topped with Kraut, Provolone Cheese & Our Mustard on Grilled Rye
PORK STROGANOFF OVER EGG NOODLES • $16.95
*SAUERBRATEN & SIDE • $19.95
Marinated Beef Brisket with Our Black Forest Gravy
*BEEF ROULADEN & SIDE • $22.95
Tenderized Beef, Rolled With Dill Pickle, Kraut, Cheese, Bacon,
Mustard Sauce, Lightly Breaded & Deep Fried
GERMAN OKTOBERFEST B**RS
“TOMCAT” ERDINGER DUNKEL
“COOL CAT” PAULANER HEFE-WEIZEN
“NINE LIVES” HACKER-PSCHORR OKTOBERFEST
GERMAN RIESLING W**E
THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING COMMUNITY CATS THROUGHOUT THE MIDDLE TO LOWER FLORIDA KEYS
Call now to connect with business.
