More Than Pudding

More Than Pudding Is it Pudding or Ice Cream? You decide! Premium Dessert and Pudding Shop

Due to family graduation celebrations and the Memorial Day Holiday, More Than Pudding will be closed on Saturday May 23r...
05/22/2026

Due to family graduation celebrations and the Memorial Day Holiday, More Than Pudding will be closed on Saturday May 23rd. We will be open again and ready to serve you on Tuesday May 26!

Introducing the new Monarch Butterfly gourmet lemonade at More Than Pudding! 🦋✨Experience the magic in every sip with th...
05/21/2026

Introducing the new Monarch Butterfly gourmet lemonade at More Than Pudding! 🦋✨
Experience the magic in every sip with this vibrant addition to our brand-new Gourmet Lemonade lineup. This “magical” blend features a mesmerizing mix of butterfly pea flower, zesty lemonade, and sweet peach, all shaken over ice for maximum refreshment.
At More Than Pudding, we are dedicated to crafting “decadent treats that will satisfy every sweet craving”. Our new gourmet lemonades are made with real fruit and premium ingredients, offering the perfect bold and vibrant flavors to pair with our signature frozen custards or massive NY-style cookies.
Why you’ll love the Monarch Butterfly:
Magical Color: Watch the beautiful natural hues of the butterfly pea flower blend with our fresh lemonade.
Vibrant Flavor: A unique tropical profile of peach and citrus.
Antioxidant Rich: Butterfly pea flower is known for being packed with antioxidants.
Stop by our shop at 3020 W Pensacola St in Tallahassee to taste the magic for yourself! We’re open Tuesday through Thursday until 9 PM, and Friday and Saturday until 11 PM.

Introducing the new Monarch Butterfly gourmet lemonade at More Than Pudding! 🦋✨Experience the magic in every sip with th...
05/21/2026

Introducing the new Monarch Butterfly gourmet lemonade at More Than Pudding! 🦋✨
Experience the magic in every sip with this vibrant addition to our brand-new Gourmet Lemonade lineup. This "magical" blend features a mesmerizing mix of butterfly pea flower, zesty lemonade, and sweet peach, all shaken over ice for maximum refreshment.
At More Than Pudding, we are dedicated to crafting "decadent treats that will satisfy every sweet craving". Our new gourmet lemonades are made with real fruit and premium ingredients, offering the perfect bold and vibrant flavors to pair with our signature frozen custards or massive NY-style cookies.
Why you'll love the Monarch Butterfly:
Magical Color: Watch the beautiful natural hues of the butterfly pea flower blend with our fresh lemonade.
Vibrant Flavor: A unique tropical profile of peach and citrus.
Antioxidant Rich: Butterfly pea flower is known for being packed with antioxidants.
Stop by our shop at 3020 W Pensacola St in Tallahassee to taste the magic for yourself! We're open Tuesday through Thursday until 9 PM, and Friday and Saturday until 11 PM.

✨ THE ULTIMATE REFRESHMENT HAS ARRIVED! ✨Just when you thought we couldn't get any sweeter, we kicked it up a notch. Get...
05/20/2026

✨ THE ULTIMATE REFRESHMENT HAS ARRIVED! ✨
Just when you thought we couldn't get any sweeter, we kicked it up a notch. Get ready to treat your tastebuds because our brand-new Gourmet Lemonade lineup is officially here! 🍋🍹
We are serving up bold, vibrant flavors made with real fruit and premium ingredients, shaken over ice for maximum flavor. Whether you want to try one of our curated creations or customize your own, we’ve got your perfect sip waiting.
Here’s a taste of what’s on the menu:
🦋 Monarch Butterfly – A magical blend of butterfly pea flower, lemonade, and peach.
🍓 Strawberry Smash – Fresh strawberries and zesty lemonade with a hint of sweetness.
🥝 Kiwi Berry Splash – Kiwi, lemon, and berries for a bright, tropical twist.
🥭 Mango Dragon Fruit – Mango, dragon fruit, and lemon for the ultimate tropical escape.
🌅 Tropical Sunset – Strawberry, pineapple, and lemon with a stunning sunset swirl.
🌊 Blue Hawaiian – Pineapple and lemon with a splash of coconut bliss.
🎨 MAKE IT YOURS! Choose your base flavor, pack it with your favorite real fruits, and create a masterpiece that is refreshingly you.
📍 Find us at: 3020 W Pensacola St.
☀️ Summer Hours:
Tuesday - Thursday: 12 PM - 9 PM
Friday - Saturday: 12 PM - 11 PM
Closed Sunday & Monday
Stop by today and find your new favorite flavor. Which one are you trying first? Tell us in the comments below! 👇

