The Proper Palm

The Proper Palm Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from The Proper Palm, Speciality food shop, 10480 Stringfellow Road Cottage 3, Saint James City, FL.

Licensed & inspected retail bakery, cupboard & island provisions | Prepared meals, specialty groceries & coastal provisions | Pre-orders on Pine Island & North Captiva

There’s still time to set the table for Father’s Day weekend.From slow-braised family meals and fresh-baked breakfast fa...
06/19/2026

There’s still time to set the table for Father’s Day weekend.

From slow-braised family meals and fresh-baked breakfast favorites to cakes, pies, cookies, pastries, and island provisions, we’ve prepared a menu designed to make your weekend feel a little more effortless and a lot more special.

Whether you’re gathering at home on Pine Island or welcoming family to North Captiva, we’ll bring The Proper Palm to your table.

Complimentary delivery is available throughout Pine Island, with coordinated delivery to North Captiva via the North Captiva Island Club ferry service. Pickup is also available at our Stringfellow Road location.

Father’s Day weekend ordering closes tomorrow morning.

Explore the menu and place your order here: https://www.hotplate.com/theproperpalm/78ad0fb7-0e06-4037-af19-57864562c9a9

From our kitchen to your island home, thank you for welcoming The Proper Palm Cupboard & Island Provisions into your celebrations.

Bokeelia • Pine Island • North Captiva

🩵🦩🎀 There are moments in business that remind you why you do what you do, and this was one of them.A heartfelt thank you...
06/18/2026

🩵🦩🎀 There are moments in business that remind you why you do what you do, and this was one of them.

A heartfelt thank you to Leanne at Sea Salt & Co. for creating this beautiful custom embroidered tote featuring The Proper Palm logo. The attention to detail, craftsmanship, and coastal charm are simply stunning, and I couldn’t love it more.

Leanne has become not only a wonderful customer, but also a sweet friend, and I’m incredibly grateful for the kindness and support she continues to show The Proper Palm. 🤍

If you’re looking to create your own signature coastal style, be sure to stop by Sea Salt & Co. From personalized totes and gifts to island-inspired accessories, Leanne creates beautiful pieces that perfectly capture our laid-back Pine Island lifestyle. 🌴🐚✨

There’s something so special about local businesses supporting one another, and I’m thankful to be part of this wonderful island community.

Thank you again, Leanne, for this thoughtful gift. I’ll be carrying a little piece of Pine Island with me wherever I go. 🩵

Island life just got a little easier.🎀🏝️❤️The Proper Palm Cupboard & Island Provisions is proud to partner with Door 2 D...
06/17/2026

Island life just got a little easier.🎀🏝️❤️

The Proper Palm Cupboard & Island Provisions is proud to partner with Door 2 Door & More to bring even more convenience to our Pine Island and North Captiva communities.

Whether you’re ordering chef-prepared meals, fresh breads, pastries, sweets, or stocking your vacation home with groceries and essentials, you can now coordinate it all in one place.

Michele and the Door 2 Door & More team have been serving our island communities for years, providing dependable, five-star service to both residents and visitors. We’re excited to partner with a local business that shares our commitment to hospitality and exceptional customer care.

Need grocery delivery? Want your Proper Palm order delivered alongside your weekly essentials? Arriving by boat or staying on North Captiva?

Door 2 Door & More can coordinate grocery and provision deliveries, provide service to Island Girl Charters, and assist with deliveries outside of our regular operating hours.

For a seamless island experience, reach out to Michele at Door 2 Door & More to coordinate your delivery needs.

Together, we’re making it easier than ever to enjoy the best of island living.

Bokeelia • Pine Island • North Captiva

Father’s Day weekend is here, and The Proper Palm Cupboard & Island Provisions is bringing chef-prepared coastal comfort...
06/17/2026

Father’s Day weekend is here, and The Proper Palm Cupboard & Island Provisions is bringing chef-prepared coastal comfort straight to your door.

