03/24/2026
Easter Lamb Cake: Black Sheep Edition. š¤
Some years ago a friend gifted us his momās vintage cast iron lamb cake pan from the 1950ās, after her passing. Iāve been making Lamb Cake every Easter since.
Every year is a little different. Iāve done traditional vanilla, toasted coconut, lemon, red velvet. This year a black sheep version felt appropriate, and chocolate is my favorite. To get the black āwoolā I tossed some shredded coconut with cocoa powder and a little activated charcoal {about 1 tsp}. I also added a bit of activated charcoal to the chocolate frosting to give it a darker color. Reminiscent of a real life black sheep.
The pans can be tricky as the shape is unusual and it can be hard un-mold the ears + nose without losing any.
The pan must be buttered and floured, spray oil doesnāt really work. Using fingers or a culinary brush, spread soft butter into every nook and cranny. Lightly dust with flour, shaking the pan around to get every spot covered.
Iāve found a dense cake, such as pound cake works the best. It holds its shape and can stay upright. I started out using regular cake recipes and theyāre too light- Iād always be reconstructing the face + ears with toothpicks to hold together. Pound cake, any pound cake recipe should do!
Eyes and nose are usually jelly beans. Decorate with spring blooms from your yard or fruit or whatever you like.
Lamb Cake has become a fun tradition, but doesnāt always have to be vanilla!