Happy Sunday! 🍰✨Sundays are made for slowing down, breathing out, and savoring the sweetest moments of life. Whether you...
05/17/2026

Happy Sunday! 🍰✨
Sundays are made for slowing down, breathing out, and savoring the sweetest moments of life. Whether you are curling up with a good book, catching up with loved ones, or simply enjoying some well-deserved quiet time, we hope your day is filled with peace and relaxation.
Take a moment for yourself today. You’ve earned it.
If you are looking to make your afternoon just a little bit sweeter, our signature Tres Leches Bread Pudding is waiting for you. Rich, creamy, and perfectly comforting—it is the ultimate Sunday treat.
How are you relaxing today? Let us know in the comments! 💛

Still need a poundcake for Mother’s Day? We are still taking orders till Friday May 8th for a Saturday pickup. Order onl...
05/06/2026

Still need a poundcake for Mother’s Day? We are still taking orders till Friday May 8th for a Saturday pickup. Order online at www.morethanpuddingcaters.com. If the flavor you want is not listed, submit your request.

Still need a pound cake for Mother’s Day? We are still taking orders till Friday May 8th for a Saturday pickup. Order on...
05/06/2026

Still need a pound cake for Mother’s Day? We are still taking orders till Friday May 8th for a Saturday pickup. Order online at www.morethanpuddingcaters.com. If the flavor you want is not listed, please submit your request.

As summer nears, our hours are changing! ⛱️We’re shortening our schedule for the upcoming season, but the quality you ex...
05/04/2026

As summer nears, our hours are changing! ⛱️We’re shortening our schedule for the upcoming season, but the quality you expect isn't changing a bit. Check out our updated times below and stop by for your favorites!

As Teacher Appreciation Week comes to a close, I would like to take this opportunity to talk about my last donation. My ...
05/02/2026

As Teacher Appreciation Week comes to a close, I would like to take this opportunity to talk about my last donation. My siblings and I are proud alumni of James S. Rickards High, and my children will be graduating from this very school this year! The school looked completely foreign to me as I walked the halls on my way to the teachers' lounge, but the pride I felt was present and strong! My only disappointment is that I didn’t get to meet or see any teachers or administrators to thank them personally for their strong dedication to our children. I hope that this token of my love and appreciation was well received, and I thank you for the honor to serve you! Shakelia Kenon, cuz I hope you got to enjoy some pound cake😘. Rickards High School family, please come visit me at my shop anytime!🥰

The celebration continues! Today I met with the incredible educators at Ruediger Elementary Schoolfor Teacher Appreciati...
04/29/2026

The celebration continues! Today I met with the incredible educators at Ruediger Elementary Schoolfor Teacher Appreciation Week! It is truly an honor to bring joy to members of our community that work so hard for our children! Enjoy your treats team!👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

If you thought our jumbo cookies were a dream, wait until you meet the newest member of the family! 🍌✨Introducing our Ba...
04/28/2026

If you thought our jumbo cookies were a dream, wait until you meet the newest member of the family! 🍌✨
Introducing our Banana Pudding Cookie—a soft, buttery base loaded with white chocolate chips, crunchy vanilla wafers, and that nostalgic banana cream flavor you love. It’s a Southern classic reimagined into the perfect chewy bite. Come grab yours before they’re gone! 🍮🍪

Address

3020 W Pensacola Street
Tallahassee, FL
32304

Opening Hours

Tuesday 12pm - 11pm
Wednesday 12pm - 11pm
Thursday 12pm - 11pm
Friday 12pm - 12am
Saturday 12pm - 12am

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when More Than Pudding posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to More Than Pudding:

Shortcuts

Share

Category