Tulsa Pizza Guy

Tulsa Pizza Guy Reviews of Tulsa Pizza Restaurants

Review  #160Pizza Time - 81st and Memorial 5.6After great reviews seen on Piso's, I was like dang, I need to eat that. T...
05/08/2026

Review #160
Pizza Time - 81st and Memorial
5.6
After great reviews seen on Piso's, I was like dang, I need to eat that. Then I did....smh. It fell below the expectations I had.

Let's start with the sauce. It had a came from a can taste. I've enjoyed pizza sauce that I knew came from a can, but this had....a distinct can flavor that wasn't good. Nothing special there. And the gel layer was not proper so it had a thick slimy texture beneath the cheese and sauce. The pepperoni didn't have a quality flavor either and not in good quantity. Had a cheapness to the flavor like pre sliced grocery store hormel pepperoni. The crust didn't seem properly risen, so it seemed lifeless, lacking flavor. The cheese was in an amount that wasn't desirable and again....had a cheap flavor. It was very hard to pick up a slice and not have the top come off due to overtopping the cheese and center loading. If it was good cheese, I'd say, yes please, overtop that, but it wasn't.

Overall, none of the flavors were really great and they did not work well together. Some basic pizza fundamentals were missing. Perhaps several beers in, it might seem better, but for a sober lunch, it was not great. I will say, it was better when I reheated the leftovers in a skillet. But, this isn't a reheat review. The score is middle of the road. It's a meh.

Eastside Pizza House -OKC7.0Had a real hard time scoring this. Ok, the crust is black because it has activated charcoal ...
04/11/2026

Eastside Pizza House -OKC
7.0

Had a real hard time scoring this.
Ok, the crust is black because it has activated charcoal in it. It did not affect the taste. The crust, chewy, very similar to the texture of LC crazy bread, but denser. There was zero crisp to it. The rim had a garlic butter on it, which I normally don't like but it was nice, not over done. (OKC seems to know how to use garlic butter on crusts better than Tulsa) The sauce was tangy, nice, I hadn't had that in a while. The cheese and pepperoni were good and properly portioned. And Oregano was sprinkled across it adding to the flavor. When you pop the box, the smell of it all was amazing.

When it came to technicals, issues arise. The crust intermingled with the sauce and cheese in zero way. If you picked up the cheese and roni, wiped the sauce with your finger, it was a slick surface that was left unaffected by the upper layers. I've never seen this with any pizza I've ever eaten. And the crust seems to lack "flavor pockets" that most crusts have. Was very odd.

Would I eat this again? Damn straight I would. And the owner was CAF, humble enough to mention other spots to try as well if you are a pizza tourist.

Overall, myself and those who ate this pizza really enjoyed it. Definitely a new experience.

Red Pepper Pizza - OKC6.3Pretty good pizza. Good for maybe birthday parties, etc. It did have some flop but it was kind ...
04/10/2026

Red Pepper Pizza - OKC
6.3

Pretty good pizza. Good for maybe birthday parties, etc. It did have some flop but it was kind of heavy for the crust type. The sauce had a very herby, rustic flavor that was good. The pepperoni flavor was good. Cheese had some pull and tasted well and was in good portion. The crust had an okay flavor but seemed like it could have been risen more. It's gel layer wasn't real great. The rim had a garlic type flavoring to it. I normally don't care for gimmick crust but it wasn't heavy and seemed to work on this pie. Overall, not bad.

The Saucee Sicilian - OKC9.1A Neapolitan pizza that was amazing. Perfect bake. The rim had some crunch yet was soft. The...
04/09/2026

The Saucee Sicilian - OKC
9.1

A Neapolitan pizza that was amazing. Perfect bake. The rim had some crunch yet was soft. The sauce was in very good portion and was not hiding like others tend to do and had a nice robust flavor. The pepperoni had a strong forward flavor, not your cheap pepperoni here. The cheese was in good portioning as well. All of the flavors work well together. Mmmm, was very good. Was a 10", 13$ and came with two meatballs (not pictured).

Bruno's Italian Ristorante - Broken Arrow8.2Best in BA, yep. What a delight to eat. The bake was great, the flavors all ...
03/24/2026

Bruno's Italian Ristorante - Broken Arrow
8.2
Best in BA, yep. What a delight to eat. The bake was great, the flavors all mixed well together. The sauce was slightly less than I'd prefer, but it had a nice herby flavor. Portioning was perfect. The crust was soft, yet firm enough to hold itself up.

God Father's To Go  Gas - Inola0.2Gross. Didn't even finish it. Was slimy on the inside. Not very flavorful. And to be h...
03/23/2026

God Father's To Go Gas - Inola
0.2
Gross. Didn't even finish it. Was slimy on the inside. Not very flavorful. And to be honest, not really even going to waste more time on this review. Blech!

Dough Mama's Pizza and Sandwiches @ Hard Rock Casino - Catoosa6.0Casino's are so gross. But...the food, meh. This was ve...
03/23/2026

Dough Mama's Pizza and Sandwiches @ Hard Rock Casino - Catoosa
6.0
Casino's are so gross. But...the food, meh. This was very cheesy with cheese pull. Bake was good. Gel layer good. But....where was the sauce? When I played "find the sauce" so I could taste it, it wasn't bad, but, it's applied negligently. Could of been better if made better with what they had. But...they didn't. Moving on.

Da Vinci's Italian Restaurant - Claremore8.0One ingredient change and my word, what a score it could have been. Claremor...
02/14/2026

Da Vinci's Italian Restaurant - Claremore
8.0

One ingredient change and my word, what a score it could have been. Claremore is hiding a gem. The crust was baked well, nice undercarriage with char. Was very light. The sauce had a nice hard herb flavor. Portion of sauce was excellent. Cheese worked well with the other ingredients and had a good cheese pull. But....the pepperoni. It had an okay flavor. Touch greasy. Either the pizza is baking faster than the pepperoni needs or, it's just not The pepperoni needed something...quality? More cooking time? But it was the one ingredient that didn't seem to mesh all the way. Still a great pizza though. In fact....I ate the whole 12 inches myself in one setting. Haven't done that in a long time.

Happy Valentine's Day.
02/14/2026

Happy Valentine's Day.

Pizzeria Gusto - OKC9.3150th Review and it is the "Best in Oklahoma" so far. Neapolitan style pizza. Amazing flavor for ...
02/03/2026

Pizzeria Gusto - OKC
9.3
150th Review and it is the "Best in Oklahoma" so far.
Neapolitan style pizza. Amazing flavor for the crust, perfectly baked. They chop the cheese off of a block of cheese, no prepackaged shredded cheese here. The sauce, fantastic. The pepperoni has a nice flavor. Cheese pull on every slice, not just the first slice. All of the flavors go perfectly with each other. Pizzeria Gusto nailed it, no gimmicks here.

Address

Tulsa, OK

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Tulsa Pizza Guy posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category