Pence Cookie Co.

Call Directions Contact the business

Pence Cookie Co. Licensed home baker of delicious, hand-decorated custom sugar cookies in New Bethlehem, PA. Contact Pence Cookie Co. Also offering holiday and gift options!

if you want to make your next event extra special - weddings, showers, birthdays, and more!

Two little boos are almost due! 👻 💜 👻
10/20/2026

Two little boos are almost due! 👻 💜 👻

Cookies for Lydia’s “Two Sweet” birthday celebration 🍬 🍭 I think the rock candy might be my favorite!
10/13/2026

Cookies for Lydia’s “Two Sweet” birthday celebration 🍬 🍭 I think the rock candy might be my favorite!

Wishing the happiest 16th birthday to Rebecca! 🐆❤️
10/12/2026

Wishing the happiest 16th birthday to Rebecca! 🐆❤️

Happy Monday! This is your reminder that cookies make a great gift for almost any occasion! 🙃😆
10/05/2026

Happy Monday! This is your reminder that cookies make a great gift for almost any occasion! 🙃😆

I am not sure I could be convinced to do these again, BUT I do love how they turned out 🐆💜
09/28/2026

I am not sure I could be convinced to do these again, BUT I do love how they turned out 🐆💜

🎃 Halloween Mystery Dumpling Preorder 🎃 Let’s try the dumplings again, except this time we’re making them Halloween! You...
09/28/2026

🎃 Halloween Mystery Dumpling Preorder 🎃

Let’s try the dumplings again, except this time we’re making them Halloween!

You’ll get one of the following 6 designs (these are the cookie cutter sketches - I have not made samples of these). Depending on how many are sold, I will make some of them glitter to add to the fun!

$5 each, pickup tentatively beginning 10/29.

🌺🌊
09/27/2026

🌺🌊

🖤🎃🤍
09/27/2026

🖤🎃🤍

Girl Scouts and cookies just kinda go together
09/26/2026

Girl Scouts and cookies just kinda go together

My customers challenged me with themes this week but I’m thrilled with how all my sets turned out. Pictures to come soon...
09/25/2026

My customers challenged me with themes this week but I’m thrilled with how all my sets turned out. Pictures to come soon, but in the meantime - can you guess the theme of this order just by the ribbon and thank you cookie? 🤔

*Please don’t answer if you’re the customer 😉*

Address

New Bethlehem, PA
16242

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 2:30pm
Tuesday 9am - 2:30pm
Wednesday 9am - 2:30pm
Thursday 9am - 2:30pm
Friday 9am - 2:30pm

Telephone

+18142211063

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Pence Cookie Co. posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Pence Cookie Co.:

Shortcuts

Share

Category