10/07/2026
Public Service/Educational Announcement:
We recently received a comment from someone who believes Myotonic goats should no longer be bred and that the breed should be allowed to die out because myotonia congenita is a genetic condition. The concern was also raised that these goats experience muscle spasms and therefore cannot have an acceptable quality of life.
We understand that people can have strong opinions about animal breeding and welfare. However, we believe this subject deserves a thoughtful response, especially when the proposed solution is for an entire breed to disappear.
Yes, myotonia congenita is a genetic neuromuscular condition. We do not dispute that. It is the reason Myotonic goats experience temporary muscle stiffness when they are startled or excited. Myotonia occurs because the muscles have difficulty relaxing normally after contraction (The Livestock Conservancy, 2026).
There is, however, an important distinction in how this condition is described. The Livestock Conservancy explains that the characteristic stiffness is a muscular phenomenon, not a loss of consciousness. The degree of stiffness can also vary considerably among individual goats (The Livestock Conservancy, 2026).
That is different from describing every episode as a painful muscle spasm.
Despite the name “Fainting goat,” Myotonic goats do not actually lose consciousness during these episodes. They remain conscious while their muscles temporarily stiffen, and the stiffness generally passes relatively quickly (The Livestock Conservancy, 2026).
Does that mean responsible owners should ignore the condition? Absolutely not.
Responsible ownership means understanding the breed, providing a safe environment, monitoring the animals, and recognizing individual differences. A goat could potentially be injured during a fall, and that is something we take seriously.
However, acknowledging a genetic characteristic is very different from concluding that an entire breed has an unacceptable quality of life and therefore should no longer exist.
Quality of life should be evaluated by considering the whole animal, not one characteristic in isolation.
We consider our goats’ overall health, body condition, behavior, mobility, nutrition, social interactions, reproductive health, and ability to function comfortably in their everyday environment.
There is another important fact that should not be overlooked.
The Myotonic, or Tennessee Fainting Goat, is currently classified as “Recovering” on The Livestock Conservancy’s 2026 Conservation Priority List. Recovering is the least threatened category on the list, but it indicates that the breed continues to receive conservation attention (The Livestock Conservancy, 2026a).
The Livestock Conservancy recognizes the Myotonic goat as a unique American genetic resource worthy of conservation. The organization also identifies characteristics that make the breed valuable, including heavy muscling, parasite resistance, active foraging ability, docile temperament, reproductive efficiency, and usefulness as a meat goat (The Livestock Conservancy, 2026b).
Therefore, while someone may personally believe that Myotonic goats should be allowed to die out, the organization dedicated to conserving America’s rare livestock breeds recognizes this as a breed worth preserving.
We choose preservation through responsible breeding.
That does not mean breeding every animal indiscriminately. It means understanding the breed, selecting healthy animals, maintaining genetic diversity, practicing good husbandry, and making responsible decisions about which animals should contribute to future generations.
We are not going to pretend myotonia does not exist. We are not going to ignore our responsibilities as breeders. And we are not going to claim that every aspect of the breed is perfect.
However, we also do not believe that having a genetic condition automatically means an animal has a poor quality of life or that an entire breed should disappear.
Responsible breeding, responsible ownership, education, and honest discussion are better answers than extinction.
At Briar Creek Farm, our Myotonic goats are cared for, valued, and loved. We will continue learning about the breed, making responsible breeding decisions, and doing our best to give every goat in our care a healthy and fulfilling life.
Different does not mean they do not deserve a future. 🐐❤️
Myotonic goats have a place in agriculture, and we are proud to help preserve that place.
Reference: The Livestock Conservancy