Stillwater Cafe

Stillwater Cafe Stillwater Cafe (formerly Garriss General Store) is a smalltown eatery in the heart of Stillwater NJ.

Join us Mother’s Day weekend for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, May 9th, at 6:30pm. Four courses...
05/06/2026

Join us Mother’s Day weekend for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, May 9th, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷

To Reserve: Call or Text Dave
(908) 472-9407

Location: 912 Main Street
Stillwater , NJ 07860

Doors open at 6:15pm. First course is served a little after 6:30.

Very limited seating available, so please reserve your table early!

Menu selections are greatly appreciated, if possible, when you make your reservation. We also kindly ask that parties of 2 & 3 consider sharing a table and meeting some new friends.

Dave

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, May 2nd, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷To R...
04/30/2026

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, May 2nd, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷

To Reserve: Call or Text Dave
(908) 472-9407

Location: 912 Main Street
Stillwater , NJ 07860

Doors open at 6:15pm. First course is served a little after 6:30.

Very limited seating available, so please reserve your table early!

Menu selections are greatly appreciated, if possible, when you make your reservation. We also kindly ask that parties of 2 & 3 consider sharing a table and meeting some new friends.

Dave

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, April 25th, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷T...
04/22/2026

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, April 25th, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷

To Reserve: Call or Text Dave
(908) 472-9407

Location: 912 Main Street
Stillwater , NJ 07860

Doors open at 6:15pm. First course is served a little after 6:30.

Very limited seating available, so please reserve your table early!

Menu selections are greatly appreciated, if possible, when you make your reservation. We also kindly ask that parties of 2 & 3 consider sharing a table and meeting some new friends.

Dave

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, April 18th, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷T...
04/14/2026

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, April 18th, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷

To Reserve: Call or Text Dave
(908) 472-9407

Location: 912 Main Street
Stillwater , NJ 07860

Doors open at 6:15pm. First course is served a little after 6:30.

Very limited seating available, so please reserve your table early!

Menu selections are greatly appreciated, if possible, when you make your reservation. We also kindly ask that parties of 2 & 3 consider sharing a table and meet some new friends.

Dave

Still a few tables left for tomorrow evening’s dinner. Please send a text or call Dave at (908) 472-9407 to reserve you...
04/10/2026

Still a few tables left for tomorrow evening’s dinner. Please send a text or call Dave at (908) 472-9407 to reserve your spot. Hope to see you there! Dave

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, April 11th, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷T...
04/06/2026

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, April 11th, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷

To Reserve: Call or Text Dave
(908) 472-9407

Location: 912 Main Street
Stillwater , NJ 07860

Doors open at 6:15pm. First course is served a little after 6:30.

Very limited seating available, so please reserve your table early!

Menu selections are greatly appreciated, if possible, when you make your reservation. We also kindly ask that parties of 2 & 3 consider sharing a table and meet some new friends.

Dave

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, April 4th, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷To...
04/01/2026

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, April 4th, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷

To Reserve: Call or Text Dave
(908) 472-9407

Location: 912 Main Street
Stillwater , NJ 07860

Doors open at 6:15pm. First course is served a little after 6:30.

Very limited seating available, so please reserve your table early!

Menu selections are greatly appreciated, if possible, when you make your reservation. We also kindly ask that parties of 2 & 3 consider sharing a table and meet some new friends.

Dave

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, March 28th, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷T...
03/25/2026

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, March 28th, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷

To Reserve: Call or Text Dave
(908) 472-9407

Location: 912 Main Street
Stillwater , NJ 07860

Doors open at 6:15pm. First course is served a little after 6:30.

Very limited seating available, so please reserve your table early!

Menu selections are greatly appreciated, if possible, when you make your reservation. We also kindly ask that parties of 2 & 3 consider sharing a table and meet some new friends.

Dave

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, March 21st, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷T...
03/18/2026

Join us for a 4 course meal at The Stillwater Cafe this Saturday, March 21st, at 6:30pm. Four courses for $45. BYOB 🍷

To Reserve: Call or Text Dave
(908) 472-9407

Location: 912 Main Street
Stillwater , NJ 07860

Doors open at 6:15pm. First course is served a little after 6:30.

Very limited seating available, so please reserve your table early!

Menu selections are greatly appreciated, if possible, when you make your reservation. We also kindly ask that parties of 2 & 3 consider sharing a table and meet some new friends.

Dave

Address

912 Main Street
Stillwater, NJ
07875

Opening Hours

6:30pm - 9:30pm

Telephone

+19733830042

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Stillwater Cafe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Stillwater Cafe:

Shortcuts

Share

Category