10/23/2024
I want to address the "they need time to bond with their owners" thing. This is your chance to make your case in the comments, but please read this in it's entirety before you respond. I'm writing this for "Farmers Only LGDs."
I think we should all be able to agree that farming/ranching in 2024 looks very different than it did 1000 years ago, or even 100 years ago. The problem is, we all take that knowledge and come to different conclusions(like politics). In this group, I'd like to be more on the same page on this topic. Even though we've banned the promoting of raising dogs inside, I know you're still lurking here 😆. Let me appeal to you.
Listening to the adult dogs barking at the wolves through the thin walls of a tent is not the same as bringing a puppy in your house at night. I know a guy who has actually pitched a tent out with his dogs, to be there with the animals, and with the dogs for support and bonding. He still does this some nights. I think he's a little crazy, but his commitment to raising LGDs in a historical context is more accurate than anyone here. The dogs don't actually sleep in the tent with him either.
A Shepherds life has always been out with the animals. The conflating of tent to house is silly. In a house, the smells and sounds are separate and far away from the livestock, and the other dogs. The point of puppies coming in the tent was never "bonding". The point was that very small puppies are vulnerable. Still their entire puppy hood was spent with livestock and with the family (who also lived with the livestock). I would even argue that many times, puppies lived in huts with the animals at night,(similar to our barns and barn yards) where predators were not able to sneak in, while the adults guarded the entrance.
All this to say, we need something different from these dogs, than what was historically needed. Many of us work jobs away from our farm. We need them to be reliable, self workers. That's never really been asked of these dogs before very recently. We should still breed for what we want, (a dog that requires minimal human direction) but we should not ignore thousands of years of development in understanding these breeds. That context is important.
We should not need to "train" a well bred dog, but it's important to understand, the person raising a puppy for the first time, with no mentor dogs is likely going to encounter some problems. They're missing important pieces of what has always been part of raising these dogs(mentor dogs, a 24/7 Shepherd, and livestock that are used to LGDs). Living in the house is not the missing piece 😆
It's very simple for those of us with an established pack, and livestock that are used to LGDs, to bring a new puppy to the farm. They are going to be successful with a puppy that a new farm might struggle with. I think that a lot of established programs are unfairly critical of folks who are struggling with a puppy, when they have no established pack.
I just had someone asking about upcoming litters, and asked about my guarantee. While I absolutely guarantee the health of my dogs, it's difficult to guarantee that they will work for you, when we've all seen so many dogs ruined by mistakes new farmers make. We are asking these dogs to do something that we never asked from the beginning of time, to grow up without a mentor, around livestock that are scared of dogs, and to do that with minimal human interaction. It's actually amazing how often it does work out, but rescues are still full from those that don't.
You can believe with all your heart that it's important to raise puppies inside for a period of bonding, and maybe it works out for a certain % of people, but it is unnecessary, and very easy to create a needy, dependent dog, when in the end, we all need independent dogs. I started this group because of this debate. The pet people dominate the other major groups, and with good intentions, are ruining thousands of dogs every year with their bad advice.
Last thought....if you buy a puppy from a reputable breeder,(and you better be asking for references) it's your responsibility to follow the advice of the breeder for what works for their dogs. Most of you have gambled on puppies from folks with no record as a breeder(me too). That's very risky. Don't do that.
Hope this has been helpful. As said in the beginning, please make your case for why you might disagree. I'm open to conversation. This is the one time you can make your case lol