Sugar Mill Bakery & Cafe

Sugar Mill Bakery & Cafe Made from scratch bakery utilizing local farms, farmers markets and vendors for the freshest ingredients. Catering, pick-up, and walk-in available.

Orders can be placed at: [email protected] or
814-330-5213

Only two days left to preorder for Friday June 19th. Cinnamon rolls are going fast!
06/17/2026

Only two days left to preorder for Friday June 19th. Cinnamon rolls are going fast!

Pre order menu for Friday June 19th.
06/16/2026

Pre order menu for Friday June 19th.

06/14/2026

Here is the pre-order menu for Friday, June 19th.

1. Rocky Road Cinnamon Rolls
2. Pecan Sticky Buns
3. Plain Sticky Buns
4. Banana Cake w/Salted Caramel Cream Cheese Icing
5. Apple Dumplings
6. Fudge Rounds
7. Peanut Butter Fudge Rounds
9. Chocolate Chip Cookies

Looking ahead to 4th of July weekend, some items available for pre-order are:

1. "The Viral" Dot Cakes
2. 9" Apple, Blueberry, or Cherry Pies
3. Assorted Brownies
4. Sugar Cookies with red/white/blue icing

06/09/2026

Just a reminder, we are closed this week. The menu for the following week is not out yet, however, we've had multiple requests for apple dumplings and banana cake with salted caramel cream cheese icing, so those will definitely be available.

Pre ordering is open for those two items for Friday June 19th and Sunday June 21st.

06/07/2026

June 7th, 2026
Last update of the night, 5:00.

8 Dirt N Worms Cookies
6 Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
5 Assorted Cupcakes

SOLD OUT: Apple Dumplings, Blueberry Coffee Cake, Bomb Pop Cookies and Banana Cake.

Food Left:
5 subs
5 Cheesesteaks
3 Chicken Parm Subs or Chicken Parm Pizzas
3 Pizzas
6 Stromboli

SOLD OUT: Mac N Cheese

06/07/2026

Cheesesteaks and chicken parm subs have been going like crazy today. About 12 left!

We will also have cupcakes in the case today.Vanilla with buttercream, chocolate with peanut butter, vanilla cupcakes wi...
06/07/2026

We will also have cupcakes in the case today.

Vanilla with buttercream, chocolate with peanut butter, vanilla cupcakes with peanut butter icing and caramel drizzle and vanilla cupcakes with peanut butter and strawberry swirl icing.

Menu for today, Sunday June 7th.Apple dumplings are all sold out already.Reminder, we are closed next week, so get your ...
06/07/2026

Menu for today, Sunday June 7th.

Apple dumplings are all sold out already.

Reminder, we are closed next week, so get your goodies today.

If you are headed to the lake and need sandwiches, let us know. We had to make bread early today for sandwich trays, so we can have subs ready any time. Shoot us a message or respond to post.

Pre order menu for Sunday, June 7th.Banana cake with salted caramel cream cheese icing sold out in 30 minutes yesterday,...
06/06/2026

Pre order menu for Sunday, June 7th.

Banana cake with salted caramel cream cheese icing sold out in 30 minutes yesterday, so we recommend pre ordering that!

06/05/2026

All sold out! See you Sunday!

Address

3209 S. 4th Street
Tyrone, PA
16686

Opening Hours

Friday 11am - 8pm
Sunday 11am - 7pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Sugar Mill Bakery & Cafe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Sugar Mill Bakery & Cafe:

Shortcuts

Share

Category