Valley Subs Plus

Valley Subs Plus Just two people with one oven and a simple menu, celebrating 10 years of business! Pro ordering tip: Call Early! Phone lines get busy and sell outs happen!

Area's first: Old Forge Pizza, Calzone, Sweetie Pie (sweet, sweet garlic 🍕) and Italian Grinder.

Open at 4 for pick up or delivery! Preorders are not necessary, but appreciated!Tonight's Desserts: Vanilla or LEMON Cak...
05/29/2026

Open at 4 for pick up or delivery! Preorders are not necessary, but appreciated!
Tonight's Desserts: Vanilla or LEMON Cake by Sugar & Spice Bakery

Open at 4! Preorders welcomed. And don't forget to reserve your mini cakes from Sugar & Spice Bakery. This Week's flavor...
05/28/2026

Open at 4! Preorders welcomed. And don't forget to reserve your mini cakes from Sugar & Spice Bakery. This Week's flavors are lemon or vanilla, $5.

Desserts by Sugar & Spice Bakery are back on Thursday! So sink your teeth into this week’s irresistible flavors— Lemon I...
05/27/2026

Desserts by Sugar & Spice Bakery are back on Thursday! So sink your teeth into this week’s irresistible flavors— Lemon Iced & Vanilla Bliss mini cakes 😎
🍋 Lemon cake with a whipped vanilla buttercream
🤍 Vanilla cake with a dreamy whipped vanilla buttercream

Sweet Valley Parade is rain or shine at 1:30!!! And please go visit Kailee, owner of Sugar & Spice Bakery at the fair! S...
05/23/2026

Sweet Valley Parade is rain or shine at 1:30!!!

And please go visit Kailee, owner of Sugar & Spice Bakery at the fair! She is set up inside the pizza building, along the back wall. She has such a kind heart and is donating half of her proceeds today to the fire company/fair! Go find your new favorite dessert and report back what you would like to see as Valley Subs Plus next featured dessert. My vote is for her lemon cake! Soooooooo gooooood!!!!!!

Also, tonight is 80's costume night at the fair! You won't want to miss my sister Kelly Goss outfit!!!!

Valley Subs will be closed today and tomorrow to enjoy the fair.

05/22/2026

Valley Subs open at 4.
Preorders welcomed!
And don't forget to visit Sugar & Spice Bakery at the Sweet Valley Fair!

Open today and Friday at 4. Closed Saturday and Sunday to enjoy the Sweet Valley Fair!!!Thursday's Specials $5 Dessets b...
05/21/2026

Open today and Friday at 4. Closed Saturday and Sunday to enjoy the Sweet Valley Fair!!!

Thursday's Specials

$5 Dessets by Sugar & Spice Bakery

6.99 - 4 cut Personal w/ one topping

$9/$14 - 6 cuts/12 cuts

$2 off Large Sweetie Pies/$1.75 off Mediums

Buy any Large Pizza, get $3 off Large Buffalo or PLAIN Chicken Bite

Stop at the fair tonight thru Sunday and try a variety of Kailee's delicious desserts so we know what we want to ask her to bake for our featured dessert next week! Taking suggestions!

Memorial Day Week, Open at 4 Wed, Thurs, Fri. Closed Sat and Sun to enjoy the Sweet Valley PARADE & FAIR!Wednesday Speci...
05/20/2026

Memorial Day Week, Open at 4 Wed, Thurs, Fri.

Closed Sat and Sun to enjoy the Sweet Valley PARADE & FAIR!

Wednesday Specials

$5 DESSERT pictured below by Sugar & Spice Bakery
$8 Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix
$9/$14 - 6 cuts/12cuts
$10 SUB or GRINDER Italian, Ham or American
$12/$15 Italian Stromboli

Want to avoid order delays during the "rush"? Call ahead! Taking pre-orders now for Wed, Thurs, and Friday

Desssert Contest Entries must be in today Monday May 18th between 5-8 pm!Sneak peak of next week's dessert by Sugar & Sp...
05/18/2026

Desssert Contest Entries must be in today Monday May 18th between 5-8 pm!

Sneak peak of next week's dessert by Sugar & Spice Bakery. Find Kailee at the fair, starting on Thursday night! She will be easy to find. She'll be the one with all the gorgeously decorated, tasty sweet treats!!!!

Sunday Specials, We accept pre-orders, call now! These specials are likely to sell out! $8.99 Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix...
05/17/2026

Sunday Specials, We accept pre-orders, call now! These specials are likely to sell out!

$8.99 Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix
$9/$14 - 6 cuts/12cuts
$10 Medium NY
$11 Large NY
$20 TWO NY PIZZAS
$25 Large NY + Whole Tray (12 cuts) Old Forge

Saturday SpecialsTaking pre-orders, call anytime!$8.99 Cheesy Garlic Dippin' Stix with sauce$9/$14 - 6 cuts/12cutsFEATUR...
05/16/2026

Saturday Specials
Taking pre-orders, call anytime!

$8.99 Cheesy Garlic Dippin' Stix with sauce

$9/$14 - 6 cuts/12cuts

FEATURED PIZZA:
$15/$13 Large/Medium
Sweetie Pie NY Pizza WITH ONE FREE TOPPING
(recomended: ham, pepperoni or bacon!)
Unlimited quantities until they sell out!

Desserts by Sugar & Spice Bakery

05/15/2026

Kailee made more desserts! If you are pre-ordering, you may want to reserve a few of these also! They will undoubtedly sell out.
Desserts by Sugar & Spice Bakery.

Address

5355 Main Road
Sweet Valley, PA
18656

Opening Hours

Wednesday 4pm - 8pm
Thursday 4pm - 8pm
Friday 4pm - 8pm
Saturday 4pm - 8pm
Sunday 4pm - 8pm

Telephone

+15704772022

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Valley Subs Plus posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category