Shisler's Cheese House

Shisler's Cheese House We have the cheeses for you! Get a taste of Amish country, and visit us in Orrville.
(372)

Many people assume Baby Swiss is just a smaller block of regular Swiss, but the difference is in the aging process. Baby...
08/15/2026

Many people assume Baby Swiss is just a smaller block of regular Swiss, but the difference is in the aging process. Baby Swiss is aged for a shorter period, which creates smaller 'eyes' (holes) and a much creamier, sweeter, and milder taste profile. It melts beautifully and is a favorite for those who find traditional Swiss too sharp. Add a block to your next order and taste the difference.

What started as a small shop on the Lincoln Highway now sends premium Ohio cheeses across the globe. Our dedicated cold-...
08/14/2026

What started as a small shop on the Lincoln Highway now sends premium Ohio cheeses across the globe. Our dedicated cold-shipping process ensures that our products arrive fresh and safe, whether they are traveling to the next state or across an ocean. You don't have to live in Orrville to enjoy authentic local quality. Browse our online store and let us ship directly to you.

To put that number into perspective, a standard jalapeño pepper only registers around 5,000 units. Our Carolina Reaper C...
08/13/2026

To put that number into perspective, a standard jalapeño pepper only registers around 5,000 units. Our Carolina Reaper Cheese is officially the hottest block we carry, crafted specifically for serious heat enthusiasts. It delivers an intense, building burn that completely transforms burgers and chili. Proceed with caution and order a block if you dare.

If you grew up in or around Ohio's Amish Country, you already know that Troyer's Trail Bologna is in a completely differ...
08/12/2026

If you grew up in or around Ohio's Amish Country, you already know that Troyer's Trail Bologna is in a completely different weight class. It's smoky, robust, and ruins you for regular lunch meat forever. We ship it nationwide so you never have to settle for the bland stuff again. Grab a ring and upgrade your lunch.

We've all told ourselves that lie when opening a fresh box of Assorted Heggy's Chocolates. Between the French Mints and ...
08/11/2026

We've all told ourselves that lie when opening a fresh box of Assorted Heggy's Chocolates. Between the French Mints and the Butter Creams, willpower doesn't stand a chance against these Ohio favorites. Don't worry, we won't judge how fast they disappear. Stock up on your favorites so you don't run out too quickly.

There is a specific kind of comfort that only comes from real, unhurried food. Whether it's the creamy melt of our Amish...
08/10/2026

There is a specific kind of comfort that only comes from real, unhurried food. Whether it's the creamy melt of our Amish Butter Cheese or the familiar snap of fresh cracklins, these are the tastes of simpler times. We source our products to ensure that every bite feels like a warm memory. Bring those classic traditions back to your own kitchen.

This is a former team member of ours that lost her Mom in a tragic accident a few days ago. She needs to make it to Flo...
08/09/2026

This is a former team member of ours that lost her Mom in a tragic accident a few days ago. She needs to make it to Florida with her two small children to arrange and attend the funeral. Any help that anyone can offer is greatly appreciated.

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/19Cx8E9prD/

Algorithms can't recommend the perfect Swiss for your recipe, and corporate warehouses don't double-check your shipping ...
08/09/2026

Algorithms can't recommend the perfect Swiss for your recipe, and corporate warehouses don't double-check your shipping box. We believe that outstanding customer service is just as important as the gourmet products we sell. When you order from our family, you're getting decades of genuine dedication in every single package. Experience the difference of a true local boutique.

We see it all the time: brave souls who think our Ghost Pepper Cheese is just a mild kick. With 855,000 Scoville units o...
08/08/2026

We see it all the time: brave souls who think our Ghost Pepper Cheese is just a mild kick. With 855,000 Scoville units of heat, it always sneaks up on you when you least expect it. If you have a friend who claims nothing is too spicy, we have the perfect gift for them. Tag the person who needs to try this.

We hear this worry all the time, but distance shouldn't keep you from great food. Our dedicated cold shipping process en...
08/07/2026

We hear this worry all the time, but distance shouldn't keep you from great food. Our dedicated cold shipping process ensures that every block of Baby Swiss and ring of Trail Bologna arrives at your door perfectly chilled. We carefully pack each order with specialized insulation and ice packs to maintain the ideal temperature. Enjoy Amish Country quality, no matter where you live.

Address

55 Kidron Road
Orrville, OH
44667

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 6pm
Tuesday 8:30am - 6pm
Wednesday 8:30am - 6pm
Thursday 8:30am - 6pm
Friday 8:30am - 6pm
Saturday 8:30am - 6pm
Sunday 9am - 5pm

Telephone

+13306822105

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Shisler's Cheese House posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Shisler's Cheese House:

Shortcuts

Share

Category