Cake Creations in New Carlisle Ohio

12/25/2025

If you’ve been into Cake Creations recently, there’s a good chance you’ve already heard the news. For those who aren’t yet aware, I’m sorry to announce that we’ve decided to close down indefinitely. We thank you for all of your business and support through all the years, and especially since our move back in June. All your well wishes and gratefulness for our sticking around has truly made this a difficult decision to make. There are several reasons why we’re closing up, but at the heart of the situation, Brooke’s recent passing has been nothing short of devastating to say the least.

Our last day in business was December 24th and we’re very sorry to only now be making it public after the fact. The Christmas season is a very busy time of year and we took as many orders as we were able to fulfill. Any earlier announcement would have likely meant we’d have had to turn dozens of people away.

We ask only for your understanding, and that you all have a Merry Christmas, and a Happy New Year.

Thank you
- Cake Creations

12/16/2025

Our phone has resumed working. Sorry for the inconvenience and thank you!

11/24/2025

View Brooke Katheryn Brewer's obituary, send flowers, find service dates, and sign the guestbook.

11/22/2025

Hello everyone! Thanksgiving is right around the corner and with that comes holiday decorated sugar cookies!
Here’s a look at our turkey cookies this year, as well as a sneak peak at our Christmas cookie selection (taking orders now!)
They’re all made from scratch and rolled out in house - each being $1.50 a piece.

We’ll be closed the day of Thanksgiving, but we’ll be open Tuesday and Wednesday, as well as Friday and Saturday at our typical hours.

Thank you all so much and have a Happy Thanksgiving!

Edit: For all those that may not be aware yet, we’ve moved location to 11140 Milton Carlisle Road, New Carlisle!l

11/17/2025

Important information for tomorrow, Tuesday the 18th. We will not be opening until 1 pm and will still be closing at our usual time of 5 pm. We will however still be taking phone calls starting at 9 am. Sorry for the late notice and thank you for your understanding!

10/14/2025

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 14th
Our internet (along with the card machine and phone line) is back up again. Thank you

10/07/2025

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 7th

Our internet has returned and we can once again take phone calls as well as credit/debit card payments. Thank you.

09/30/2025

Important information for this SATURDAY, 10/4:
Because of the Heritage of Flight Festival, Cake Creations, and by extension, The Evans Family Ranch, will both be inaccessible from town. In addition to this, the East side of 571 leading here will also be inaccessible until about 12pm. We will effectively be open from 12-3pm this SATURDAY, 10/4, so please keep this in mind if you’re planning on placing an order, or even just dropping by. Thank you!

06/26/2025

The Evans Family Ranch has A LOT planned for their 4th of July celebration happening TOMORROW, THIS FRIDAY, JUNE 27th, and we’ve decided to extend our hours to take part in some of the festivities! We’ll have our usual selection of goodies, as well as some Red White and Blue options as we wait to watch the firework show!

Check out the Evans Family Ranch page for more information on admission and what will all be happening here on the ranch!

🎉 By now your calendars should include the Evans Family Ranch 4th of July Celebration Benefiting Autumn Trails Stable Equine-Assisted Services Center on Friday, June 27th — an evening filled with live music 🎶, delicious food trucks 🍔, family fun 🎈, and a spectacular fireworks show 🎇! If they don't, get that date marked!

📍 Evans Family Ranch | Gates open at 4PM
🎤 Live Bands • 🎟️ Raffle Prizes • 🐴 Supports Equine-Assisted Services

(Reminders: cash only, bring your own lawn chairs & no outside food or drinks!)

📸 Check out the flyer below and share it with your friends!
Every ticket, every sponsor, and every smile helps us change lives through the healing power of horses.

🎟 Learn more or become a sponsor at: www.autumntrailsstable.org/concert

06/17/2025

Many thanks to all those who’ve come out and or placed orders during our test open and first week at our new location!

For those who haven’t heard yet, we’re back in business in a new location. We’re at the Evans Family Ranch - 11140 Milton Carlisle Rd here in New Carlisle, and that’s just East of town on 571.

Our new location should be updated on both Google and Apple Maps (though Apple might list us at both for some reason)

Feel free to come on down to the Evans Family Ranch and keep an eye out for the big pink sign out front, you can’t miss us!

06/05/2025

Amazing news everybody! We’re finally ready to open our doors and will be doing so TOMORROW! We’ll be open this week Friday (9a-5p) and Saturday (8a-3p) with a limited selection of goods in our cases. We’ll be back to our normal schedule starting on Tuesday the 10th with our full selection available. Thanks again for all your continued support and we hope to see you all soon. The wait is finally over! 🥳

Our new location is at the Evans Family Ranch in New Carlisle
11140 Milton Carlisle Road

We’ll be taking phone calls during our open hours, including this Friday and Saturday
(937)-845-9710

Normal operating hours starting Tuesday the 10th:
Tuesday - Friday 9am-5pm
Saturday - 8am-3pm
Sunday & Monday - Closed

05/26/2025

Happy Memorial Day everyone. Quick update: Progress is coming along nicely with our imminent move to Evans Family Ranch. We’re just waiting on our new doors to be installed along with a couple of other things. We hope to be able to open in a week or so, so stay tuned for more news!