Pop-Start Pizza

06/04/2026

🍕🔥 PIZZA PEOPLE 🔥🍕

Sun's out. Pizza season is in full effect. Sounds like a good time to attack the mismatch.

📸 Pictured Pie-to-Try: "Mismatch"
🍗 Roasted Chicken
🍯 Sweet & Tangy Carolina BBQ Sauce
🧀 Smoked Mozz
🧅 Onion
🌱 Green Onion
🌶️ Pickled Fresno

This is our take on a classic BBQ Chicken Pizza.

Shaq has a phrase for when a defender gets caught in a mismatch: "BBQ Chicken."

That's when somebody's about to get cooked.

This BBQ Chicken Pizza is attacking the paint all game long.

BBQ Chicken. Bucket after bucket.

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
🚫 No Add-Ons
💻 Online Ordering LIVE
🚗 DoorDash & UberEats (limited radius)
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148
🚗 Street parking + Pick 'n Save lot
♿ Accessible parking available

Online Ordering & Rewards Program Available!

PizzaSeason

05/30/2026

05/17/2026

🚨 HOLIDAY BREAK ANNOUNCEMENT 🚨

Pizza People — we’re taking a quick little pause before the summer chaos kicks into full gear. 🍕☀️

We’ll be closed May 17th – May 25th as we celebrate the wedding of a close friend and give ourselves + our staff a well-earned breather before we lock in for summer service.

We’ll be back to regular hours starting Tuesday, May 26th:
Tuesday – Saturday 11AM – 8PM

We’re sorry for the inconvenience. We’ll definitely miss slinging pies for you, but trust us — we’ll be fully charged and ready to rock when we get back. ❤️

Thank you for all the support, patience, and love you continue to show our little pizza shop.

AND because we hate leaving you hanging…

🚨CONTEST IS CLOSED 🚨
CONGRATULATIONS TO JULIE BROOKS

🎉 $100 POP-START GIFT CARD GIVEAWAY 🎉

TO ENTER:
👉 Follow us
👉 Like this post
👉 Share this post
👉 Tag your pizza crew (each tag = extra entry 👀)
🔥 BONUS ENTRY: Follow us on BOTH Instagram + Facebook

🤑 Winner gets $100 in Pop-Start pizza money.
🍕 You get fed. 🤝 Everybody wins.

We’ll announce the winner when we return from break.
See you soon, pizza people. ❤️🔥

05/16/2026

🍕🔥 PIZZA PEOPLE 🔥🍕

☀️ Sun’s shining, summer’s right around the corner, and we’re soaking up every second of pizza season with you this week — because next week (5/18-5/25) we’ll be CLOSED for a little recharge before the full summer stretch.

We’re gonna miss slinging pies for you, but we’re hyped to come back the following week and ride out the rest of summer:
⏰ Tuesday–Saturday // 11am–8pm

And don’t worry… we’ve got a BIG giveaway post dropping soon to try and make up for our little break 👀

📸 Pictured Pie-to-Try: “NOT Pocket”
🧄 Garlic Cream
🍖 Prosciutto Cotto
🧅 Onion
🧀 Henning’s Onion & Chive Cheddar
🤍 BelGioioso Ricotta
🟡 Parm
✨ Fried Garlic

This one hits like the molten hot ham & cheese pocket of childhood glory you probably burned the roof of your mouth on way too many times.

Creamy. Cheesy. Salty. Comforting. Crispy edges. Big nostalgia energy.

Basically our elevated pizza-shop riff on that freezer aisle legend.

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
🚫 No Add-Ons
💻 Online Ordering LIVE
🚗 DoorDash & UberEats (limited radius)
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148
🚗 Street parking + Pick ’n Save lot
♿ Accessible parking available

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!

05/15/2026

🍕🔥PIZZA PEOPLE 🔥🍕

🚨 BAD BOYS, BAD BOYS… whatcha gonna do when this pie comes for you 🚨🍕

📸 Pictured Pie-to-Try: “BAD BOY” 🧄 Garlic Cream
🍔 Seared Ground Beef 🥓 Nueske’s Bacon
🧅 Caramelized Onions 🧀 BelGioioso Gorgonzola
🟠 Henning’s Cheddar 🥒 Pickles 🌶️ Pickled Jalapeños
🟡 Special Mustard

This one’s our pizza riff on one of our go-to burger orders from Kopp's Frozen Custard — a certified Wisconsin institution and mandatory stop anytime you’re rolling into Milwaukee or headed to a Milwaukee Brewers game.

If you’re into our Smash Mouth pie, this is that same smash burger DNA… just a little edgier. Beef. Bacon. Mustard. Pickles. Jalapeños. Funky cheese. Sweet onions. Total drive-thru outlaw behavior.

Throw on some jorts, run through the streets, and grab this pie.

It’s a real Bad Boy.

👀 We’ve also got a whole new Pie-to-Try lineup rolling into the weekend, so there are plenty of new pies to check out!

⚠️ Heads up: we’ll be closed next week — full details, dates, and a giveaway post dropping soon to give you all the deets.

⏰ NEW HOURS — Tuesday–Saturday 11am–8pm

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
🚫 No Add-Ons
💻 Online Ordering LIVE
🚗 DoorDash & UberEats (limited radius)
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148
🚗 Street parking + Pick ’n Save lot
♿ Accessible parking available

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!

