Valley Subs Plus

Valley Subs Plus Just two people with one oven and a simple menu, celebrating 10 years of business! Pro ordering tip: Call Early! Phone lines get busy and sell outs happen!

Area's first: Old Forge Pizza, Calzone, Sweetie Pie (sweet, sweet garlic 🍕) and Italian Grinder.

Thursday Specials $9 - 6 cutsFEATURED PIZZA $15 Large, $13 Medium NY Thin Crust Chicken Bacon Ranch (With or w/o BBQ dri...
06/18/2026

Thursday Specials

$9 - 6 cuts

FEATURED PIZZA
$15 Large, $13 Medium
NY Thin Crust Chicken Bacon Ranch
(With or w/o BBQ drizzle)

$5 - Smores mini cakes by Sugar & Spice Bakery
They are a rich chocolate cake with a whipped homemade marshmallow buttercream and garnished with a graham cracker crumble and a Hershey chocolate 😋

Preorders always welcomed. Call or message.

Wednesday's SpecialsOpen at 4. Preorders not necessary, but appreciated. * $15 Large, $12 Medium:Italian Stromboli OrCAL...
06/17/2026

Wednesday's Specials
Open at 4. Preorders not necessary, but appreciated.

* $15 Large, $12 Medium:
Italian Stromboli
Or
CALZONE (Plain or with PEPPERONI)

*Buy any Large Pizza, Get $3 off Large Chicken Bites (Plain or Buffalo Chicken)

$5 French Fries

Sunday, open at 4Featured pizza: NY White DeluxeRound, thin crust white pizza (no sauce) topped with broccoli, ricotta a...
06/14/2026

Sunday, open at 4

Featured pizza: NY White Deluxe
Round, thin crust white pizza (no sauce) topped with broccoli, ricotta and tomato
$17 Large 16"
$15 Medium 14"

2 for $20
TWO Large 16" Round, Thin Crust NY Style Pizzas

$11
One NY Style Pizza

Saturday open at 4Call now to schedule your Pick-Up or Delivery time!FEATURED PIZZA: Buffalo Chicken$15 Large NY$20 Whol...
06/13/2026

Saturday open at 4
Call now to schedule your Pick-Up or Delivery time!

FEATURED PIZZA: Buffalo Chicken
$15 Large NY
$20 Whole Tray Old Forge
$14 Half Tray

$9
6 cuts, with or without onion, plain or Sweet sauces

$22.90
Large NY + Large Buffalo Bite

$25
Whole Tray Old Forge + Large NY

Friday Open at 4, pre-orders welcomed! Time slots fill up fast!Specials$9 Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix$96 cuts, with or wit...
06/12/2026

Friday Open at 4, pre-orders welcomed! Time slots fill up fast!

Specials

$9
Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix

$9
6 cuts, with or without onion

$20
Large NY + Small Buffalo Bite

$25
Whole Tray + Large NY

Thursday Specials $9 Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix$25 Whole Tray + Large NY Featured Pizza NY Sweetie Pie with Bacon or Pepp...
06/11/2026

Thursday Specials

$9 Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix

$25 Whole Tray + Large NY

Featured Pizza
NY Sweetie Pie with Bacon or Pepperoni
$15 Large, $13 Medium

Dessert by Sugar & Spice Bakery

Wednesday's Featured Items:*Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix $9*Buffalo Bites, plain or with sauce$11 Large, $7 Small Dessert b...
06/10/2026

Wednesday's Featured Items:

*Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix $9

*Buffalo Bites, plain or with sauce
$11 Large, $7 Small

Dessert by Kailee at Sugar & Spice Bakery. It's called a BROOKIE. Don't know what a brookie is? Well, you'll want to find out!

Open this week Wed - Sun at 4 pm.Wednesday's Featured Items:*Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix $9*Buffalo Bites, plain or with s...
06/09/2026

Open this week Wed - Sun at 4 pm.

Wednesday's Featured Items:

*Cheesy Garlic Dippin Stix $9

*Buffalo Bites, plain or with sauce
$11 Large, $7 Small

Sneak peak at the dessert by Kailee at Sugar & Spice Bakery. It's called a BROOKIE. Don't know what a brookie is? Well, you'll want to find out!

Open today, Sunday at 4, Specials belowIf you do not have power, and want to ensure your pizza delivery, please pre-ord...
06/07/2026

Open today, Sunday at 4, Specials below

If you do not have power, and want to ensure your pizza delivery, please pre-order. Due to local outages, we will likely sell out.

Featured Pizza
$15 Large, $13 Medium
NY Style Pizza topped with Fresh Green Peppers, Onion, Mushrooms and choice of Sausage or Pepperoni. REGULAR SAUCE OR SWEETIE PIE

$9 Cheesy Garlic Stix

Address

5355 Main Road
Sweet Valley, PA
18656

Opening Hours

Wednesday 4pm - 8pm
Thursday 4pm - 8pm
Friday 4pm - 8pm
Saturday 4pm - 8pm
Sunday 4pm - 8pm

Telephone

+15704772022

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Valley Subs Plus posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category