Bennett Shellfish

Bennett Shellfish Specializing in daily, locally caught seafood. Our Clam Pie is a must-try! Our seafood is handled, monitored, and refrigerated under strict sanitary conditions.
(1)

Your health and safety are our number one priority. Try our daily baked cakes and pies! Bennett Shellfish Montauk Est. 1600's. We are one of the East End's founding families. We have been working/harvesting the local bays and ocean for over 14 generations. All our products are grill and oven-ready, made fresh daily... Clam pies, Chowders, White Clam Sauce, Stuffed Clams, Stuffed Scallops, Fish Cak

es, Crab Bites, Seafood Pockets, and amazing desserts! Try our daily made cakes and pies, specializing in birthday and wedding cakes!

05/26/2026
05/26/2026

Gotta try the CLAM PIE! Bennett Shellfish

05/24/2026

Stop by and try it for yourself! 2 for 1 38.00!

05/21/2026
05/20/2026

Stop by for your CLAM PIE! Bennett Shellfish 631.903.5817 🥧🥧🥧

05/18/2026

2 for 1 Lobster Rolls 38.00!!

GIVE THE GIFT OF FRESH SEAFOOD FROM BENNETT’S! 631.903.5817
05/08/2026

GIVE THE GIFT OF FRESH SEAFOOD FROM BENNETT’S! 631.903.5817

05/01/2026

Gotta go to Bennett Shellfish Montauk! 2 for 1 Lobster Rolls!

04/26/2026

Address

2 S Debusy Road
Montauk, NY
11954

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 8pm
Tuesday 11am - 8pm
Wednesday 11am - 8pm
Thursday 11am - 8pm
Friday 11am - 8pm
Saturday 11am - 8pm
Sunday 11am - 8pm

Telephone

+16319035817

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Bennett Shellfish posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category