05/14/2026

🍕⭐ PIZZA PEOPLE ⭐🍕

Sun is shining and vibes are high. 😎🍕

📸 Pictured Pie-to-Try: “THE POWER-UP”
🍅 Tomato
🍄 Wild Mushrooms
🍕 Pepperoni
🧀 Onion & Chive Cheddar (Henning Cheese)
🔥 Smoked Mozzarella
🧀 Freshly Shaved Parm (BelGioioso)
🧄 Fried Garlic
🌿 Basil

It’s giving full-on retro platformer energy—like you just hit a question block and unlocked a next-level pizza. Classic red-sauce base, stacked with power-up toppings, and finished with boss-level cheese pulls. One bite and you’re in the Mushroom Kingdom of flavor.

It’s-a delicious.

⏰ NEW HOURS — Tuesday–Saturday 11am–8pm

👀 More menu drops incoming this weekend + announcements + giveaways coming soon

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
🚫 No Add-Ons
💻 Online Ordering LIVE
🚗 DoorDash & UberEats (limited radius)
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148
🚗 Street parking + Pick ’n Save lot
♿ Accessible parking available

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!

05/12/2026

🍕🔥 PIZZA PEOPLE 🔥🍕

📸 Pictured Pie: “NY Marg”
🍅 Tomato
🧀 BelGioioso Mozz Mix & Freshly Shaved Parm
🌿 Basil

Our riff on the classic Margherita—with one foot in Naples and the other in an old-school New York pizza shop. We let our special BelGioioso Mozz Mix do the heavy lifting, then finish it with a heavy portion of freshly shaved BelGioioso Parm and basil for that perfect balance of rich, bright, and nostalgic pizza shop flavor.

Simple. Classic. Iconic for a reason.

⏰ NEW HOURS — Tuesday–Saturday 11am–8pm
👀 Keep an eye out for new menu items dropping...
🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
🚫 No Add-Ons
💻 Online Ordering LIVE
🚗 DoorDash & UberEats (limited radius)
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148
🚗 Street parking + Pick ’n Save lot
♿ Accessible parking available

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!

05/08/2026

🍕🔥 PIZZA PEOPLE 🔥🍕

🎤 Still hungry after Cinco De Mayo? We got your late-night taco craving covered… pizza style 😎🌮🍕

📸 Pictured Pie-to-Try: “Carne A-ZA-Da” 🥩 Marinated Shaved Ribeye 🍋 Lime Crema 🌶️ Poblano Peppers 🧅 Onion 🌿 Cilantro 🔥 Valentina Hot Sauce 🌶️ Pickled Fresno Peppers

If you didn’t get your fill of tacos this week, here’s our riff on a classic Carne Asada street taco—built on a Neapolitan crust and loaded with smoky, tangy, savory flavor in every bite. The ribeye brings the richness, the lime crema cools it down, and the Valentina + Fresno peppers keep things cruising with just the right heat. 🔥

Perfectly paired with a Mexican Coke, Sprite, Topo Chico Ranch Water, or our Mango Seltzer 🍹

👀 Side-to-Try: “POP-In Peppers” 🌶️ Roasted Shish*to Peppers 🧀 BelGioioso Parm 🍋 Lemon 🫒 Olive Oil 🥣 Pop-Sauce Dippie

These smoky little guys bring that medium-to-mild heat… but fair warning: about 1 in 10 comes in HOT 🌋😂 Just dip and POP ‘em in.

⏰ NEW HOURS — Tuesday–Saturday 11am–8pm 👀 Keep an eye out for new menu items dropping...

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
🚫 No Add-Ons
💻 Online Ordering LIVE
🚗 DoorDash & UberEats (limited radius)
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148
🚗 Street parking + Pick ’n Save lot

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!

05/07/2026

🍕🔥 PIZZA PEOPLE 🔥🍕

🎤 Nuthin’ but a Bee Sting, baby…
Just some sweet heat hittin’ smooth all day 😎🔥🍯

📸 Pictured Pie-to-Try: “Nuthin’ But A Bee Sting”
🌶️ Chipotle Garlic Cream
🥓 Nueske’s Beer-Braised Bacon
🧀 Leon’s Bee Sting Cheddar
🧅 Spring Onions
🍯 Hot Honey
🌿 Fennel Pollen

When a local cheese comes packed with this much flavor, we gotta build a pie around it. Leon’s Bee Sting Cheddar brings that perfect balance of creamy, smoky, sweet heat—and we layered it up with beer-braised bacon, chipotle garlic cream, and hot honey to let it ride.

Smooth like a springtime cruise with the windows down… then the heat kicks in on the back end. This one’s straight-up flavor bumpin’. 🔥🎶

⏰ NEW HOURS — Tuesday–Saturday 11am–8pm
👀 Keep an eye out for new menu items dropping...

🔥 Dine-In or Carry Out
🚫 No Add-Ons
💻 Online Ordering LIVE
🚗 DoorDash & UberEats (limited radius)
📍 1033 22nd St, Two Rivers, WI
📱 (274) 202-1148
🚗 Street parking + Pick ’n Save lot
♿ Accessible parking available

Online Orders & Rewards Program Available!