Cookie Girl Bake Shop

Cookie Girl Bake Shop Edible works of art that taste as good as they look! Ask about custom orders. CURRENTLY NOT OPEN TO WALK-INS. CURBSIDE PICKUP ONLY.

We're on Instagram:
Follow us on Twitter: We are a Cookie Bakery and specialize in custom iced Sugar Cookie pops and Cookie Bouquets. Our artist will turn any idea or theme into edible works of art! In addition to decorated sugar cookies, we offer the classics: chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, oatmeal raisin, sugared sugar, M&Mmm, chocolate chocolate chip, sprinkle

, and our famous Kitchen Sink cookies! Try our delicious Deep Dish Chocolate Chip Cookie Cakes, really good Brownies, scratch-made Cupcakes, loaf cakes and more! Everything is hand-made from scratch, with lots of love, on the premises. There are NO NUTS in the store, and we also offer select Gluten Free products! Cookie Girl is Kosher dairy, and able to ship anywhere in the contiguous US!


Let us bring your cookie dreams to life!

WE WILL MISS YOU!we've officially closed our doors, sold our shop, and are on to new adventures...it is bittersweet to e...
07/09/2022

WE WILL MISS YOU!
we've officially closed our doors, sold our shop, and are on to new adventures...it is bittersweet to explore new opportunities, as making sweet edible art has been a joy for over a decade. please stay tuned bc we may pop up again in the future! also stay tuned for who will be occupying our old space in town plaza. 👀
THANKS FOR THE MEMORIES, support, and love. not goodbye forever but: so long for now. 💖

(see our last post)yes THOSE rumors had some truth to them: Cookie Girl will cease operations in the near future..after ...
05/06/2022

(see our last post)
yes THOSE rumors had some truth to them: Cookie Girl will cease operations in the near future..after over 10 years of serving up sweet memories, things are shifting! This closure may be temporary/we might pop up as a reworked version, in another form, down the line!👀
thank you endlessly for the support and love over the years; we shall miss you when we're gone! Still here for now, though: call us to order at 845 708 5888 while supplies last

cookies: a kind way of letting a person know they've been on your mindPLEASE READ THIS WHOLE POST!:YOU dear clientele ha...
05/06/2022

cookies: a kind way of letting a person know they've been on your mindPLEASE READ THIS WHOLE POST!:
YOU dear clientele have been on our minds heavy, as with heavy hearts we share that Cookie Girl will be permanently shuttering the doors and ceasing operations in the near future..
The exact date is to be determined, and we will be keeping you posted as things unfold. We have SO MUCH GRATITUDE for being here to serve you for over 10 years(!) and cannot thank you enough for your support..
We continue to operate by preorder for curbside pickup for the time being, and intend to serve all the while, so please call the shop at 845 708 5888 with any questions or to place an order for freshly baked cookies and other goodies, while you still can!
A GREAT MANY THANKS with lots of love always
💖

💐🐇🌷🐣🌸🌼🌻
04/15/2022

💐🐇🌷🐣🌸🌼🌻

💐🐇🐣🌷🌼🌻🌸
04/15/2022

💐🐇🐣🌷🌼🌻🌸

04/06/2022


daydreaming about a warm and coastal situation..
04/06/2022

daydreaming about a warm and coastal situation..

bright spring cheer on this grey cold day!
04/06/2022

bright spring cheer on this grey cold day!

one of my favorite orders ever💜 .ge thank youu 💜
04/06/2022

one of my favorite orders ever
💜 .ge thank youu 💜

when they ask for a wheaten terrier wearing a stethoscope for a PhD grad who loves her dog:
04/06/2022

when they ask for a wheaten terrier wearing a stethoscope for a PhD grad who loves her dog:


04/06/2022


Address

191 S Main St
New City, NY
10956

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10am - 5pm
Wednesday 10am - 5pm
Thursday 10am - 5pm
Friday 10am - 5pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm

Telephone

+18457085888

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cookie Girl Bake Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cookie Girl Bake Shop:

Shortcuts

Share

Category

ALL ITEMS ARE CURRENTLY MADE TO ORDER ONLY

*Currently operating by curb-side pickup only due to COVID-19*

We are a humble bake shop where everything is scratch-made with love, in small batches with premium ingredients. Offering not only an assortment of cookies, but also cookie cakes, cupcakes, brownies, blondies, sheet cakes, party pops and more. Our signature iced sugar cookie pops can be crafted into dazzling cookie bouquets, and our artists can customize any idea or theme into edible works of art. Current Classic Cookies: old-fashioned chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, oatmeal raisin, sugared sugar, plain sugar, m&mmmmm, chocolate chocolate chip, rainbow sprinkle, and our beloved kitchen sink cookies (with pretzels, chocolate chips, oatmeal, potato chips, and cheerios) Our delicious Deep Dish Chocolate Chip Cookie Cakes are substantial cookie cakes in a variety of sizes, made to order with fresh buttercream and chocolate fudge icings. Everything is hand-made from scratch on the premises. There are NO NUTS in the store, although we have a couple ingredients that come from facilities that may also process nuts. Please call us at the shop for more information regarding food allergies and intolerances.

We also offer select Gluten Free products and are able to ship anywhere in the contiguous US. Let us bring your cookie dreams to life!