The Old Mystic Country Store featuring Papa Tony's Pizza

10/22/2023

Ready for something spooky?
What lurks beneath?!?
Join us October 20th and 21st, and October 26, 27, & 28
From 6:00 to 8:30pm
Creepy snacks and goulish cocktails!
Visit Mystic Seaport Museum for tickets!

06/14/2023

Looking for a 3+ bedroom to rent ASAP! Any leads would be great!

04/06/2023

This month at Supercharged! Get down here and get yours today!!!

02/07/2023

Come see us at Supercharged in Montville. February specials inspired by Papa Tony's. The King Papa and The Westerly. We would love to see your faces! Did I mention amazing cocktails to go with it!

10/26/2022

!!!YARD SALE!!!
Stop by this Sunday October 30th from 10 till 2
Everything must go!!!
Restaurant supplies and equipment
Holiday decorations
Catering supplies
And much much more!

10/15/2022

Indoor yard sale....restaurant equipment, small wares, decor, furniture and fixtures! Stop in today!

10/14/2022

To our Valued Customers, community, family and friends, we want to thank you from the bottom of our hearts for supporting us through the last almost 3 years.❤️❤️
That being said, tomorrow will be our last day in Old Mystic. We have tried to stay afloat during these difficult times, but now our time has come to make this difficult decision. 😥
We have a limited menu still available 🥪and we will be having an indoor yardsale on Saturday and Sunday or Stop and just say goodbye!👋
Stay tuned for what may be next.....we haven't given up on Papa Tony's and hope to open a new location in the future!🤞

09/22/2022

Send us your email for updates and specials!

Send a message to learn more

09/18/2022

Book us for your catering events!