Pence Cookie Co.

Pence Cookie Co. Licensed home baker of delicious, hand-decorated custom sugar cookies in New Bethlehem, PA. Contact Pence Cookie Co. Also offering holiday and gift options!

if you want to make your next event extra special - weddings, showers, birthdays, and more!

09/04/2026
*THIS IS NOT MY PHOTO OR MY COOKIES. FOR EXAMPLE ONLY*My supplies are en route but I am taking preorders for….🥟 ✨MYSTERY...
09/04/2026

*THIS IS NOT MY PHOTO OR MY COOKIES. FOR EXAMPLE ONLY*

My supplies are en route but I am taking preorders for….

🥟 ✨MYSTERY DUMPLING SUGAR COOKIES✨🥟

There will be five possible color options including one “rare” glitter dumpling cookie. The cookie you get is completely random!

$5 each and the tentative pickup date is 9/18. If my supplies are delayed I will be sure to announce. Cash at pickup or Venmo

Fresh off the market bridal shower incorporating the wedding colors of burgundy and light pink 🥕🤍
09/03/2026

Fresh off the market bridal shower incorporating the wedding colors of burgundy and light pink 🥕🤍

Eivy celebrated her very first birthday with some “one silly goose” cookies 🪿 🎉
08/31/2026

Eivy celebrated her very first birthday with some “one silly goose” cookies 🪿 🎉

SOLD!32 individually sealed mini cookies up for grabs. Please let me know what date you’ll be picking up when you claim....
08/30/2026

SOLD!

32 individually sealed mini cookies up for grabs. Please let me know what date you’ll be picking up when you claim. $25 for all or I can split into 16 cookies for $13

If you know me, you know that this was a hard set to let go of! But congratulations to the Mortensen family on their ado...
08/25/2026

If you know me, you know that this was a hard set to let go of! But congratulations to the Mortensen family on their adoption of Lonnie! 🧙🏼‍♂️⚡️🦉

08/24/2026
Back to School cookie preorders are now available for pickup, including these super cute “teacher survival kits”. Thanks...
08/23/2026

Back to School cookie preorders are now available for pickup, including these super cute “teacher survival kits”. Thanks to all who ordered and I hope you have a wonderful school year!🍎👩🏼‍🏫

Extras available for pickup beginning tomorrow. $3 eachOption 1 “A+” - 23 availableOption 2 🍎- SOLD OUT
08/22/2026

Extras available for pickup beginning tomorrow. $3 each

Option 1 “A+” - 23 available
Option 2 🍎- SOLD OUT

Address

New Bethlehem, PA
16242

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 2:30pm
Tuesday 9am - 2:30pm
Wednesday 9am - 2:30pm
Thursday 9am - 2:30pm
Friday 9am - 2:30pm

Telephone

+18142211063

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Pence Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Pence Cookie Co.:

Shortcuts

Share

Category