Pence Cookie Co.

Pence Cookie Co. Licensed home baker of delicious, hand-decorated custom sugar cookies in New Bethlehem, PA. Contact Pence Cookie Co. Also offering holiday and gift options!

if you want to make your next event extra special - weddings, showers, birthdays, and more!

06/10/2026
This week I was asked to make a set that I also made as one of my first sets back in 2022⬇️Inspo/2022/2026
06/08/2026

This week I was asked to make a set that I also made as one of my first sets back in 2022

⬇️Inspo/2022/2026

Happy first birthday to Blair! 🥳
06/07/2026

Happy first birthday to Blair! 🥳

🖤🤍
06/03/2026

🖤🤍

05/29/2026

Cookies ready for CCA recital weekend! 🧑🏼‍🩰💕

Anyone having a craving for some sugar cookies? I started decorating these but decided I didn’t like the shade of green ...
05/27/2026

Anyone having a craving for some sugar cookies? I started decorating these but decided I didn’t like the shade of green and remade them. There are 9 full-size cookies and 12 minis. $10 for all 🙃 and I can leave on my porch for you

Four dozen monster cookies up for grabs. Cookies are approximately 2 ounces each (large but not giant). Comment below to...
05/25/2026

Four dozen monster cookies up for grabs. Cookies are approximately 2 ounces each (large but not giant). Comment below to reserve a box. Available for porch pickup now.
$20/dozen

👩🏻‍🎓GRADUATION MINIS👨🏻‍🎓Limited number availableCustomize to your school colors (leave in comments)$10 per pack (will be...
05/24/2026

👩🏻‍🎓GRADUATION MINIS👨🏻‍🎓

Limited number available
Customize to your school colors (leave in comments)
$10 per pack (will be packaged in sleeve with bow)
Pickup Tuesday afternoon or after

SOLDOne 12” chocolate chip/m&m cookie cake available for porch pickup. $25. You may leave cash or Venmo ashleyjeannine15...
05/24/2026

SOLD

One 12” chocolate chip/m&m cookie cake available for porch pickup. $25. You may leave cash or Venmo ashleyjeannine15.

Address

New Bethlehem, PA
16242

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 2:30pm
Tuesday 9am - 2:30pm
Wednesday 9am - 2:30pm
Thursday 9am - 2:30pm
Friday 9am - 2:30pm

Telephone

+18142211063

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Pence Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Pence Cookie Co.:

Shortcuts

Share

Category