What are the opening hours?

Monday 8am - 4:30pm Tuesday 8am - 4:30pm Wednesday 8am - 4:30pm Thursday 8am - 4:30pm Friday 8am - 4:30pm Saturday 8am - 12pm

Old World Creamery

Home
United States
Sheboygan, WI
Old World Creamery

Call Directions Website Contact the business

The Butter Choice

Old World Creamery – A Scoop of Nostalgia, A Dash of Delight! Step into Old World Creamery, where timeless charm meets tasty treats!

Old World Creamery is a family-owned food manufacturer located in Sheboygan, WI, specializing in carefully crafting a variety of quality cheese, butter, and dairy products from the finest ingredients available. We’re your neighborhood destination for creamy indulgence, cozy vibes, and now… $.25 scoops of Cedar Crest ice cream—a local legend in every lick! Whether you're craving a quick pick-me-up or a sweet stroll down memory lane, we’ve got you covered. Come for the classic creamery feel, stay for the unbeatable scoop deal. Because at Old World Creamery, happiness is just a quarter away! Specialties:
Butter
Cheese
Cream Cheese

Products:
Dairy Products
Gift Items
Magnets
Cutting Boards
Bobble Heads
Olives
Jarred Asparagus
Jams
Amish Candy
Cheese Fudge
Cheese Balls
Grilled Cheese
$0.25 Ice Cream Scoops from our local partner Cedar Crest! Brands:
Cedar Crest

Certifications:
Safe Quality Food Institute - SQFI
Certified by MOSA

10/11/2026

Bring bold flavor to every pour with Old World Creamery's Homemade Bloody Mary Mix. 🍅🌶️

Crafted with quality ingredients and a perfectly balanced blend of savory spices, our Bloody Mary Mix makes it easy to create a delicious cocktail or add a flavorful kick to your favorite recipes. Whether you're tailgating with friends, or enjoying a weekend gathering, it's the perfect addition to any occasion. Customers love its homemade taste and keep coming back for more, grab a bottle before it's gone!

09/11/2026

🏈Game day favorites start with great cream cheese.

Made in-house with care, our 8 oz. Cream Cheese Bars deliver the homemade quality and smooth, creamy flavor that make every recipe better. Whether you're mixing up Buffalo chicken dip for the big game, spreading it on a bagel, or creating a crowd-pleasing appetizer, our cream cheese is the perfect addition to your game day spread. Bring rich flavor and quality ingredients to every gathering with Old World Creamery.

Taste the craftsmanship. Taste the quality. Taste Old World Creamery.

09/02/2026

🍪 Calling all bakers!
Whether you're making cookies, cakes, breads, or pastries, our Unsalted Butter gives you precise control over every recipe while delivering rich flavor and consistent results. 🧈👩‍🍳
What's your favorite thing to bake?

08/20/2026

Meet the butter that food lovers can't stop talking about!
Old World Creamery Irish Butter features a higher butterfat content, creating a richer, creamier texture that elevates everything from toast to baked goods. 🥐✨
Once you try it, you'll understand why it's a customer favorite!

08/06/2026

Our Old World Creamery Butter is made using quality Wisconsin milk and cream, blended with generations of experience and packaged right in Sheboygan.
The result? Rich, creamy butter you'll taste in every bite. 🧈

📍1606 Erie Ave Sheboygan, WI
📞(920) 550-4443
🌐www.owcreamery.com

07/22/2026

💰 Looking for wholesale butter at prices that help your business thrive?
Old World Creamery offers exceptional quality and outstanding wholesale value. Whether you're serving customers, stocking shelves, or creating delicious recipes, our butter delivers premium quality without the premium price tag. 🧈✨
Contact us today and see why businesses choose Old World Creamery!

07/09/2026

🧈 A century of buttery goodness! Since 1912, Old World Creamery has been committed to crafting high-quality dairy products with the same family values and pride that started it all. From local dairy farms to your table, quality is at the heart of everything we do. ❤️ 🐄
What's your favorite way to enjoy butter?

04/01/2026

🧀 Discover the Flavor of Old World Cheese
At Old World Creamery, our cheese is crafted with tradition, quality, and rich, authentic flavor in every bite. From smooth and creamy varieties to bold and aged favorites, we bring you cheese made the way it should be—carefully, thoughtfully, and deliciously.
Whether you’re snacking, cooking, or entertaining, there’s an Old World cheese that brings your plate to life.
Taste craftsmanship. Taste tradition. Taste Old World Creamery.

03/19/2026

🧈🧀 Old World Creamery: Crafted the Old‑Fashioned Way
From rich butter to flavorful cheese and silky‑smooth cream cheese, Old World Creamery brings tradition to every bite. Made with care, crafted for quality, and always delicious.

Taste the difference that real craftsmanship makes.

02/25/2026

🧀🐄 Welcome to the heart of gourmet bliss where every churn and stir is a step towards dairy perfection! At our creamery, we're passionate about crafting butter and cheese that turn meals into feasts. Our commitment to top-quality dairy products ensures each slice and spread is a testament to traditional food manufacturing at its best. Taste the love in every bite! 🧈✨

Address

1606 Erie Avenue
Sheboygan, WI
53081

Opening Hours

Monday	8am - 4:30pm
Tuesday	8am - 4:30pm
Wednesday	8am - 4:30pm
Thursday	8am - 4:30pm
Friday	8am - 4:30pm
Saturday	8am - 12pm

Telephone

+19205504443

Website

https://www.owcreamery.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Old World Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Old World Creamery:

Want your business to be the top-listed food & beverage service in Sheboygan?