Skip the cooking and spend more time celebrating. Our prepared meals arrive fully assembled and ready to heat in your oven—just place them in the oven, gather around the table, and dinner is served.

This weekend’s featured provisions include:

• Casetta Lasagna Bolognese with roasted garlic whipped ricotta

• Proper Palm Pistachio Florentine Chicken with organic chicken breasts, roasted garlic Boursin béchamel, spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, and a pistachio-Parmesan crust

• Chicken Pot Pie with pimento cheese biscuits

• Seven Layer Salad with Golden Goddess passionfruit vinaigrette

• Roasted Beef Waldorf Salad

• Bokeelia Citrus Quiche Lorraine with Pine Island farm-fresh eggs, hickory-smoked bacon, Irish cheddar, artichoke hearts, whipped ricotta, and a touch of Florida citrus

• Fresh breads, breakfast favorites, pastries, and sweet treats

Build your own Father’s Day feast for $75 with our family meal option, perfect for effortless entertaining all weekend long.

Delivery is available Saturday and Sunday morning.

Pine Island: Complimentary delivery.

North Captiva: Coordinated delivery via the North Captiva Island Club ferry service.

Please enter your delivery address and any special instructions in the notes section at checkout.

Order here: https://www.hotplate.com/theproperpalm/78ad0fb7-0e06-4037-af19-57864562c9a9

Quantities are limited, and ordering closes when we sell out.

From our kitchen to your table, thank you for welcoming The Proper Palm Cupboard & Island Provisions into your Father’s Day traditions.
Pine Island • North Captiva

🎀🎀A friendly reminder that ordering for this weekend’s menu closes tomorrow morning.The kitchen has been busy this week ...
06/10/2026

🎀🎀A friendly reminder that ordering for this weekend’s menu closes tomorrow morning.

The kitchen has been busy this week as I continue preparing for the opening of The Proper Palm Cupboard & Island Provisions, and I’m excited to share another small preview of what’s to come.

Alongside our baked goods, we’ve added a collection of prepared meals, salads, side dishes, charcuterie, and desserts inspired by the foods I grew up around, the recipes that found their way to our family table, and the hospitality traditions that have always inspired The Proper Palm.

This week’s menu includes Chicken Pot Pie, Beef Bourguignon, Mama’s Chicken & Wild Rice Casserole, White Truffle & Chive Duchess Potatoes, fresh salads, charcuterie boards, Banana Pudding for Two, and a few sweet treats as well.

Everything is prepared fresh in small batches and designed to be enjoyed at home with family and friends.

Thank you for following along as this next chapter takes shape. Your encouragement, orders, comments, and support mean more than you know.

View this week’s menu:
https://www.hotplate.com/theproperpalm

Small batch by design.
Fresh by promise.
Delivered like hospitality.
Always Proper 🎀🏝️🍰

🌴 Arriving on North Captiva this weekend?Skip the grocery run and let us help make your island stay a little more relaxi...
06/09/2026

🌴 Arriving on North Captiva this weekend?

Skip the grocery run and let us help make your island stay a little more relaxing.

The Proper Palm Cupboard & Island Provisions is offering a preview menu featuring ready-to-heat family meals, fresh salads, charcuterie boards, house-baked breads, and desserts prepared fresh on Pine Island and delivered to North Captiva Island Club Dock.

Whether you’re checking into a vacation rental, gathering with family, or simply enjoying a quiet island weekend, we’ve taken care of dinner.

This week’s menu includes:
• Chicken Pot Pie with Proper Palm Pimento Cheese Biscuits
• French Beef Bourguignon
• White Truffle & Chive Duchess Potatoes
• Proper Palm Seven-Layer Salad
• Roasted Beet & Apricot Waldorf Salad
• Charcuterie for Two
• House-made desserts and more

The doors may not be open yet, but the kitchen certainly is.

Order here:
https://www.hotplate.com/theproperpalm

North Captiva deliveries available. Pine Island pickup and delivery available.

Beautiful food. Thoughtful details. Always Proper.

🎀🦩 The Proper Palm Cupboard & Island Provisions is now open for orders! 🦩🎀The doors may not be open yet, but the menu an...
06/07/2026

🎀🦩 The Proper Palm Cupboard & Island Provisions is now open for orders! 🦩🎀

The doors may not be open yet, but the menu and kitchen are. 🍽️✨

This weekend we're excited to share a special preview of what's to come at The Proper Palm. Enjoy a limited menu featuring handcrafted take-and-bake suppers, fresh salads, house-baked breads, and signature desserts, all prepared in small batches right here on Pine Island. 🌴🍞🥗

Each meal arrives fully prepared and chilled, ready to heat and serve in approximately 25–30 minutes. Simply place it in the oven and let us take care of supper. 🥘✨

Available this weekend for:
🏝️ Pine Island Delivery
⛴️ North Captiva Delivery
🛍️ Saturday & Sunday Pickup

Please enter your delivery address and any special notes during checkout.

Order Here:
https://www.hotplate.com/theproperpalm

Thank you for being part of this journey. We're thrilled to share this first glimpse of The Proper Palm Cupboard & Island Provisions before officially welcoming guests into our new location. 💙

🌴 Small batch by design.
🍽️ Fresh by promise.
🎀 Delivered like hospitality.
🦩 Always Proper

06/07/2026

🥚 SUMMER EGG SPECIAL 🥚

We know groceries aren’t getting any cheaper, and we want to do our small part to help.

For a limited time this summer, our farm-fresh eggs will be just $5 per dozen (regularly $7).

Our hens are still enjoying sunshine, fresh air, and plenty of treats, and we’re happy to pass along some savings to our wonderful customers during these challenging times.

Thank you for supporting our small family farm. ❤️

📍 Green Thumb Ranch
🥚 Farm-fresh eggs
💲 $5 per dozen – Summer Special
While supplies last!

A beautiful few days in Palm Beach.After a busy season and a little baker’s block, I took some time away to recharge, ga...
06/07/2026

A beautiful few days in Palm Beach.

After a busy season and a little baker’s block, I took some time away to recharge, gather inspiration, and enjoy a little R&R mixed with some R&D.

The Proper Palm has always been about more than baked goods. It’s about creating a feeling—beautiful tables, thoughtful hospitality, timeless recipes, coastal charm, and those little details that make everyday life feel special.

This trip was filled with plenty of inspiration, from historic courtyards and ocean views to incredible meals, pastries, and design ideas that will undoubtedly find their way back to Bokeelia and The Proper Palm.

Thank you for your patience while we’ve been closed. I’m looking forward to sharing some exciting news soon and getting back into the kitchen next week.

Stay tuned. The next chapter is almost here.

— Tristan

The Proper Palm 🎀🦩🍰🏝️🫖

The Proper Palm 🎀🦩🍰 will remain closed this week as we finalize approvals and complete the transition from our cottage b...
05/28/2026

The Proper Palm 🎀🦩🍰 will remain closed this week as we finalize approvals and complete the transition from our cottage bakery model into our new retail bakery space here on Pine Island. ✨🍍

While we work through these final steps behind the scenes, all existing pre-orders and custom orders already scheduled for this weekend will still be baked fresh and fulfilled from our cottage bakery kitchen as planned. 💙

This next chapter has involved many more moving parts than most people realize, but we are getting very close and cannot wait to welcome everyone into the new Proper Palm experience soon.

Official opening date announcement coming soon… 🤫✨

Thank you all so much for the kindness, patience and support during this transition. It truly means the world to our little island bakery.

Address

10480 Stringfellow Road Cottage 3
Saint James City, FL
33956

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Proper Palm posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category